An empirical comparison of the therapeutic benefits of physical exercise and cognitive training on the executive functions of older adults: a meta-analysis of controlled trials.

UNLABELLED A robust body of aging-related research has established benefits of both physical exercise (PE) and cognitive training (CT) on executive functions related to the activities of daily living of older adults; however, no meta-analysis has compared these treatments. OBJECTIVE The current quantitative review involved a comparison of the overall effect sizes of PE and CT interventions on executive functions (Morris, 2008; pre-post-controlled effect size: d(ppc)), while also exploring contextual moderators of treatment outcomes. METHOD A systematic review identified 46 studies (23 PE, 21 CT, and 2 both) meeting inclusion criteria (i.e., controlled interventions, executive-related outcomes, mean ages 65+, information to calculate d(ppc)). RESULTS The weighted mean dppc values came to 0.12 (p < .01) for PE and 0.24 (p < .01) for CT. Treatment effects differed based on executive constructs for CT, with problem solving presenting the highest d(ppc) (0.47, p < .01). Notably, PE produced similar effect sizes across distinct executive functions. Treatment characteristics (e.g., session length/frequency) did not predict effect sizes. CT had a significant benefit on healthy participants (0.26, p < .01), but cognitively impaired samples did not experience a significant effect. CONCLUSIONS Both treatments improved executive functions, but CT presented a potential advantage at improving executive functions. Improvements in executive functions differed depending on construct for CT, whereas each construct produced similar, modest effect sizes for PE. Publication bias and study quality variability potentially bias these conclusions, as lower quality studies likely produced inflated effect sizes.

[1]  N. Laird,et al.  Meta-analysis in clinical trials. , 1986, Controlled clinical trials.

[2]  Todd C. Handy,et al.  Resistance training and functional plasticity of the aging brain: a 12-month randomized controlled trial , 2012, Neurobiology of Aging.

[3]  Robert L. Bangert-Drowns,et al.  Review of developments in meta-analytic method. , 1986 .

[4]  T. Salthouse,et al.  Executive functioning as a potential mediator of age-related cognitive decline in normal adults. , 2003, Journal of experimental psychology. General.

[5]  K. Ottenbacher,et al.  The effects of exercise training on elderly persons with cognitive impairment and dementia: a meta-analysis. , 2004, Archives of physical medicine and rehabilitation.

[6]  M. Rosenberg,et al.  THE FILE‐DRAWER PROBLEM REVISITED: A GENERAL WEIGHTED METHOD FOR CALCULATING FAIL‐SAFE NUMBERS IN META‐ANALYSIS , 2005, Evolution; international journal of organic evolution.

[7]  S. Awata,et al.  Effects of Intervention Using a Community‐Based Walking Program for Prevention of Mental Decline: A Randomized Controlled Trial , 2012, Journal of the American Geriatrics Society.

[8]  Vered Aharonson,et al.  Computer-Based, Personalized Cognitive Training versus Classical Computer Games: A Randomized Double-Blind Prospective Trial of Cognitive Stimulation , 2011, Neuroepidemiology.

[9]  L. Hedges,et al.  The Handbook of Research Synthesis and Meta-Analysis , 2009 .

[10]  R. Schwarzer,et al.  Complex mental and physical activity in older women and cognitive performance: a 6-month randomized controlled trial. , 2010, The journals of gerontology. Series A, Biological sciences and medical sciences.

[11]  Jennifer L. Mozolic,et al.  Human Neuroscience , 2022 .

[12]  S R Lord,et al.  Effects of group exercise on cognitive functioning and mood in older women , 1977, Australian and New Zealand journal of public health.

[13]  D J Madden,et al.  Improving aerobic capacity in healthy older adults does not necessarily lead to improved cognitive performance. , 1989, Psychology and aging.

[14]  Sarah A. Chau,et al.  Current and Emerging Drug Treatment Options for Alzheimer’s Disease , 2011, Drugs.

[15]  Rhiannon Whitaker,et al.  Goal-oriented cognitive rehabilitation for people with early-stage Alzheimer disease: a single-blind randomized controlled trial of clinical efficacy. , 2010, The American journal of geriatric psychiatry : official journal of the American Association for Geriatric Psychiatry.

[16]  A Baddeley,et al.  The fractionation of working memory. , 1996, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[17]  D. Tranel,et al.  Neuropsychological assessment, 5th ed. , 2012 .

[18]  Matthew Rizzo,et al.  The Accelerate Study: The Longitudinal Effect of Speed of Processing Training on Cognitive Performance of Older Adults , 2007 .

[19]  Arthur F. Kramer,et al.  Capitalizing on cortical plasticity: influence of physical activity on cognition and brain function , 2007, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[20]  Denise C Park,et al.  The effects of an engaged lifestyle on cognitive vitality: a field experiment. , 2008, Psychology and aging.

[21]  R. Corbeil,et al.  Coping With Dementia: Evaluation of Four Nonpharmacologic Interventions , 2000, International Psychogeriatrics.

[22]  Michael Valenzuela,et al.  Cognitive Exercise and Its Role in Cognitive Function in Older Adults , 2010, Current psychiatry reports.

[23]  A F Kramer,et al.  Aging, exercise, and attention. , 1992, Psychology and aging.

[24]  C R Jack,et al.  Serial MRI and CSF biomarkers in normal aging, MCI, and AD , 2010, Neurology.

[25]  A. Otero,et al.  Social networks, social integration, and social engagement determine cognitive decline in community-dwelling Spanish older adults. , 2003, The journals of gerontology. Series B, Psychological sciences and social sciences.

