The Charr Problem Revisited: Exceptional Phenotypic Plasticity Promotes Ecological Speciation in Postglacial Lakes

Abstract The salmonid arctic charr Salvelinus alpinus (L.) is one of the most widespread fishes in the world and is found farther north than any other freshwater or diadromous fish, but also in cool water farther south. It shows a strong phenotypic, ecological, and life history diversity throughout its circumpolar range. One particular side of this diversity is the frequent occurrence of two or more distinct charr morphs in the same lake. This polymorphism has been termed ‘the charr problem’. Similar cases are found in other postglacial fishes, but not with the extent and diversity as with the arctic charr. This review first treats the classical case, pioneered in an advanced way by Winifred Frost, of autumn and winter spawning charr in Windermere, England, and three other cases that have received much research interest in recent years: Thingvallavatn, Iceland; Loch Rannoch, Scotland; and Fjellfrøsvatn, Norway. Then a special kind of sympatry with one morph living permanently in the profundal zone, known from a few lakes in Europe, Russia and Canada and unique for arctic charr among postglacial fishes, is reviewed. Among them is a recently discovered charr at 450 m depth in Tinnsjøen, Norway, one of the few very deep lakes in the world. With examples, the concluding discussion focuses on the variation of arctic charr polymorphisms which extends from early stages of ecological segregation to cases of reproductive isolation and speciation; and on models to explain the charr problem. The exceptional diversity of arctic charr provides a unique potential for further progress in studies on ecologically driven evolution within the frames of modern theory of developmental plasticity, adaptive radiation and adaptive speciation.

[1]  W. E. Frost.  Some observations on the biology of the char, Salvelinus willughbii Gunther, of Windermere , 1950 .

[2]  A. Quartier.  Morphologie et biologie de Salvelinus alpinus dans le lac de Neuchâtel , 1951 .

[3]  J. Mcphail.  A Systematic Study of the Salvelinus alpinus Complex in North America , 1961 .

[4]  W. E. Frost.  The homing of charr Salvelinus willughbii (Günther) in Windermere , 1963 .

[5]  W. E. Frost.  Breeding habits of Windermere charr, Salvelinus willughbii (Günther), and their bearing on speciation of these fish , 1965, Proceedings of the Royal Society of London. Series B. Biological Sciences.

[6]  Food and habitat segregation by two sympatric Arctic Char populations: With 1 figure and 3 tables in the text , 1975 .

[7]  C. Kipling,et al.  The growth of charr, Salvelinus willughbii Günther, in Windermere , 1977 .

[8]  S. Gould,et al.  Ontogeny and Phylogeny , 1978 .

[9]  K. Hindar,et al.  Habitat and Food Segregation of Dwarf and Normal Arctic Charr (Salvelinus alpinus) from Vangsvatnet Lake, Western Norway , 1982 .

[10]  K. Hindar,et al.  Reproductive Strategy of Dwarf and Normal Arctic Charr (Salvelinus alpinus) from Vangsvatnet Lake, Western Norway , 1982 .

[11]  L. Johnson.  Homeostatic Characteristics of Single Species Fish Stocks in Arctic Lakes , 1983 .

[12]  H. Nordeng.  Solution to the "Char problem" based on Arctic char (Salvelinus alpinus) in Norway , 1983 .

[13]  A. R. Child.  Biochemical polymorphism in charr (Salvelinus alpinus L.) From three cumbrian lakes , 1984, Heredity.

[14]  K. Hindar,et al.  Genetic differentiation among local populations and morphotypes of Arctic Charr, Salvelinus alpinus , 1986 .

[15]  C. A. Mills,et al.  An electrophoretic and biometric study of Arctic charr, Salvelinm alpinus (L.), from ten British lakes , 1988 .

[16]  R. Greer,et al.  Morphometric analysis of two ecologically distinct forms of Arctic charr, Salvelinus alpinus (L.), in Loch Rannoch, Scotland , 1988 .

[17]  R. Greer,et al.  Two ecologically distinct forms of arctic charr Salvelinus alpinus (L.) in Loch Rannoch, Scotland , 1988 .

[18]  S. Gould.  Wonderful Life: The Burgess Shale and the Nature of History , 1989 .

[19]  M. West-Eberhard.  Phenotypic Plasticity and the Origins of Diversity , 1989 .

