Mystery unsolved: missing limbs in deformed amphibians.

Ballengee and Sessions (2009) claim that predatory attacks by small predators such as Sympetrum dragonfly larvae are sufficient to explain amphibian limb deformities in which the limb is partly or completely missing. This deformity type, the most common in nature, is not well explained by Ribeiroia infection which has also been nominated as a mechanism for limb deformities. We argue that the conclusions of the Ballanegee and Sessions study are not well founded. In part this is because the authors have provided no quantitative analysis of the association between limb deformities and predator densities. Our own data on frequencies of limb deformities suggest that missing hind limbs are often extremely rare even when Sympetrum and other small predators are common. While predatory attacks may contribute to observations of limb deformities, further study will be required to elucidate their role; other potential mechanisms deserve study as well. It is premature, and counterproductive, to draw any conclusions regarding the mechanisms behind the most common limb deformities recorded in natural populations.

[1]  Geffrey F. Stopper,et al.  How trematodes cause limb deformities in amphibians. , 2002, The Journal of experimental zoology.

[2]  Kevin B. Lunde,et al.  The effect of trematode infection on amphibian limb development and survivorship. , 1999, Science.

[3]  E. Werner,et al.  Estimating Decline and Distributional Change in Amphibians , 2003 .

[4]  E. Werner,et al.  Amphibian species richness across environmental gradients , 2007 .

[5]  G. Gauze.  The struggle for existence, by G. F. Gause. , 1934 .

[6]  E. Werner,et al.  Turnover in an amphibian metacommunity : the role of local and regional factors , 2007 .

[7]  J. Bonin,et al.  HINDLIMB DEFORMITIES (ECTROMELIA, ECTRODACTYLY) IN FREE-LIVING ANURANS FROM AGRICULTURAL HABITATS , 1997, Journal of wildlife diseases.

[8]  D. Skelly,et al.  Ribeiroia Infection Is Not Responsible for Vermont Amphibian Deformities , 2007, EcoHealth.

[9]  Kevin B. Lunde,et al.  Ribeiroia ondatrae (Trematoda: Digenea) infection induces severe limb malformations in western toads (Bufo boreas) , 2001 .

[10]  P. J. Hughesdon,et al.  The Struggle for Existence , 1927, Nature.

[11]  D. Schluter,et al.  MICROCOSM EXPERIMENTS HAVE LIMITED RELEVANCE FOR COMMUNITY AND ECOSYSTEM ECOLOGY , 1996 .

[12]  E. Werner,et al.  Metacommunity patterns in larval odonates , 2008, Oecologia.

[13]  David K. Skelly,et al.  LONG-TERM DISTRIBUTIONAL DYNAMICS OF A MICHIGAN AMPHIBIAN ASSEMBLAGE , 1999 .

[14]  S. Sessions,et al.  Morphological clues from multilegged frogs: are retinoids to blame? , 1999, Science.

[15]  David Skelly,et al.  Proximity to Pollution Sources and Risk of Amphibian Limb Malformation , 2005, Environmental health perspectives.

[16]  Pieter T. J. Johnson,et al.  Amphibian deformities and Ribeiroia infection: an emerging helminthiasis. , 2003, Trends in parasitology.

[17]  B. Martof.  Factors Influencing Size and Composition of Populations of Rana clamitans , 1956 .

[18]  David K. Skelly,et al.  EXPERIMENTAL VENUE AND ESTIMATION OF INTERACTION STRENGTH , 2002 .

[19]  D. Rosenberry,et al.  Multiple Causes for the Malformed Frog Phenomenon , 2003 .

[20]  S. Sessions,et al.  Explanation for missing limbs in deformed amphibians. , 2009, Journal of Experimental Zoology Part B: Molecular and Developmental Evolution.

[21]  S. R. Carpenter,et al.  Microcosm experiments have limited relevance for community and ecosystem ecology : Microcosms , 1996 .

[22]  E. Werner,et al.  Comparative landscape dynamics of two anuran species: climate-driven interaction of local and regional processes , 2009 .

[23]  Lina J. Urquidi,et al.  Multiple stressor effects in relation to declining amphibian populations , 2003 .