Dichotomy in perceptual learning of interval timing: calibration of mean accuracy and precision differ in specificity and time course.

Our brain is inexorably confronted with a dynamic environment in which it has to fine-tune spatiotemporal representations of incoming sensory stimuli and commit to a decision accordingly. Among those representations needing constant calibration is interval timing, which plays a pivotal role in various cognitive and motor tasks. To investigate how perceived time interval is adjusted by experience, we conducted a human psychophysical experiment using an implicit interval-timing task in which observers responded to an invisible bar drifting at a constant speed. We tracked daily changes in distributions of response times for a range of physical time intervals over multiple days of training with two major types of timing performance, mean accuracy and precision. We found a decoupled dynamics of mean accuracy and precision in terms of their time course and specificity of perceptual learning. Mean accuracy showed feedback-driven instantaneous calibration evidenced by a partial transfer around the time interval trained with feedback, while timing precision exhibited a long-term slow improvement with no evident specificity. We found that a Bayesian observer model, in which a subjective time interval is determined jointly by a prior and likelihood function for timing, captures the dissociative temporal dynamics of the two types of timing measures simultaneously. Finally, the model suggested that the width of the prior, not the likelihoods, gradually shrinks over sessions, substantiating the important role of prior knowledge in perceptual learning of interval timing.

[1]  Jennifer T. Coull,et al.  Behavioural Dissociation between Exogenous and Endogenous Temporal Orienting of Attention , 2011, PloS one.

[2]  Ramon Bartolo,et al.  The Context of Temporal Processing Is Represented in the Multidimensional Relationships between Timing Tasks , 2008, PloS one.

[3]  J. Gibbon,et al.  Coupled Temporal Memories in Parkinson's Disease: A Dopamine-Related Dysfunction , 1998, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience.

[4]  Pascal Mamassian,et al.  Evaluation of Objective Uncertainty in the Visual System , 2009, PLoS Comput. Biol..

[5]  Kwang-Hyuk Lee,et al.  The Role of the Cerebellum in Subsecond Time Perception: Evidence from Repetitive Transcranial Magnetic Stimulation , 2007, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience.

[6]  Daniel M. Wolpert,et al.  Signal-dependent noise determines motor planning , 1998, Nature.

[7]  M. Fahle Perceptual learning: specificity versus generalization , 2005, Current Opinion in Neurobiology.

[8]  P. Tse,et al.  Attention and the subjective expansion of time , 2004, Perception & psychophysics.

[9]  T. Papathomas,et al.  Audiovisual short-term influences and aftereffects in motion: examination across three sets of directional pairings. , 2008, Journal of vision.

[10]  U. Karmarkar,et al.  Timing in the Absence of Clocks: Encoding Time in Neural Network States , 2007, Neuron.

[11]  Michael H. Herzog,et al.  Reverse feedback induces position and orientation specific changes , 2006, Vision Research.

[12]  Konrad Paul Kording,et al.  Learning Priors for Bayesian Computations in the Nervous System , 2010, PloS one.

[13]  Michael S. Landy,et al.  Optimal Compensation for Temporal Uncertainty in Movement Planning , 2008, PLoS Comput. Biol..

[14]  M. Shadlen,et al.  A representation of the hazard rate of elapsed time in macaque area LIP , 2005, Nature Neuroscience.

[15]  Michael N. Shadlen,et al.  Temporal context calibrates interval timing , 2010, Nature Neuroscience.

[16]  A. Georgopoulos,et al.  Neurophysiology of perceptual and motor aspects of interception. , 2006, Journal of neurophysiology.

[17]  D. Eagleman Human time perception and its illusions , 2008, Current Opinion in Neurobiology.

[18]  Derek H. Arnold,et al.  Spatially Localized Distortions of Event Time , 2006, Current Biology.

[19]  Ryota Kanai,et al.  Time dilation in dynamic visual display. , 2006, Journal of vision.

[20]  A. Faisal,et al.  Near Optimal Combination of Sensory and Motor Uncertainty in Time During a Naturalistic Perception-Action Task , 2008, Journal of neurophysiology.

[21]  Hugo Merchant,et al.  Learning and generalization of time production in humans: rules of transfer across modalities and interval durations , 2009, Experimental Brain Research.

[22]  Catalin V. Buhusi,et al.  What makes us tick? Functional and neural mechanisms of interval timing , 2005, Nature Reviews Neuroscience.

[23]  R. Weale Vision. A Computational Investigation Into the Human Representation and Processing of Visual Information. David Marr , 1983 .

[24]  Barbara Anne Dosher,et al.  Modeling mechanisms of perceptual learning with augmented Hebbian re-weighting , 2010, Vision Research.

