Evolution and development of the primate limb skeleton

The order Primates is composed of many closely related lineages, each having a relatively well established phylogeny supported by both the fossil record and molecular data. 1 Primate evolution is characterized by a series of adaptive radiations beginning early in the Cenozoic era. Studies of these radiations have uncovered two major trends. One is that substantial amounts of morphological diversity have been produced over short periods of evolutionary time. 2 The other is that consistent and repeated patterns (variational tendencies 3 ) are detected. Taxa within clades, such as the strepsirrhines of Madagascar and the platyrrhines of the Neotropics, have diversified in body size, substrate preference, and diet. 2 , 4–6 The diversification of adaptive strategies within such clades is accompanied by repeated patterns of change in cheiridial proportions 7 , 8 (Fig. 1) and tooth‐cusp morphology. 9 There are obvious adaptive, natural‐selection based explanations for these patterns. The hands and feet are in direct contact with a substrate, so their form would be expected to reflect substrate preference, whereas tooth shape is related directly to the functional demands of masticating foods having different mechanical properties. What remains unclear, however, is the role of developmental and genetic processes that underlie the evolutionary diversity of the primate body plan. Are variational tendencies a signature of constraints in developmental pathways? What is the genetic basis for similar morphological transformations among closely related species? These are a sampling of the types of questions we believe can be addressed by future research integrating evidence from paleontology, comparative morphology, and developmental genetics.

[1]  M. Purugganan,et al.  Accelerated regulatory gene evolution in an adaptive radiation , 2001, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[2]  H. F. Nijhout,et al.  Metaphors and the role of genes in development. , 1990, BioEssays : news and reviews in molecular, cellular and developmental biology.

[3]  G. von Dassow,et al.  Modularity in animal development and evolution: elements of a conceptual framework for EvoDevo. , 1999, The Journal of experimental zoology.

[4]  M. Goodman,et al.  Embryonic ε and γ globin genes of a prosimian primate (Galago crassicaudatus): Nucleotide and amino acid sequences, developmental regulation and phylogenetic footprints , 1988 .

[5]  M. Capecchi,et al.  Absence of radius and ulna in mice lacking hoxa-11 andhoxd-11 , 1995, Nature.

[6]  C. Tickle,et al.  A model for anteroposterior patterning of the vertebrate limb based on sequential long- and short-range Shh signalling and Bmp signalling. , 2000, Development.

[7]  J. Martín,et al.  Paired-related homeobox genes cooperate in handplate and hindlimb zeugopod morphogenesis. , 1999, Developmental biology.

[8]  R. Krumlauf Hox genes in vertebrate development , 1994, Cell.

[9]  S. Brenner,et al.  Detecting conserved regulatory elements with the model genome of the Japanese puffer fish, Fugu rubripes. , 1995, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[10]  D. Kingsley,et al.  GDF5 coordinates bone and joint formation during digit development. , 1999, Developmental biology.

[11]  B. Shea Ontogenetic Allometry and Scaling , 1985 .

[12]  R. Oliva,et al.  Identification of conserved potentially regulatory sequences of the SRY gene from 10 different species of mammals. , 1998, Biochemical and biophysical research communications.

[13]  B. Wood,et al.  Soft-tissue characters in higher primate phylogenetics. , 2000, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[14]  K. Umesono,et al.  Activin and its receptors during gastrulation and the later phases of mesoderm development in the chick embryo. , 1995, Developmental biology.

[15]  M. Goodman,et al.  Model for the fetal recruitment of simian gamma-globin genes based on findings from two New World monkeys Cebus apella and Callithrix jacchus (Platyrrhini, Primates). , 1999, The Journal of experimental zoology.

[16]  R. Hardison Conserved noncoding sequences are reliable guides to regulatory elements. , 2000, Trends in genetics : TIG.

[17]  Z B Zeng,et al.  Estimating the genetic architecture of quantitative traits. , 1999, Genetical research.

[18]  C. Tabin,et al.  Analysis of Hoxd-13 and Hoxd-11 misexpression in chick limb buds reveals that Hox genes affect both bone condensation and growth. , 1997, Development.

