The Effect of Spatial and Temporal Heterogeneity on the Design and Analysis of Empirical Studies of Scale‐Dependent Systems

Processes interacting across scales of space and time influence emergent patterns in ecological systems, but to obtain strong inference and empirical generalities, ecologists need to balance reality with the practicalities of design and analyses. This article discusses heterogeneity, scaling, and design analysis problems and offers potential solutions to improve empirically based research. In particular, we recommend bridging the dichotomy between correlative and manipulative studies by nesting manipulative studies within a correlative framework. We suggest that building on variation, by designing studies to detect variability, rather than fighting it often leads to an increase in generality. We also emphasize the importance of natural history information for determining likely scales of spatial and temporal heterogeneity and the probable occurrence of feedback loops, indirect effects, and interacting processes. Finally, we integrate these concepts and suggest planned iterations between multiscale studies to build up natural history information and test the strength of relationships across space and time. This offers a way forward in terms of heuristically developing models and determining ecological generalities.

[1]  Christoffer Boström,et al.  Recruitment and population maintenance of the bivalve Macoma balthica (L) - Factors affecting settling success and early survival on shallow sandy bottoms , 1995 .

[2]  Paul J. Somerfield,et al.  A comparison of the power of categorical and correlational tests applied to community ecology data from gradient studies , 2002 .

[3]  Stephen P. Hubbell,et al.  Species‐Area Curves, Diversity Indices, and Species Abundance Distributions: A Multifractal Analysis , 2002, The American Naturalist.

[4]  S. Carpenter,et al.  Ecological forecasts: an emerging imperative. , 2001, Science.

[5]  L. Hedges,et al.  Meta-analysis: Combining the results of independent experiments , 1993 .

[6]  A. B. Hill.  The Environment and Disease: Association or Causation? , 1965, Proceedings of the Royal Society of Medicine.

[7]  David C. Schneider,et al.  Matching the outcome of small-scale density manipulation experiments with larger scale patterns: an example of bivalve adult/juvenile interactions , 1997 .

[8]  M. Hodda,et al.  Variation in estuarine littoral nematode populations over three spatial scales. , 1990 .

[9]  R. Callaway,et al.  Abiotic Stress and the Relative Importance of Interference and Facilitation in Montane Bunchgrass Communities in Western Montana , 1996, The American Naturalist.

[10]  DAVID SCHNEIDER,et al.  Equalisation of prey numbers by migratory shorebirds , 1978, Nature.

[11]  G A Fox,et al.  Practical causal inference for ecoepidemiologists. , 1991, Journal of toxicology and environmental health.

[12]  F. H. Rigler,et al.  Recognition of the Possible: An Advantage of Empiricism in Ecology , 1982 .

[13]  P. Chesson,et al.  Scaling up population dynamics: integrating theory and data , 2005, Oecologia.

[14]  Pierre Legendre,et al.  Integrating heterogeneity across spatial scales: interactions between Atrina zelandica and benthic macrofauna , 2002 .

[15]  P. Herman,et al.  Multi-scale analysis of species-environment relationships , 2005 .

[16]  Robert D. Holt,et al.  RESOLVING ECOLOGICAL QUESTIONS THROUGH META‐ANALYSIS: GOALS, METRICS, AND MODELS , 1999 .

[17]  Lauri Oksanen,et al.  Logic of experiments in ecology: is pseudoreplication a pseudoissue? , 2001 .

[18]  Brian D. Inouye,et al.  THE IMPORTANCE OF THE VARIANCE AROUND THE MEAN EFFECT SIZE OF ECOLOGICAL PROCESSES: COMMENT , 2005 .

[19]  B. Cade,et al.  Estimating effects of limiting factors with regression quantiles , 1999 .

[20]  Michael Elliott.  Detecting ecological impacts: Concepts and applications in coastal habitats , 1997 .

[21]  Pierre Legendre,et al.  Nonlinear foraging response of a large marine predator to benthic prey: eagle ray pits and bivalves in a New Zealand sandflat , 1997 .

[22]  Robert V. O'Neill,et al.  IS IT TIME TO BURY THE ECOSYSTEM CONCEPT? (WITH FULL MILITARY HONORS, OF COURSE!)1 , 2001 .

[23]  S. Levin.  THE PROBLEM OF PATTERN AND SCALE IN ECOLOGY , 1992 .

[24]  M. Tegner,et al.  TEMPORAL AND SPATIAL SCALES OF KELP DEMOGRAPHY: THE ROLE OF OCEANOGRAPHIC CLIMATE , 1999 .