[25]  R. Miall,et al.  The precision of temporal judgement: milliseconds, many minutes, and beyond , 2009, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[26]  M. Sahani,et al.  Implicit knowledge of visual uncertainty guides decisions with asymmetric outcomes. , 2008, Journal of vision.

[27]  U. Karmarkar,et al.  Temporal specificity of perceptual learning in an auditory discrimination task. , 2003, Learning & memory.

[28]  Hugo Merchant,et al.  Do we have a common mechanism for measuring time in the hundreds of millisecond range? Evidence from multiple-interval timing tasks. , 2008, Journal of neurophysiology.

[29]  C. Law,et al.  Neural correlates of perceptual learning in a sensory-motor, but not a sensory, cortical area , 2008, Nature Neuroscience.

[30]  Alex L. White,et al.  Visuomotor timing compensates for changes in perceptual latency , 2008, Current Biology.

[31]  S. Fairhurst,et al.  Scalar timing in animals and humans , 2002 .

[32]  M. Banks,et al.  Visual–Haptic Adaptation Is Determined by Relative Reliability , 2010, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[33]  S. Hochstein,et al.  Reverse hierarchies and sensory learning , 2009, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[34]  Robert A. Jacobs,et al.  Motor timing learned without motor training , 2000, Nature Neuroscience.

[35]  Maneesh Sahani,et al.  Inferring Elapsed Time from Stochastic Neural Processes , 2007, NIPS.

[36]  M. Eckstein,et al.  Perceptual learning through optimization of attentional weighting: human versus optimal Bayesian learner. , 2004, Journal of vision.

[37]  Konrad P. Körding,et al.  Self versus Environment Motion in Postural Control , 2010, PLoS Comput. Biol..

[38]  D. Burr,et al.  The Ventriloquist Effect Results from Near-Optimal Bimodal Integration , 2004, Current Biology.

[39]  Ari Koskelainen,et al.  Origin of the fast negative ERG component from isolated aspartate-treated mouse retina. , 2009, Journal of vision.

[40]  John Gibbon,et al.  Categorical Scaling of Duration Bisection in Pigeons (Columba livia), Mice (Mus musculus), and Humans (Homo sapiens) , 2008, Psychological science.

[41]  D. Scott Perceptual learning. , 1974, Queen's nursing journal.

[42]  Eli Brenner,et al.  If I saw it, it probably wasn't far from where I was looking. , 2008, Journal of vision.

[43]  J. Saunders,et al.  Do humans optimally integrate stereo and texture information for judgments of surface slant? , 2003, Vision Research.

[44]  F. Vidal,et al.  Functional Anatomy of the Attentional Modulation of Time Estimation , 2004, Science.

[45]  David M. Eagleman,et al.  Does Time Really Slow Down during a Frightening Event? , 2007, PloS one.

[46]  M. Miyazaki,et al.  Testing Bayesian models of human coincidence timing. , 2005, Journal of neurophysiology.

[47]  J. Staddon Interval timing: memory, not a clock , 2005, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[48]  S. Hochstein,et al.  Task difficulty and the specificity of perceptual learning , 1997, Nature.

[49]  Claudette Fortin,et al.  Expectancy in humans in multisecond peak-interval timing with gaps , 2009, Attention, perception & psychophysics.

[50]  Takeo Watanabe,et al.  Advances in visual perceptual learning and plasticity , 2010, Nature Reviews Neuroscience.

[51]  Aaron R. Seitz,et al.  Rapidly learned stimulus expectations alter perception of motion. , 2010, Journal of vision.

[52]  J. Assad,et al.  Dissociation of visual, motor and predictive signals in parietal cortex during visual guidance , 1999, Nature Neuroscience.

[53]  L. Ryan,et al.  Erroneous knowledge of results affects decision and memory processes on timing tasks. , 2007, Journal of experimental psychology. Human perception and performance.

[54]  A. Yuille,et al.  Object perception as Bayesian inference. , 2004, Annual review of psychology.

[55]  Heinrich H Bülthoff,et al.  Bayesian motion estimation accounts for a surprising bias in 3D vision , 2008, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[56]  M. Paulus,et al.  Decision making, impulsivity and time perception , 2008, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[57]  M. Sahani,et al.  Observers Exploit Stochastic Models of Sensory Change to Help Judge the Passage of Time , 2011, Current Biology.

[58]  M. Shadlen,et al.  Representation of Time by Neurons in the Posterior Parietal Cortex of the Macaque , 2003, Neuron.

[59]  R. Miall,et al.  Distinct systems for automatic and cognitively controlled time measurement: evidence from neuroimaging , 2003, Current Opinion in Neurobiology.

