Reply to "Comment on 'Operational Earthquake Forecasting: Status of Knowledge and Guidelines for Implementation by Jordan et al. [2011]' by Stuart Crampin"

In his commentary on the International Commission on Earthquake Forecasting (ICEF) report [Jordan et al. 2011], Crampin [2012] claims that observable changes in shear-wave splitting can predict large earthquakes on short time scales with high reliability and skill, and he challenges a central ICEF finding—that no method has yet demonstrated such a predictive capability. In particular, Crampin asserts that "observations of seismic shear-wave splitting monitored at a three-borehole Stress-Monitoring Site (SMS) in central Italy could monitor stress-accumulation and stress-relaxation (crack-coalescence) before all damaging (M ≥ 5) earthquakes within 1000 km of the SMS […] This means that installation of one expensive SMS (preferably two throughout the length of Italy) would stress-forecast the time, magnitude, and in some circumstances fault-break of all potentially damaging on the mainland of Italy". Crampin's assertions are based on prediction methods he has advocated for several decades [e.g., Crampin et al. 1984; Crampin et al. 1990]. As part of the ICEF study, we reviewed the literature on these methods. Nothing contained in the present commentary compels us to alter our previous findings. [...]

[1]  Matthew C. Gerstenberger,et al.  New Zealand Earthquake Forecast Testing Centre , 2010 .

[2]  Ian Main,et al.  A statistical evaluation of a ‘stress‐forecast’ earthquake , 2004 .

[3]  S. Crampin,et al.  Comment on "systematic analysis of shear-wave splitting in the aftershock zone of the 1999 Chi-Chi, Taiwan, earthquake: Shallow crustal anisotropy and lack of precursory changes, by Yungfeng Liu, Ta-Liang Teng, and Yehuda Ben-Zion" , 2005 .

[4]  M. Savage,et al.  Shear wave anisotropy and stress direction in and near Long Valley Caldera, California, 1979–1988 , 1990 .

[5]  Y. Ben‐Zion,et al.  Spatiotemporal variations of crustal anisotropy from similar events in aftershocks of the 1999 M7.4 İzmit and M7.1 Düzce, Turkey, earthquake sequences , 2005 .

[6]  Jon B. Fletcher,et al.  Changes in shear wave splitting at Anza near the time of the North Palm Springs Earthquake , 1990 .

[7]  P. Shearer,et al.  Reply [to “Comment on ‘Quantitative measurements of shear wave polarizations at the Anza Seismic Network, southern California: Implications for shear wave splitting and earthquake prediction’ by Richard C. Aster, Peter M. Shearer, and Jon Berger”] , 1991 .

[8]  Thomas H. Jordan,et al.  Operational Earthquake Forecasting: Some Thoughts on Why and How , 2010 .

[9]  S. Crampin.  Comment on the report "Operational Earthquake Forecasting " by the International Commission on Earthquake Forecasting for Civil Protection , 2012 .

[10]  P. Okubo,et al.  Crustal shear wave anisotropy in southern Hawaii: Spatial and temporal analysis , 1995 .

[11]  Philip J. Maechling,et al.  The Collaboratory for the Study of Earthquake Predictability perspective on computational earthquake science , 2010 .

[12]  Y. Ben‐Zion,et al.  Systematic Analysis of Shear-Wave Splitting in the Aftershock Zone of the 1999 Chi-Chi, Taiwan, Earthquake: Shallow Crustal Anisotropy and Lack of Precursory Variations , 2004 .

[13]  Richard W. Byrne,et al.  Reply to Thornton & McAuliffe (2012) , 2012, Animal Behaviour.

[14]  Theodora Volti,et al.  A successfully stress-forecast earthquake , 1999 .

[15]  T. Jordan.  Earthquake Predictability, Brick by Brick , 2006 .

[16]  S J Chaconas,et al.  A statistical evaluation of nasal growth. , 1969, American journal of orthodontics.

[17]  Report of the International Commission on Earthquake Forecasting for Civil Protection (Invited) , 2009 .

[18]  T. Jordan,et al.  A second Opinion on “ Operational Earthquake forecasting : some Thoughts on Why and How , ” by , 2011 .

[19]  A. Ryall,et al.  S-wave splitting: Key to earthquake prediction? , 1974, Bulletin of the Seismological Society of America.

[20]  Naoshi Hirata,et al.  Overview of the first earthquake forecast testing experiment in Japan , 2011 .

[21]  T. Jordan,et al.  Reply to `A Second Opinion on “Operational Earthquake Forecasting: Some Thoughts on Why and How,” by Thomas H. Jordan and Lucile M. Jones,' by Stuart Crampin , 2011 .

[22]  J. B. Fletcher,et al.  Comment on “Quantitative measurements of shear wave polarizations at the Anza Seismic Network, southern California: Implications for shear wave splitting and earthquake prediction” by Richard C. Aster, Peter M. Shearer, and Jon Berger , 1991 .

[23]  R. Evans,et al.  Earthquake prediction: a new physical basis , 1984 .

[24]  Peter M. Shearer,et al.  Quantitative measurements of shear wave polarizations at the Anza Seismic Network, southern California: Implications for shear wave splitting and earthquake prediction , 1990 .

[25]  S. Crampin.  A Second Opinion on “Operational Earthquake Forecasting: Some Thoughts on Why and How,” by Thomas H. Jordan and Lucile M. Jones , 2011 .