Tight Quantum Lower Bound for Approximate Counting with Quantum States

We prove tight lower bounds for the following variant of the counting problem considered by Aaronson et al. The task is to distinguish whether an input set $x\subseteq [n]$ has size either $k$ or $k'=(1+\epsilon)k$. We assume the algorithm has access to * the membership oracle, which, for each $i\in [n]$, can answer whether $i\in x$, or not; and * the uniform superposition $|\psi_x\rangle = \sum_{i\in x} |i\rangle/\sqrt{|x|}$ over the elements of $x$. Moreover, we consider three different ways how the algorithm can access this state: ** the algorithm can have copies of the state $|\psi_x\rangle$; ** the algorithm can execute the reflecting oracle which reflects about the state $|\psi_x\rangle$; ** the algorithm can execute the state-generating oracle (or its inverse) which performs the transformation $|0\rangle\mapsto |\psi_x\rangle$. Without the second type of resources (related to $|\psi_x\rangle$), the problem is well-understood, see Brassard et al. The study of the problem with the second type of resources was recently initiated by Aaronson et al. We completely resolve the problem for all values of $1/k \le \epsilon\le 1$, giving tight trade-offs between all types of resources available to the algorithm. Thus, we close the main open problems from Aaronson et al. The lower bounds are proven using variants of the adversary bound by Belovs and employing analysis closely related to the Johnson association scheme.