[60]  P. Montague,et al.  Motor-Sensory Recalibration Leads to an Illusory Reversal of Action and Sensation , 2006, Neuron.

[61]  Virginie van Wassenhove,et al.  The experience of time: neural mechanisms and the interplay of emotion, cognition and embodiment , 2009, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[62]  A. Nobre,et al.  Dissociating explicit timing from temporal expectation with fMRI , 2008, Current Opinion in Neurobiology.

[63]  Dean V Buonomano,et al.  Influence of the interstimulus interval on temporal processing and learning: testing the state-dependent network model , 2009, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[64]  Dean V Buonomano,et al.  Timing of neural responses in cortical organotypic slices , 2003, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[65]  Barbara Anne Dosher,et al.  The Functional Form of Performance Improvements in Perceptual Learning , 2007, Psychological science.

[66]  C. Gallistel,et al.  Toward a neurobiology of temporal cognition: advances and challenges , 1997, Current Opinion in Neurobiology.

[67]  L. Maloney,et al.  Bayesian decision theory as a model of human visual perception: Testing Bayesian transfer , 2009, Visual Neuroscience.

[68]  Robert C. Wilson,et al.  An Approximately Bayesian Delta-Rule Model Explains the Dynamics of Belief Updating in a Changing Environment , 2010, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[69]  J. Wearden,et al.  Scalar Properties in Animal Timing: Conformity and Violations , 2006, Quarterly journal of experimental psychology.

[70]  C. Gilbert,et al.  The Neural Basis of Perceptual Learning , 2001, Neuron.

[71]  Robin D. Thomas,et al.  Evidence for criterion shifts in visual perceptual learning: Data and implications , 2008, Perception & psychophysics.

[72]  Konrad Paul Kording,et al.  Review TRENDS in Cognitive Sciences Vol.10 No.7 July 2006 Special Issue: Probabilistic models of cognition Bayesian decision theory in sensorimotor control , 2022 .

[73]  S. Grondin Timing and time perception: A review of recent behavioral and neuroscience findings and theoretical directions , 2010, Attention, perception & psychophysics.

[74]  Cong Yu,et al.  Stimulus Coding Rules for Perceptual Learning , 2008, PLoS biology.

[75]  Simon Grondin,et al.  Unequal Weber fractions for the categorization of brief temporal intervals , 2010, Attention, perception & psychophysics.

[76]  Mitsuo Kawato,et al.  Boosting perceptual learning by fake feedback , 2009, Vision Research.

[77]  A. Gorea,et al.  Comparison of perceptual and motor latencies via anticipatory and reactive response times , 2009, Attention, perception & psychophysics.

[78]  H. Zelaznik,et al.  Dissociation of explicit and implicit timing in repetitive tapping and drawing movements. , 2002 .

[79]  M. Ernst,et al.  Humans integrate visual and haptic information in a statistically optimal fashion , 2002, Nature.

[80]  J. Gibbon,et al.  Scalar expectancy theory and peak-interval timing in humans. , 1998, Journal of experimental psychology. Animal behavior processes.

[81]  Nathaniel S. Miller,et al.  Picking up the pace: Effects of global temporal context on sensitivity to the tempo of auditory sequences , 2007, Perception & psychophysics.

[82]  S Zeki,et al.  The sightless view: neural correlates of occluded objects. , 2007, Cerebral cortex.

[83]  C. Summerfield,et al.  A Neural Representation of Prior Information during Perceptual Inference , 2008, Neuron.

[84]  Daniel Linares,et al.  Where is the moving object now? Judgments of instantaneous position show poor temporal precision (SD = 70 ms). , 2009, Journal of vision.

[85]  John E. Schlerf,et al.  Dedicated and intrinsic models of time perception , 2008, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[86]  B. Dosher,et al.  Characterizing observers using external noise and observer models: assessing internal representations with external noise. , 2008, Psychological review.

[87]  J. Hegdé Time course of visual perception: Coarse-to-fine processing and beyond , 2008, Progress in Neurobiology.

[88]  Warren H. Meck,et al.  Chronic treatment with haloperidol induces deficits in working memory and feedback effects of interval timing , 2005, Brain and Cognition.

[89]  Akihiro Yagi,et al.  Reduction of stimulus visibility compresses apparent time intervals , 2008, Nature Neuroscience.

[90]  Misha Tsodyks,et al.  Neural networks and perceptual learning , 2004, Nature.

[91]  Misha Tsodyks,et al.  Context-enabled learning in the human visual system , 2002, Nature.

[92]  J. Tanji,et al.  Interval time coding by neurons in the presupplementary and supplementary motor areas , 2009, Nature Neuroscience.