[19]  G. Wagner,et al.  Evolution of Hoxa-11 in lineages phylogenetically positioned along the fin-limb transition. , 2000, Molecular phylogenetics and evolution.

[20]  M. Hamrick Development and evolution of the mammalian limb: adaptive diversification of nails, hooves, and claws , 2001, Evolution & development.

[21]  H. Iba,et al.  Misexpression of Hoxa-13 induces cartilage homeotic transformation and changes cell adhesiveness in chick limb buds. , 1995, Genes & development.

[22]  P. Sharpe,et al.  Developmental genetics and early hominid craniodental evolution , 2001, BioEssays : news and reviews in molecular, cellular and developmental biology.

[23]  A. Leroi The scale independence of evolution , 2000, Evolution & development.

[24]  M. Ravosa Allometry and heterochrony in extant and extinct Malagasy primates , 1992 .

[25]  M. Capecchi,et al.  A mutational analysis of the 5' HoxD genes: dissection of genetic interactions during limb development in the mouse. , 1996, Development.

[26]  C. Groves,et al.  Toward a phylogenetic classification of Primates based on DNA evidence complemented by fossil evidence. , 1998, Molecular phylogenetics and evolution.

[27]  P. Garber,et al.  Adaptive Radiations of Neotropical Primates , 1996, Springer US.

[28]  D. Huylebroeck,et al.  Follistatins neutralize activin bioactivity by inhibition of activin binding to its type II receptors , 1996, Molecular and Cellular Endocrinology.

[29]  Bret J. Pearson,et al.  Recruitment of a hedgehog regulatory circuit in butterfly eyespot evolution. , 1999, Science.

[30]  G. Church,et al.  Microarray analysis of the transcriptional network controlled by the photoreceptor homeobox gene Crx , 2000, Current Biology.

[31]  J. True,et al.  Developmental system drift and flexibility in evolutionary trajectories , 2001, Evolution & development.

[32]  J. Jernvall Linking development with generation of novelty in mammalian teeth. , 2000, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[33]  R. Dahn,et al.  Interdigital regulation of digit identity and homeotic transformation by modulated BMP signaling. , 2000, Science.

[34]  Craig Nelson,et al.  Hox genes and the evolution of vertebrate axial morphology. , 1995, Development.

[35]  F. Ruddle,et al.  An efficient cis-element discovery method using multiple sequence comparisons based on evolutionary relationships. , 2001, Genomics.

[36]  D. Duboule,et al.  A molecular approach to the evolution of vertebrate paired appendages. , 1996, Trends in ecology & evolution.

[37]  J. Rodríguez-León,et al.  Control of digit formation by activin signalling. , 1999, Development.

[38]  Denis Duboule,et al.  Hox genes in digit development and evolution , 1999, Cell and Tissue Research.

[39]  J. Jernvall,et al.  The hypocone as a key innovation in mammalian evolution. , 1995, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[40]  P. Ahlberg,et al.  The origin and early diversification of tetrapods , 1994, Nature.

[41]  T. Lufkin,et al.  Transcriptional control of Hox genes in the vertebrate nervous system. , 1996, Current opinion in genetics & development.

[42]  S. Carroll,et al.  Fossils, genes and the evolution of animal limbs , 1997, Nature.

[43]  Günter P. Wagner,et al.  Developmental evolution as a mechanistic science: the inference from developmental mechanisms to evolutionary processes , 2000 .

[44]  A. Kuroiwa,et al.  Homeobox gene expression correlated with the bifurcation process of limb cartilage development , 1991, Nature.

[45]  M. Cohn,et al.  Developmental basis of limblessness and axial patterning in snakes , 1999, Nature.

[46]  C. Tabin,et al.  Analysis of Hox gene expression in the chick limb bud. , 1996, Development.

[47]  Y. Hérault,et al.  Hox gene expression in limbs: colinearity by opposite regulatory controls. , 1999, Developmental biology.

[48]  G. Wagner,et al.  The tetrapod limb: a hypothesis on its origin. , 2001, The Journal of experimental zoology.

[49]  W. Miller,et al.  Comparison of five methods for finding conserved sequences in multiple alignments of gene regulatory regions. , 1999, Nucleic acids research.