[25]  Enric Sala,et al.  Natural History: the sense of wonder, creativity and progress in ecology* , 2001 .

[26]  Glenn De'ath,et al.  IDENTIFYING ECOLOGICAL CHANGE AND ITS CAUSES: A CASE STUDY ON CORAL REEFS , 2004 .

[27]  R. O'Neill,et al.  Ecological Society of America IS IT TIME TO BURY THE ECOSYSTEM CONCEPT ? ( WITH FULL MILITARY HONORS , OF COURSE ! ) , 2001 .

[28]  B. Cade,et al.  QUANTILE REGRESSION REVEALS HIDDEN BIAS AND UNCERTAINTY IN HABITAT MODELS , 2005 .

[29]  Simon F. Thrush,et al.  Variable effect of a large suspension-feeding bivalve on infauna: experimenting in a complex system , 2001 .

[30]  C. Smith,et al.  The effects of patch size and substrate isolation on colonization modes and rates in an intertidal sediment , 1989 .

[31]  Erik Bonsdorff,et al.  Population responses of coastal zoobenthos to stress induced by drifting algal mats , 1996 .

[32]  JAMES R. MILLER,et al.  Spatial Extrapolation: The Science of Predicting Ecological Patterns and Processes , 2004 .

[33]  Erik Bonsdorff,et al.  Drifting algae and zoobenthos — Effects on settling and community structure , 1992 .

[34]  Daniel Simberloff,et al.  Community Ecology: Is It Time to Move On? , 2004, The American Naturalist.

[35]  L. Benedetti‐Cecchi.  The importance of the variance around the mean effect size of ecological processes , 2003 .

[36]  D. R. Strong,et al.  Density-vague population change. , 1986, Trends in ecology & evolution.

[37]  E. Maggi,et al.  INTERACTIVE EFFECTS OF SPATIAL VARIANCE AND MEAN INTENSITY OF GRAZING ON ALGAL COVER IN ROCK POOLS , 2005 .

[38]  P. Legendre,et al.  Partialling out the spatial component of ecological variation , 1992 .

[39]  Francis Juanes,et al.  INFERRING ECOLOGICAL RELATIONSHIPS FROM THE EDGES OF SCATTER DIAGRAMS: COMPARISON OF REGRESSION TECHNIQUES , 1998 .

[40]  D. J. Futumya,et al.  Wherefore and whither the naturalist? , 1998, The American naturalist.

[41]  Gordon A. Robilliard,et al.  Biological Accommodation in the Benthic Community at McMurdo Sound, Antarctica , 1974 .

[42]  H. Stommel,et al.  Varieties of Oceanographic Experience , 1963 .

[43]  Simon F. Thrush,et al.  Adult/juvenile interactions of infaunal bivalves: contrasting outcomes in different habitats , 1996 .

[44]  E. Bonsdorff,et al.  Drifting algal mats as an alternative habitat for benthic invertebrates: Species specific responses to a transient resource. , 2000, Journal of experimental marine biology and ecology.

[45]  J. Bruno,et al.  Inclusion of facilitation into ecological theory , 2003 .

[46]  Karl Cottenie,et al.  Comment to Oksanen (2001): reconciling Oksanen (2001) and Hurlbert (1984) , 2003 .

[47]  Lawrence B. Slobodkin,et al.  A Critique for Ecology , 1991 .

[48]  D. A. Perry,et al.  Self-organizing systems across scales. , 1995, Trends in ecology & evolution.

[49]  Simon F. Thrush,et al.  Scale-Dependent Recolonization: The Role of Sediment Stability in a Dynamic Sandflat Habitat , 1996 .

[50]  H. Stommel,et al.  Varieties of Oceanographic Experience: The ocean can be investigated as a hydrodynamical phenomenon as well as explored geographically. , 1963, Science.

[51]  Jessica Gurevitch,et al.  Ecography 25: 601 -- 615, 2002 , 2022 .

[52]  Uta Berger,et al.  Pattern-Oriented Modeling of Agent-Based Complex Systems: Lessons from Ecology , 2005, Science.

[53]  Julian D. Olden,et al.  Torturing data for the sake of generality: How valid are our regression models? , 2000 .

[54]  Anthony W King,et al.  Aggregating Fine-Scale Ecological Knowledge to Model Coarser-Scale Attributes of Ecosystems. , 1992, Ecological applications : a publication of the Ecological Society of America.

