Comparative evaluation of published real-time PCR assays for the detection of malaria following MIQE guidelines

BackgroundThe use of malaria-specific quantitative real-time PCR (qPCR) is increasing due to its high sensitivity, speciation and quantification of malaria parasites. However, due to the lack of consensus or standardized methods in performing qPCR, it is difficult to evaluate and/or compare the quality of work reported by different authors for a cross-study and/or cross-platform assay analysis.MethodsThe performances of seven published qPCR assays that detect Plasmodium spp or Plasmodium falciparum were compared using standard DNA and samples from a clinical trial. Amplification and qPCR measurements were performed using the Applied Biosystems 7500 Fast Real-Time PCR System. All the analyses were automatically established using the default settings. For the TaqMan probe format, the assays were performed in the background of QuantiFast Probe Master Mix whereas in SYBR Green format, the assays were performed in the background of QuantiFast SYBR Green Master Mix and QuantiTect SYBR Green Master Mix background.ResultsAssays with high PCR efficiencies outperformed those with low efficiencies in all categories including sensitivity, precision and consistency regardless of the assay format and background. With the exception of one assay, all assays evaluated showed lower sensitivity compared to what have been published. When samples from a malaria challenge study were analysed, the qPCR assay with the overall best performance detected parasites in subjects earliest and with most consistency.ConclusionThe data demonstrate the need for increased consensus and guidelines that will encourage better experimental practices, allowing more consistent and unambiguous interpretation of qPCR results.

[1]  D Payne,et al.  Use and limitations of light microscopy for diagnosing malaria at the primary health care level. , 1988, Bulletin of the World Health Organization.

[2]  G. Snounou,et al.  The importance of sensitive detection of malaria parasites in the human and insect hosts in epidemiological studies, as shown by the analysis of field samples from Guinea Bissau. , 1993, Transactions of the Royal Society of Tropical Medicine and Hygiene.

[3]  K. Kain,et al.  Imported malaria: prospective analysis of problems in diagnosis and management. , 1998, Clinical infectious diseases : an official publication of the Infectious Diseases Society of America.

[4]  R Heinrich,et al.  Mathematical modelling of the within-host dynamics of Plasmodium falciparum , 2000, Parasitology.

[5]  E. Linders,et al.  Detection of Plasmodium falciparum malaria parasites in vivo by real-time quantitative PCR. , 2001, Molecular and biochemical parasitology.

[6]  K. Kain,et al.  Impact of microscopy error on estimates of protective efficacy in malaria-prevention trials. , 2002, The Journal of infectious diseases.

[7]  C. Tang,et al.  Real-Time Fluorescence-Based PCR for Detection of Malaria Parasites , 2002, Journal of Clinical Microbiology.

[8]  G. Dettori,et al.  Identification of Plasmodium falciparum, P. vivax, P. ovale and P. malariae and detection of mixed infection in patients with imported malaria in Italy. , 2003, The new microbiologica.

[9]  P. Chiodini,et al.  Use of a rapid, single-round, multiplex PCR to detect malarial parasites and identify the species present , 2003, Annals of tropical medicine and parasitology.

[10]  G. Snounou,et al.  Development of a Real-Time PCR Assay for Detection of Plasmodium falciparum, Plasmodium vivax, and Plasmodium ovale for Routine Clinical Diagnosis , 2004, Journal of Clinical Microbiology.

[11]  K. Jaton,et al.  Detection of Four Plasmodium Species in Blood from Humans by 18S rRNA Gene Subunit-Based and Species-Specific Real-Time PCR Assays , 2004, Journal of Clinical Microbiology.

[12]  S. D. de Vlas,et al.  Testing vaccines in human experimental malaria: statistical analysis of parasitemia measured by a quantitative real-time polymerase chain reaction. , 2004, The American journal of tropical medicine and hygiene.

[13]  D. Webster,et al.  Calculation of liver-to-blood inocula, parasite growth rates, and preerythrocytic vaccine efficacy, from serial quantitative polymerase chain reaction studies of volunteers challenged with malaria sporozoites. , 2005, The Journal of infectious diseases.

[14]  P. Wilkins,et al.  PCR as a Confirmatory Technique for Laboratory Diagnosis of Malaria , 2006, Journal of Clinical Microbiology.

[15]  C. Wongsrichanalai,et al.  Reader technique as a source of variability in determining malaria parasite density by microscopy , 2006, Malaria Journal.

[16]  B. Ogutu,et al.  Establishing a malaria diagnostics centre of excellence in Kisumu, Kenya , 2007, Malaria Journal.

[17]  J. Sattabongkot,et al.  Comparison of PCR and microscopy for the detection of asymptomatic malaria in a Plasmodium falciparum/vivax endemic area in Thailand , 2006, Malaria Journal.

[18]  K. Kain,et al.  Advances in malaria diagnosis , 2007, Expert review of anti-infective therapy.

[19]  A. Heath,et al.  Establishment of the 1st World Health Organization International Standard for Plasmodium falciparum DNA for nucleic acid amplification technique (NAT)-based assays , 2008, Malaria Journal.

[20]  R. Fabre,et al.  PCR-based methods to the diagnosis of imported malaria. , 2008, Parasite.

[21]  K. Marsh,et al.  Report of a consultation on the optimization of clinical challenge trials for evaluation of candidate blood stage malaria vaccines, 18-19 March 2009, Bethesda, MD, USA. , 2009, Vaccine.

[22]  Chris J Drakeley,et al.  Submicroscopic infection in Plasmodium falciparum-endemic populations: a systematic review and meta-analysis. , 2009, The Journal of infectious diseases.

[23]  B. Carme,et al.  Multiplex real-time PCR detection of P. falciparum, P. vivax and P. malariae in human blood samples. , 2009, Experimental parasitology.

[24]  V. Beneš,et al.  The MIQE guidelines: minimum information for publication of quantitative real-time PCR experiments. , 2009, Clinical chemistry.

[25]  R. Sauerwein,et al.  Experimental human challenge infections can accelerate clinical malaria vaccine development , 2010, Nature Reviews Immunology.

[26]  C. Ockenhouse,et al.  Development of a Highly Sensitive Genus-Specific Quantitative Reverse Transcriptase Real-Time PCR Assay for Detection and Quantitation of Plasmodium by Amplifying RNA and DNA of the 18S rRNA Genes , 2011, Journal of Clinical Microbiology.

[27]  O. Cabaret,et al.  Cytochrome b Gene Quantitative PCR for Diagnosing Plasmodium falciparum Infection in Travelers , 2011, Journal of Clinical Microbiology.