[50]  Gerd B. Müller,et al.  Homology, Hox Genes, and Developmental Integration , 1996 .

[51]  J. I. Izpisúa Belmonte,et al.  Limbs are moving: where are they going? , 1998, Trends in genetics : TIG.

[52]  P. Gruss,et al.  The establishment of murine Hox-1 expression domains during patterning of the limb. , 1993, Developmental biology.

[53]  K Ikeo,et al.  Pax 6: mastering eye morphogenesis and eye evolution. , 1999, Trends in genetics : TIG.

[54]  K. Patel,et al.  Tbx genes and limb identity in chick embryo development. , 1998, Development.

[55]  D. Duboule,et al.  Transgenic analysis of a potential Hoxd-11 limb regulatory element present in tetrapods and fish. , 1996, Developmental biology.

[56]  A. Sidow,et al.  Diversification of the Wnt gene family on the ancestral lineage of vertebrates. , 1992, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[57]  S. Brenner,et al.  The conserved role of Krox-20 in directing Hox gene expression during vertebrate hindbrain segmentation. , 1996, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[58]  C Kappen,et al.  Two steps in the evolution of Antennapedia-class vertebrate homeobox genes. , 1989, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[59]  E. Lewis A gene complex controlling segmentation in Drosophila , 1978, Nature.

[60]  J. Greer,et al.  Maintenance of functional equivalence during paralogous Hox gene evolution , 2000, Nature.

[61]  A. Simeone Otx1 and Otx2 in the development and evolution of the mammalian brain , 1998, The EMBO journal.

[62]  M. Cohn,et al.  Morphological analysis of the mammalian postcranium: a developmental perspective. , 1999, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[63]  Ginés Morata,et al.  Conserved regulation of proximodistal limb axis development by Meis1/Hth , 1999, Nature.

[64]  F. Ruddle,et al.  Combinations of closely situated cis-acting elements determine tissue-specific patterns and anterior extent of early Hoxc8 expression. , 1996, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[65]  J. Capdevila,et al.  23 – Perspectives on the Evolutionary Origin of Tetrapod Limbs , 2000 .

[66]  S. Keränen,et al.  Evolutionary modification of development in mammalian teeth: quantifying gene expression patterns and topography. , 2000, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[67]  Brian T. Shea,et al.  Heterochrony in Primates , 1988 .

[68]  M. Goodman,et al.  Phylogenetic footprinting reveals unexpected complexity in trans factor binding upstream from the epsilon-globin gene. , 1993, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[69]  D. Duboule,et al.  The Art of Making a Joint , 2001, Science.

[70]  D. Stern PERSPECTIVE: EVOLUTIONARY DEVELOPMENTAL BIOLOGY AND THE PROBLEM OF VARIATION , 2000, Evolution; international journal of organic evolution.

[71]  F. Ruddle,et al.  Modification of expression and cis-regulation of Hoxc8 in the evolution of diverged axial morphology. , 1998, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[72]  M. Goodman,et al.  Dynamics of regulatory evolution in primate β-globin gene clusters: cis- mediated aquisition of simian γ fetal expression patterns , 1997 .

[73]  R. Hinchliffe,et al.  Developmental Approaches to the Problem of Transformation of Limb Structure in Evolution , 1991 .

[74]  Christine Hartmann,et al.  Wnt-14 Plays a Pivotal Role in Inducing Synovial Joint Formation in the Developing Appendicular Skeleton , 2001, Cell.

[75]  D. Stern A role of Ultrabithorax in morphological differences between Drosophila species , 1998, Nature.

[76]  G. Wagner,et al.  Heterochronic differences of Hoxa-11 expression in Xenopus fore- and hind limb development: Evidence for lower limb identity of the anuran ankle bones , 1998, Development Genes and Evolution.

[77]  J. W. Pendleton,et al.  Expansion of the Hox gene family and the evolution of chordates. , 1993, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[78]  M. Hamrick Primate origins: evolutionary change in digital ray patterning and segmentation. , 2001, Journal of human evolution.