[55]  J. Platt.  Strong Inference , 2007 .

[56]  Erik Bonsdorff,et al.  Altered Benthic Prey‐Availability Due to Episodic Oxygen Deficiency Caused by Drifting Algal Mats , 1996 .

[57]  Annamarie Hatcher,et al.  Variation in the components of Benthic community structure in a Coastal Lagoon as a function of Spatial Scale , 1989 .

[58]  Simon F. Thrush,et al.  The importance of predators on a sandflat: interplay between seasonal changes in prey densities and predator effects , 1994 .

[59]  R. Rosenthal.  Meta-analytic procedures for social research , 1984 .

[60]  G. Belovsky,et al.  Ten Suggestions to Strengthen the Science of Ecology , 2004 .

[61]  Paul K Dayton,et al.  The Importance of the Natural Sciences to Conservation , 2003, The American Naturalist.

[62]  Donald L. DeAngelis,et al.  UNCERTAINTY IN SPATIALLY EXPLICIT ANIMAL DISPERSAL MODELS , 2003 .

[63]  Roy A. Walters,et al.  Scale-up of ecological experiments: Density variation in the mobile bivalve Macomona liliana , 1997 .

[64]  Göran Englund,et al.  The importance of data-selection criteria: meta-analyses of stream predation experiments , 1999 .

[65]  Simon F. Thrush,et al.  THE GENERALITY OF FIELD EXPERIMENTS: INTERACTIONS BETWEEN LOCAL AND BROAD-SCALE PROCESSES , 2000 .

[66]  Simon A. Levin,et al.  2 – Concepts of Scale at the Local Level , 1993 .

[67]  Pierre Legendre,et al.  Identifying relationships between adult and juvenile bivalves at different spatial scales , 1997 .

[68]  J. Lawton.  Are there general laws in ecology , 1999 .

[69]  M. Bertness,et al.  Positive interactions in communities. , 1994, Trends in ecology & evolution.

[70]  Johan van de Koppel,et al.  Self‐Organization and Vegetation Collapse in Salt Marsh Ecosystems , 2004, The American Naturalist.

[71]  C. McCulloch,et al.  Quantitative Ecology: Spatial and Temporal Scaling , 1995 .

[72]  Jay T. Lennon,et al.  Knowing when to draw the line: designing more informative ecological experiments , 2005 .

[73]  J. Bence,et al.  TEMPORAL AND SPATIAL VARIATION IN ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACT ASSESSMENT , 2001 .

[74]  David C. Schneider,et al.  Spatial structure of bivalves in a sandflat:: Scale and generating processes , 1997 .

[75]  J. Lawton,et al.  Linking Species and Ecosystems , 1996 .

[76]  M Susser,et al.  Rules of inference in epidemiology. , 1986, Regulatory toxicology and pharmacology : RTP.

[77]  Jessica Gurevitch,et al.  EFFECTS OF SPATIAL STRUCTURES ON THE RESULTS OF FIELD EXPERIMENTS , 2004 .

[78]  L. L. Eberhardt,et al.  Designing Environmental Field Studies , 1991 .

[79]  Peter M. J. Herman,et al.  Spatial and temporal variation in benthic macrofauna and relationships with environmental variables in an estuarine, intertidal soft-sediment environment , 2002 .

[80]  Joe N. Perry,et al.  A method of estimating the slope of upper bounds of plots of body size and abundance in natural animal assemblages , 1992 .

[81]  David C. Schneider,et al.  Multiscale experimental analysis of aggregative responses of mobile predators to infaunal prey , 1997 .

[82]  Craig W. Osenberg,et al.  Detecting Ecological Impacts Caused by Human Activities , 1996 .

[83]  Alan D. Ansell,et al.  Biology and ecology of Shallow coastal waters , 1997 .

[84]  J. Platt.  Strong Inference: Certain systematic methods of scientific thinking may produce much more rapid progress than others. , 1964, Science.

[85]  J. Wiens.  Spatial Scaling in Ecology , 1989 .

[86]  Katherine L. Gross,et al.  WHAT IS THE OBSERVED RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN SPECIES RICHNESS AND PRODUCTIVITY , 2001 .

[87]  S. D. Cooper,et al.  Scale effects and extrapolation in ecological experiments , 2003 .

[88]  Laurent Seuront,et al.  Handbook of Scaling Methods in Aquatic Ecology: Measurement, Analysis, Simulation , 2007 .