[20]  Mitochondrial DNA Variation among Anadromous Populations of Cisco (Coregonus artedii) as revealed by Restriction Analysis , 1990 .

[21]  I. Näslund.  The development of regular seasonal habitat shifts in a landlocked Arctic charr, Salvelinus alpinus L., population , 1990 .

[22]  D. Noakes,et al.  Mitochondrial DNA diversity among four sympatric morphs of Arctic charr, Salvelinus alpinus L., from Thingvallavatn, Iceland , 1991 .

[23]  L. Bernatchez,et al.  PHYLOGEOGRAPHIC STRUCTURE IN MITOCHONDRIAL DNA OF THE LAKE WHITEFISH (COREGONUS CLUPEAFORMIS) AND ITS RELATION TO PLEISTOCENE GLACIATIONS , 1991, Evolution; international journal of organic evolution.

[24]  J. Taggart,et al.  Genetic differentiation among the sympatric brown trout (Salmo trutta) populations of Lough Melvin, Ireland , 1991 .

[25]  K. Magnússon,et al.  The Arctic Charr Salvelinus alpinus in Thingvallavatn , 1992 .

[26]  J. M. Elliott,et al.  Long-term and short-term fluctuations in the numbers and catches of Arctic charr, Salvelinus alpinus (L.), in Windermere (northwest England) , 1992 .

[27]  B. Jonsson,et al.  Diet Differentiation in Polymorphic Arctic Charr in Thingvallavatn, Iceland , 1992 .

[28]  C. Mcgowan,et al.  The genetics of sympatric Arctic charr [Salvelinus alpinus (L.)] populations from Loch Rannoch, Scotland , 1992 .

[29]  D. Noakes,et al.  Genetically based differences in foraging behaviour among sympatric morphs of arctic charr (Pisces: Salmonidae) , 1993, Animal Behaviour.

[30]  J. M. Elliott,et al.  The effect of large‐scale spatial variation of pelagic fish on hydroacoustic estimates of their population density in Windermere (northwest England) , 1993 .

[31]  J. M. Elliott,et al.  Racial differences in eggs and juveniles of Windermere charr, Salvelinus alpinus , 1994 .

[32]  L. Jørgensen,et al.  Influence of Parr Growth, Lake Morphology, and Freshwater Parasites on the Degree of Anadromy in Different Populations of Arctic Char (Salvelinus alpinus) in Northern Norway , 1994 .

[33]  T. G. Heggberget,et al.  Growth and Sex Distribution in an Anadromous Population of Arctic Char in Northern Norway , 1994 .

[34]  Odd Terje Sandlund,et al.  Trophic specialization in Arctic charr Salvelinus alpinus (Pisces; Salmonidae): morphological divergence and ontogenetic niche shifts , 1994 .

[35]  J. Thorpe.  Reproductive strategies in Atlantic salmon, Salmo salar L. , 1994 .

[36]  J. Reist,et al.  Evidence for two morphotypes of Arctic char (Salvelinus alpinus (L.)) from Lake Hazen, Ellesmere Island, Northwest Territories, Canada , 1995 .

[37]  K. Hindar,et al.  Effects of acidification on normal and dwarf arctic charr Salvelinus alpinus (L.) in a norwegian lake , 1995 .

[38]  T. B. Smith,et al.  Resource polymorphisms in vertebrates. , 1995, Trends in ecology & evolution.

[39]  J. Reist,et al.  Phylogeography and postglacial dispersal of arctic charr Salvelinus alpinus in North America , 1996 .

[40]  D. Noakes,et al.  Genetic basis of life history variations among sympatric morphs of arctic char, Salvelinus alpinus. , 1996 .

[41]  J. Volpe,et al.  Molecular genetic examination of the polymorphic Arctic charr Salvelinus alpinus of Thingvallavatn, Iceland , 1996, Molecular ecology.

[42]  D. P. Fey,et al.  Migrations in an extreme northern population of Arctic charr Salvelinus alpinus: insights from otolith microchemistry , 1996 .

[43]  Skúli Skúlason,et al.  EVOLUTIONARY SIGNIFICANCE OF RESOURCE POLYMORPHISMS IN FISHES, AMPHIBIANS, AND BIRDS , 1996 .