[93]  C. Law,et al.  The relative influences of priors and sensory evidence on an oculomotor decision variable during perceptual learning. , 2008, Journal of neurophysiology.

[94]  J. Gibbon Scalar expectancy theory and Weber's law in animal timing. , 1977 .

[95]  S. S. Stevens,et al.  Handbook of experimental psychology , 1951 .

[96]  Hugo Merchant,et al.  Subsecond timing in primates: comparison of interval production between human subjects and rhesus monkeys. , 2009, Journal of neurophysiology.

[97]  Konrad P. Körding,et al.  Bayesian Integration and Non-Linear Feedback Control in a Full-Body Motor Task , 2009, PLoS Comput. Biol..

[98]  Nancy Byl,et al.  Practice-Related Improvements in Somatosensory Interval Discrimination Are Temporally Specific But Generalize across Skin Location, Hemisphere, and Modality , 1998, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[99]  Marvin M Chun,et al.  Spatiotemporal object continuity in human ventral visual cortex , 2008, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[100]  Robert A Jacobs,et al.  Comparing perceptual learning tasks: a review. , 2002, Journal of vision.

[101]  Clayton E. Curtis,et al.  Neural Substrates of Dynamic Object Occlusion , 2007, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience.

[102]  Scott O Murray,et al.  The effects of spatial attention in early human visual cortex are stimulus independent. , 2008, Journal of vision.

[103]  J. Tenenbaum,et al.  Special issue on “Probabilistic models of cognition , 2022 .

[104]  Joshua I Gold,et al.  Relationships between the threshold and slope of psychometric and neurometric functions during perceptual learning: implications for neuronal pooling. , 2010, Journal of neurophysiology.

[105]  Cong Yu,et al.  Perceptual learning in contrast discrimination and the (minimal) role of context. , 2004, Journal of vision.

[106]  D. Buonomano,et al.  Learning and Generalization of Auditory Temporal–Interval Discrimination in Humans , 1997, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[107]  I. J. Myung,et al.  When a good fit can be bad , 2002, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[108]  F A Wichmann,et al.  Ning for Helpful Comments and Suggestions. This Paper Benefited Con- Siderably from Conscientious Peer Review, and We Thank Our Reviewers the Psychometric Function: I. Fitting, Sampling, and Goodness of Fit , 2001 .

[109]  J. Devin McAuley,et al.  Time judgments in global temporal contexts , 2005, Perception & psychophysics.

[110]  Charles Kemp,et al.  Bayesian models of cognition , 2008 .

[111]  D. Burr,et al.  Optimal Encoding of Interval Timing in Expert Percussionists , 2011, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[112]  M. Fahle,et al.  The role of feedback in learning a vernier discrimination task , 1997, Vision Research.

[113]  M. Wittmann The inner experience of time , 2009, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[114]  S. Kitazawa,et al.  Bayesian calibration of simultaneity in tactile temporal order judgment , 2006, Nature Neuroscience.

[115]  Konrad Paul Kording,et al.  Bayesian integration in sensorimotor learning , 2004, Nature.

[116]  Frank Tong,et al.  The Functional Impact of Mental Imagery on Conscious Perception , 2008, Current Biology.

[117]  Walter Senn,et al.  Adaptive Gain Modulation in V1 Explains Contextual Modifications during Bisection Learning , 2009, PLoS Comput. Biol..

[118]  Gerald Westheimer,et al.  Discrimination of short time intervals by the human observer , 1999, Experimental Brain Research.

[119]  Matthew B. Wall,et al.  Time perception: Manipulation of task difficulty dissociates clock functions from other cognitive demands , 2007, Neuropsychologia.

[120]  Karl J. Friston The free-energy principle: a unified brain theory? , 2010, Nature Reviews Neuroscience.

[121]  Rajesh P. N. Rao,et al.  Bayesian brain : probabilistic approaches to neural coding , 2006 .

[122]  P. Tse,et al.  Time and the Brain: How Subjective Time Relates to Neural Time , 2005 .

[123]  M Concetta Morrone,et al.  Neural mechanisms for timing visual events are spatially selective in real-world coordinates , 2007, Nature Neuroscience.

[124]  Eero P. Simoncelli,et al.  Noise characteristics and prior expectations in human visual speed perception , 2006, Nature Neuroscience.

[125]  C. Law,et al.  Reinforcement learning can account for associative and perceptual learning on a visual decision task , 2009, Nature Neuroscience.

[126]  W. Meck,et al.  Neuroanatomical and Neurochemical Substrates of Timing , 2011, Neuropsychopharmacology.

[127]  M. Landy,et al.  Decision making, movement planning and statistical decision theory , 2008, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.