[89]  Simon F. Thrush,et al.  MACROBENTHIC RECOVERY PROCESSES FOLLOWING CATASTROPHIC SEDIMENTATION ON ESTUARINE SANDFLATS , 2003 .

[90]  Susan S. Bell,et al.  Toward a landscape approach in seagrass beds: using macroalgal accumulation to address questions of scale , 1995, Oecologia.

[91]  Simon F. Thrush,et al.  Emergence and floating behaviours of post‐settlement juveniles of Macomona liliana (Bivalvia: Tellinacea) , 1993 .

[92]  Underwood,et al.  Observations in ecology: you can't make progress on processes without understanding the patterns. , 2000, Journal of experimental marine biology and ecology.

[93]  Vonda J. Cummings,et al.  ASSESSING ENVIRONMENTAL IMPACTS: EFFECTS OF SPATIAL AND TEMPORAL VARIABILITY AT LIKELY IMPACT SCALES , 2001 .

[94]  Paul A. Keddy,et al.  Working with Heterogeneity: An Operator’s Guide to Environmental Gradients , 1991 .

[95]  Simon F. Thrush,et al.  Benthic faunal responses to variations in patch density and patch size of a suspension-feeding bivalve , 1997 .

[96]  Lisandro Benedetti Cecchi,et al.  The importance of the variance around the mean effect size of ecological processes: reply , 2005 .

[97]  P. Legendre.  Spatial Autocorrelation: Trouble or New Paradigm? , 1993 .

[98]  James P. Barry,et al.  Physical Heterogeneity and the Organization of Marine Communities , 1991 .

[99]  Jianguo Wu,et al.  Multiscale Analysis of Landscape Heterogeneity: Scale Variance and Pattern Metrics , 2000, Ann. GIS.

[100]  L. R. Taylor,et al.  Aggregation, Variance and the Mean , 1961, Nature.

[101]  David C. Schneider,et al.  Quantitative Ecology: Spatial and Temporal Scaling , 1994 .

[102]  S. Levin.  The problem of pattern and scale in ecology , 1992 .

[103]  Marti J. Anderson,et al.  Partitioning the variation among spatial, temporal and environmental components in a multivariate data set , 1998 .

[104]  Erik Bonsdorff,et al.  Rapid zoobenthic community responses to accumulations of drifting algae , 1996 .

[105]  M. Tegner,et al.  SLIDING BASELINES, GHOSTS, AND REDUCED EXPECTATIONS IN KELP FOREST COMMUNITIES , 1998 .

[106]  A. King.  Translating models across scales in the landscape , 1991 .

[107]  Meike J. Wittmann,et al.  Mathematical Ecology , 2006 .

[108]  D. DeAngelis,et al.  Equilibrium and Nonequilibrium Concepts in Ecological Models , 1987 .

[109]  Craig W. Osenberg,et al.  META‐ANALYSIS OF MARINE NUTRIENT‐ENRICHMENT EXPERIMENTS: VARIATION IN THE MAGNITUDE OF NUTRIENT LIMITATION , 1999 .

[110]  R. O'Neill.  A Hierarchical Concept of Ecosystems. , 1986 .

[111]  Thomas R Anderson,et al.  Metabolic Stoichiometry and the Fate of Excess Carbon and Nutrients in Consumers , 2004, The American Naturalist.

[112]  David C. Schneider,et al.  The role of fluid dynamics in the ecology of marine birds , 1991 .

[113]  Simon F. Thrush,et al.  Assessing the short‐term stability of spatial patterns of macrobenthos in a dynamic estuarine system , 1997 .

[114]  Mark W. Denny,et al.  QUANTIFYING SCALE IN ECOLOGY: LESSONS FROM AWAVE-SWEPT SHORE , 2004 .

[115]  Pierre Legendre,et al.  Untangling Multiple Factors in Spatial Distributions: Lilies, Gophers, and Rocks , 1996 .

[116]  E. Berlow,et al.  The Keystone Species Concept: Variation in Interaction Strength in a Rocky Intertidal Habitat , 1994 .

[117]  David C. Schneider,et al.  Evaluation of a gradient sampling design for environmental impact assessment , 1997 .

[118]  Erik Bonsdorff,et al.  Structuring zoobenthos: the importance of predation, siphon cropping and physical disturbance , 1995 .

[119]  Erik Bonsdorff,et al.  Life in the fast lane: macrobenthos use temporary drifting algal habitats , 2005 .