[44]  J. M. Elliott,et al.  Changes in the population density of pelagic salmonids in relation to changes in lake enrichment in Windermere (northwest England) , 1996 .

[45]  P. Amundsen,et al.  Parasite communities in two sympatric morphs of Arctic charr, Salvelinus alpinus (L.), in northern Norway. , 1997 .

[46]  S. Alekseev,et al.  A NEW FORM OF CHARR, SALVELINUS ALPINUS (SALMONIDAE), FROM LAKE DAVATCHAN IN TRANSBAIKALIA AND ITS MORPHOLOGICAL DIFFERENCES FROM SYMPATRIC FORMS , 1998 .

[47]  J. E. Stacy,et al.  Genetic evidence for different migration routes of freshwater fish into Norway revealed by analysis of current perch (Perca fluviatilis) populations in Scandinavia , 1998, Molecular ecology.

[48]  Scott Roberts,et al.  The fish , 1998, SIGGRAPH '98.

[49]  F. Huntingford,et al.  Trophic polymorphism amongst Arctic charr from Loch Rannoch, Scotland , 1998 .

[50]  L. Bernatchez,et al.  Microsatellite gene diversity analysis in anadromous arctic char, Salvelinus alpinus, from Labrador, Canada , 1998 .

[51]  Continental rifting and habitat formation. Arena for ressource polymorphism in Arctic Charr , 1998 .

[52]  An experimental comparison of cannibalistic response in different Arctic charr (Salvelinus alpinus (L.)) stocks , 1999 .

[53]  J. García-Marín,et al.  Postglacial colonization of brown trout in Europe based on distribution of allozyme variants , 1999, Heredity.

[54]  K. Jakobsen,et al.  Genetic divergence and phylogeographic relationships among European perch (Perca fluviatilis) populations reflect glacial refugia and postglacial colonization , 1999, Molecular ecology.

[55]  S. Skúlason,et al.  Heterochrony in skeletal development and body size in progeny of two morphs of Arctic charr from Thingvallavatn, Iceland , 1999 .

[56]  D. Gíslason,et al.  Rapid and coupled phenotypic and genetic divergence in Icelandic Arctic char (Salvelinus alpinus) , 1999 .

[57]  H. J. Malmquist,et al.  Biodiversity of macroinvertebrates on rocky substrate in the surf zone of Icelandic lakes , 2000 .

[58]  J. M. Elliott,et al.  Variations in juvenile growth, energy allocation and life-history strategies of two populations of Arctic charr in North Norway , 2000 .

[59]  J. Hammar.  Cannibals and parasites: conflicting regulators of bimodality in high latitude Arctic char, Salvelinus alpinus , 2000 .

[60]  A. Finstad,et al.  Production and predation rates in a cannibalistic Arctic char (Salvelinus alpinus L.) population , 2001 .

[61]  Nina Jonsson,et al.  Polymorphism and speciation in Arctic charr , 2001 .

[62]  L. Bernatchez,et al.  HOLARCTIC PHYLOGEOGRAPHY OF ARCTIC CHARR (SALVELINUS ALPINUS L.) INFERRED FROM MITOCHONDRIAL DNA SEQUENCES , 2001, Evolution; international journal of organic evolution.

[63]  J. M. Elliott,et al.  A comparison of three methods for assessing the abundance of Arctic charr, Salvelinus alpinus, in Windermere (northwest England) , 2001 .

[64]  G. Turner.  The Ecology of Adaptive Radiation , 2001, Heredity.

[65]  T. Storebakken,et al.  Atlantic Salmon, Salmo Salar , 2002 .

[66]  F. Huntingford,et al.  Inherited differences in head allometry in polymorphic Arctic charr from Loch Rannoch, Scotland , 2002 .

[67]  J. M. Elliott,et al.  Evidence for genetic differences in the offspring of two sympatric morphs of Arctic charr , 2002 .

[68]  Nina Jonsson,et al.  Atlantic salmon Salmo salar L., brown trout Salmo trutta L. and Arctic charr Salvelinus alpinus (L.): a review of aspects of their life histories , 2003 .

[69]  S. Alekseyev,et al.  Diversification, Sympatric Speciation, and Trophic Polymorphism of Arctic Charr, Salvelinus Alpinus Complex, in Transbaikalia , 2002, Environmental Biology of Fishes.

