We investigate here two questions, first in a Boolean setting and then in a gradual setting: Can we give a formal meaning to “being at odds” (in the sense of being an outlayer) with regard to a subset and, as a dual problem, can we give a meaning to “being even” (in the sense of conforming to a given set of values). Is there a relation between oddness and evenness? Such questions emerge from recent proposals for using oddness or evenness measures in classification problems. This paper is dedicated to a formal study of the oddness and evenness indices in the case of subsets with three or four elements, which are at the basis of the associated measures. Triples are indeed the only subsets such that adding an item that conforms to the triple minority, if any, destroys the majority. It appears that the notions of oddness and evenness are not simple dual of each other; a third notion of being “balanced” interplays with the two others. This is discussed in the setting of squares and hexagons of opposition. The notions of oddness and evenness are related to the study of homogeneous and heterogeneous logical proportions that link four Boolean variables through the conjunction of two equivalences between similarity or dissimilarity indicators pertaining to pairs of these variables. Although elementary, the analysis provides an organized view of new notions that appear to be meaningful when revisiting the old ideas of similarity and dissimilarity in a new perspective. As a side result, it is also mentioned that the logical proportion underlying the idea of being balanced corresponds to the logical encoding of Bongard problems.
[1]
Gilles Richard,et al.
Evenness-Based Reasoning with Logical Proportions Applied to Classification
,
2015,
SUM.
[2]
Gilles Richard,et al.
Oddness-Based Classifiers for Boolean or Numerical Data
,
2015,
KI.
[3]
Gilles Richard,et al.
From Analogical Proportion to Logical Proportions
,
2013,
Logica Universalis.
[4]
Robert Blanché,et al.
Structures Intellectuelles : essai sur l'organisation systématique des concepts
,
1981
.
[5]
Gilles Richard,et al.
A New View of Conformity and Its Application to Classification
,
2015,
ECSQARU.
[6]
Jean-Yves Béziau,et al.
The Power of the Hexagon
,
2012,
Logica Universalis.
[7]
Gilles Richard,et al.
Homogenous and Heterogeneous Logical Proportions
,
2014,
FLAP.
[8]
Henri Prade,et al.
Handling Analogical Proportions in Classical Logic and Fuzzy Logics Settings
,
2009,
ECSQARU.
[9]
Didier Dubois,et al.
From Blanché’s Hexagonal Organization of Concepts to Formal Concept Analysis and Possibility Theory
,
2012,
Logica Universalis.
[10]
Béziau Jean-Yves.
New light on the Square of oppositions and its nameless corner
,
2003
.
[11]
D. Hofstadter,et al.
Godel, Escher, Bach: An Eternal Golden Braid
,
1979
.