[79]  P. Brown,et al.  Out on a limb. , 1998, The Journal of hand surgery.

[80]  M. Laubichler Review of: Carroll, Sean B., Jennifer K. Grenier and Scott D. Weatherbee: From DNA to diversity : molecular genetics and the evolution of animal design. Malden, Mass [u.a.]: Blackwell Science 2001 , 2003 .

[81]  E. Olson,et al.  The bHLH transcription factor dHAND controls Sonic hedgehog expression and establishment of the zone of polarizing activity during limb development. , 2000, Development.

[82]  S. Carroll Homeotic genes and the evolution of arthropods and chordates , 1995, Nature.

[83]  PERSPECTIVE: EVOLUTIONARY DEVELOPMENTAL BIOLOGY AND THE PROBLEM OF VARIATION , 2000 .

[84]  C. Abate-Shen,et al.  Roles for Msx and Dlx homeoproteins in vertebrate development. , 2000, Gene.

[85]  M. Goodman,et al.  Evolution of a Fetal Expression Pattern via cisChanges near the γ Globin Gene* , 1997, The Journal of Biological Chemistry.

[86]  L. Almasy,et al.  Quantitative trait linkage mapping in anthropology. , 1999, American journal of physical anthropology.

[87]  W Miller,et al.  Locus control regions of mammalian beta-globin gene clusters: combining phylogenetic analyses and experimental results to gain functional insights. , 1997, Gene.

[88]  Kurt Wüthrich,et al.  Homeodomain-DNA recognition , 1994, Cell.

[89]  M. Hamrick Pattern and process in the evolution of primate nails and claws. , 1999, Journal of human evolution.

[90]  N. M. Huber Ponderal index and height. , 1969, American journal of physical anthropology.

[91]  D. Duboule,et al.  Regulation of number and size of digits by posterior Hox genes: a dose-dependent mechanism with potential evolutionary implications. , 1997, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[92]  E. Davidson,et al.  Modular cis-regulatory organization of developmentally expressed genes: two genes transcribed territorially in the sea urchin embryo, and additional examples. , 1996, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[93]  H. Jung,et al.  Genotype, phenotype, and developmental biology of molar tooth characters. , 2000, American journal of physical anthropology.

[94]  M. Purugganan The molecular evolution of development , 1998, BioEssays : news and reviews in molecular, cellular and developmental biology.

[95]  R. Carroll,et al.  Towards a new evolutionary synthesis. , 2000, Trends in ecology & evolution.

[96]  M. McCollum The robust australopithecine face: a morphogenetic perspective. , 1999, Science.

[97]  I. S. Kathiriya,et al.  Role of dHAND in the anterior-posterior polarization of the limb bud: implications for the Sonic hedgehog pathway. , 2000, Development.

[98]  K. Glander,et al.  Relative growth of the limbs and trunk in sifakas: heterochronic, ecological, and functional considerations. , 1993, American journal of physical anthropology.

[99]  B. Shea Relative growth of the limbs and trunk in the African apes. , 1981, American journal of physical anthropology.

[100]  R. Raff,et al.  Resynthesizing evolutionary and developmental biology. , 1996, Developmental biology.

[101]  F. Ruddle,et al.  Comparative studies on mammalian Hoxc8 early enhancer sequence reveal a baleen whale-specific deletion of a cis-acting element. , 1998, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[102]  P Chambon,et al.  Hoxa-13 and Hoxd-13 play a crucial role in the patterning of the limb autopod. , 1996, Development.

[103]  F. Collins,et al.  Differential phylogenetic footprinting as a means to identify base changes responsible for recruitment of the anthropoid gamma gene to a fetal expression pattern. , 1994, The Journal of biological chemistry.

[104]  E. Mayr Cause and Effect in Biology: Kinds of causes, predictability, and teleology are viewed by a practicing biologist , 1961 .

[105]  G. Wagner,et al.  1,2,3 = 2,3,4: a solution to the problem of the homology of the digits in the avian hand. , 1999, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[106]  K. K. Smith,et al.  Have gene knockouts caused evolutionary reversals in the mammalian first arch? , 1998, BioEssays : news and reviews in molecular, cellular and developmental biology.