[70]  K. Gunnarsson,et al.  Alternative mating tactics of arctic charr, Salvelinus alpinus, in Thingvallavatn, Iceland , 1989, Environmental Biology of Fishes.

[71]  F. Huntingford,et al.  Incipient speciation driven by phenotypic plasticity? Evidence from sympatric populations of Arctic charr , 2004 .

[72]  P. Amundsen,et al.  Takvatn Through 20 Years: Long-term Effects of an Experimental Mass Removal of Arctic Charr, Salvelinus Alpinus, From a Subarctic Lake , 2002, Environmental Biology of Fishes.

[73]  S. Skúlason,et al.  Adaptive Speciation: Adaptive Speciation in Northern Freshwater Fishes , 2004 .

[74]  H. Rundle,et al.  Natural selection and ecological speciation in sticklebacks , 2004 .

[75]  I. Folstad,et al.  Lek fidelity of male Arctic charr , 2004 .

[76]  H. J. Malmquist.  Phenotype-specific feeding behaviour of two arctic charr Salvelinus alpinus morphs , 1992, Oecologia.

[77]  K. Magnússon,et al.  Genetic analysis of four sympatric morphs of Arctic charr, Salvelinus alpinus, from Thingvallavatn, Iceland , 1987, Environmental Biology of Fishes.

[78]  J. Dempson,et al.  The Biology of Arctic Charr, Salvelinus Alpinus, of Gander Lake, A Large, Deep, Oligotrophic Lake in Newfoundland, Canada , 2002, Environmental Biology of Fishes.

[79]  Ulf Dieckmann,et al.  Adaptive Speciation , 2004 .

[80]  F. Huntingford,et al.  The functional significance of inherited differences in feeding morphology in a sympatric polymorphic population of Arctic charr , 2004, Evolutionary Ecology.

[81]  D. Fraser,et al.  A stable isotope analysis of trophic polymorphism among Arctic charr from Loch Ericht, Scotland , 2004 .

[82]  D. Gíslason,et al.  Population genetic structure of Arctic Charr, Salvelinus alpinus from northwest Europe on large and small spatial scales , 2004, Molecular ecology.

[83]  R. Knudsen,et al.  Genetic differences between two sympatric morphs of Arctic charr confirmed by microsatellite DNA , 2004 .

[84]  Walter Carl Hartwig,et al.  Life's solution: Inevitable humans in a lonely universe , 2004 .

[85]  P. Gowaty.  Developmental Plasticity and Evolution Mary Jane West-Eberhard , 2005, Animal Behaviour.

[86]  M. Power,et al.  Ecological segregation within and among Arctic char morphotypesin Gander Lake, Newfoundland , 2005, Environmental Biology of Fishes.

[87]  R. Borgstrøm,et al.  Cannibalism in Arctic charr: do all individuals have the same propensity to be cannibals? , 2005 .

[88]  C. Adams,et al.  Does Breeding Site Fidelity Drive Phenotypic and Genetic Sub-Structuring of a Population of Arctic Charr? , 2005, Evolutionary Ecology.

[89]  Parallel Evolution, not Always so Parallel: Comparison of Small Benthic Charr, Salvelinus alpinus, from Grímsnes and Thingvallavatn, Iceland , 2005, Environmental Biology of Fishes.

[90]  M. Power,et al.  Ecology and Trophic Relationships of the Fishes of Gander Lake, a Large, Deep, Oligotrophic Lake in Newfoundland, Canada , 2005 .

[91]  M. Kottelat,et al.  Salvelinus evasus sp. n., a charr from deep waters of Lake Ammersee, southern Germany (Teleostei: Salmonidae), with comments on two extinct species , 2005 .

[92]  M. West-Eberhard,et al.  Developmental plasticity and the origin of species differences , 2005, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[93]  D. Noakes,et al.  Segregation in spawning and early life history among polymorphic Arctic charr, Salvelinus alpinus, in Thingvallavatn, Iceland , 2006 .

[94]  P. Byström.  Recruitment pulses induce cannibalistic giants in Arctic char. , 2006, The Journal of animal ecology.

[95]  R. Primicerio,et al.  Divergent, genetically based feeding behaviour of two sympatric Arctic charr, Salvelinus alpinus (L.), morphs , 2006 .

[96]  京都大学附属図書館,et al.  Systema naturae（自然の体系） , 2006 .

[97]  A. N. Matveev,et al.  The second population of Arctic charr Salvelinus alpinus complex (Salmoniformes, Salmonidae) in the Lake Baikal basin, the highest mountain charr population in Russia , 2006, Journal of Ichthyology.

[98]  P. Amundsen,et al.  Incipient speciation through niche expansion: an example from the Arctic charr in a subarctic lake , 2006, Proceedings of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[99]  J. B. James,et al.  The Arctic charr (Salvelinus alpinus) populations of Windermere, UK: population trends associated with eutrophication, climate change and increased abundance of roach (Rutilus rutilus) , 2008, Environmental Biology of Fishes.

[100]  C. Adams,et al.  Patterns of phenotypic and genetic variability show hidden diversity in Scottish Arctic charr , 2007 .

[101]  P. Amundsen,et al.  Seasonal and ontogenetic variations in resource use by two sympatric Arctic charr morphs , 2008, Environmental Biology of Fishes.

[102]  I. Winfield,et al.  Assessment of long-term changes in habitat availability for Arctic charr (Salvelinus alpinus) in a temperate lake using oxygen profiles and hydroacoustic surveys , 2007 .

[103]  V. Brykov,et al.  Divergence of Salvelinus species from northeastern Asia based on mitochondrial DNA , 2007 .

[104]  P. Maitland,et al.  Arctic charr in Britain and Ireland – 15 species or one? , 2007 .

[105]  Seasonal variability in the abundance of Arctic charr (Salvelinus alpinus (L.)) recorded using hydroacoustics in Windermere, UK and its implications for survey design , 2007 .

[106]  Lennart Persson,et al.  Culling Prey Promotes Predator Recovery — Alternative States in a Whole-Lake Experiment , 2022 .

[107]  R. Primicerio,et al.  Contrasting niche-based variation in trophic morphology within Arctic charr populations , 2007 .

[108]  P. Maitland,et al.  The status of Arctic charr Salvelinus alpinus in Britain and Ireland , 2007 .

[109]  M. Kottelat,et al.  Handbook of European freshwater fishes , 2007 .

[110]  C. Adams,et al.  Parallel divergence of sympatric genetic and body size forms of Arctic charr, Salvelinus alpinus, from two Scottish lakes , 2008 .

[111]  A. Phan,et al.  MH class IIα polymorphism in local and global adaptation of Arctic charr (Salvelinus alpinus L.) , 2008, Immunogenetics.

[112]  C. T. Regan,et al.  The Freshwater Fishes Of The British Isles , 2008 .

[113]  F. Huntingford,et al.  Foraging specialisms, prey size and life‐history patterns: a test of predictions using sympatric polymorphic Arctic charr (Salvelinus alpinus) , 2008 .

[114]  D. Gomez-Uchida,et al.  Genetic divergence between sympatric Arctic charr Salvelinus alpinus morphs in Gander Lake, Newfoundland: roles of migration, mutation and unequal effective population sizes , 2008 .

[115]  D. Noakes.  2006 International Charr Symposium, Reykjavik, Iceland , 2008, Environmental Biology of Fishes.

[116]  A. D. de Roos,et al.  The Effect of Population Size and Recombination on Delayed Evolution of Polymorphism and Speciation in Sexual Populations , 2008, The American Naturalist.

[117]  M. Power,et al.  Fish in high-latitude Arctic lakes , 2008 .

[118]  A. N. Matveev,et al.  Phylogeography and sympatric differentiation of the Arctic charr Salvelinus alpinus (L.) complex in Siberia as revealed by mtDNA sequence analysis. , 2009, Journal of fish biology.

[119]  R. Ricklefs,et al.  Adaptation and diversification on islands , 2009, Nature.

[120]  R. Primicerio,et al.  Temporal stability of individual feeding specialization may promote speciation. , 2010, The Journal of animal ecology.

[121]  Arctic Charr ( Salvelinus alpinus ) in Windermere (Cumbria) , 2010 .

[122]  S. Einum,et al.  Reproductive Ecology: A Tale of Two Sexes , 2010 .

[123]  J. Richardson,et al.  Fauna boreali-Americana , 2011 .

[124]  M. Power,et al.  Determining the consistency of thermal habitat segregation within and among Arctic charr morphotypes in Gander Lake, Newfoundland , 2012 .