[26]  C. Barnes,et al.  Neural plasticity in the ageing brain , 2006, Nature Reviews Neuroscience.

[27]  M. D. Calero,et al.  Cognitive plasticity as a modulating variable on the effects of memory training in elderly persons. , 2007, Archives of clinical neuropsychology : the official journal of the National Academy of Neuropsychologists.

[28]  R. N. Davis,et al.  Cognitive Intervention in Alzheimer Disease: A Randomized Placebo-Controlled Study , 2001, Alzheimer disease and associated disorders.

[29]  Perminder Sachdev,et al.  Can cognitive exercise prevent the onset of dementia? Systematic review of randomized clinical trials with longitudinal follow-up. , 2009, The American journal of geriatric psychiatry : official journal of the American Association for Geriatric Psychiatry.

[30]  Lynn Hasher,et al.  Age-related differences in cognition: the role of distraction control. , 2008, Neuropsychology.

[31]  A. Kramer,et al.  Fitness Effects on the Cognitive Function of Older Adults , 2003, Psychological science.

[32]  Faith M. Gunning-Dixon,et al.  Neuroanatomical correlates of selected executive functions in middle-aged and older adults: a prospective MRI study , 2003, Neuropsychologia.

[33]  S. Morris.  Estimating Effect Sizes From Pretest-Posttest-Control Group Designs , 2008 .

[34]  Linda Clare,et al.  Executive Function and Activities of Daily Living in Alzheimer’s Disease: A Correlational Meta-Analysis , 2012, Dementia and Geriatric Cognitive Disorders.

[35]  Beverly J. Warren,et al.  Physical Activity and Cognitive Performance in the Older Population , 1995 .

[36]  C. Bonetto,et al.  STAM Protocol in Dementia , 2012, American journal of Alzheimer's disease and other dementias.

[37]  Lars Nyberg,et al.  Plasticity of executive functioning in young and older adults: immediate training gains, transfer, and long-term maintenance. , 2008, Psychology and aging.

[38]  E. McAuley,et al.  Frontiers in Aging Neuroscience Aging Neuroscience , 2022 .

[39]  Mitchell Haas,et al.  Randomized, controlled, six-month trial of yoga in healthy seniors: effects on cognition and quality of life. , 2006, Alternative therapies in health and medicine.

[40]  C. Anderson-Hanley,et al.  Cognitive health benefits of strengthening exercise for community-dwelling older adults , 2010, Journal of clinical and experimental neuropsychology.

[41]  A. Kurz,et al.  The clinical significance of cognition-focused interventions for cognitively impaired older adults: a systematic review of randomized controlled trials , 2011, International Psychogeriatrics.

[42]  George W Rebok,et al.  Effects of cognitive training interventions with older adults: a randomized controlled trial. , 2002, JAMA.

[43]  Paige E. Scalf,et al.  Cardiovascular fitness, cortical plasticity, and aging. , 2004, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[44]  Brian Levine,et al.  Cognitive rehabilitation in the elderly: A randomized trial to evaluate a new protocol , 2006, Journal of the International Neuropsychological Society.

[45]  D. Cahn-Weiner,et al.  Tests of Executive Function Predict Instrumental Activities of Daily Living in Community-Dwelling Older Individuals , 2002, Applied neuropsychology.

[46]  S. Willis,et al.  In-Home Cognitive Training with Older Married Couples: Individual Versus Collaborative Learning , 2006, Neuropsychology, development, and cognition. Section B, Aging, neuropsychology and cognition.

[47]  W. Mechelen,et al.  The Effects of Exercise on Cognition in Older Adults With and Without Cognitive Decline: A Systematic Review , 2008, Clinical journal of sport medicine : official journal of the Canadian Academy of Sport Medicine.

[48]  Erika Borella,et al.  Working memory training in older adults: evidence of transfer and maintenance effects. , 2010, Psychology and aging.

[49]  W. Mechelen,et al.  Walking or vitamin B for cognition in older adults with mild cognitive impairment? A randomised controlled trial , 2008, British Journal of Sports Medicine.

[50]  B. Biswal,et al.  Correspondence of executive function related functional and anatomical alterations in aging brain , 2014, Progress in Neuro-Psychopharmacology and Biological Psychiatry.

[51]  Yasuyuki Taki,et al.  Brain Training Game Improves Executive Functions and Processing Speed in the Elderly: A Randomized Controlled Trial , 2012, PloS one.

[52]  M. Posner,et al.  Research on attention networks as a model for the integration of psychological science. , 2007, Annual review of psychology.

[53]  K. Sink,et al.  Designing clinical trials for assessing the effects of cognitive training and physical activity interventions on cognitive outcomes: The Seniors Health and Activity Research Program Pilot (SHARP-P) Study, a randomized controlled trial , 2011, BMC geriatrics.

[54]  Jeffrey N. Browndyke,et al.  Aerobic Exercise and Neurocognitive Performance: A Meta-Analytic Review of Randomized Controlled Trials , 2010, Psychosomatic medicine.

[55]  M. Yassuda,et al.  Executive dysfunction correlates with impaired functional status in older adults with varying degrees of cognitive impairment , 2008, International Psychogeriatrics.

[56]  Ashley R. Morgan,et al.  A cognitive training intervention improves modality-specific attention in a randomized controlled trial of healthy older adults , 2011, Neurobiology of Aging.

[57]  J. Sánchez-Meca,et al.  Averaging Dependent Effect Sizes in Meta-Analysis: a Cautionary Note about Procedures , 1999, The Spanish Journal of Psychology.

[58]  M. B. Jurado,et al.  The Elusive Nature of Executive Functions: A Review of our Current Understanding , 2007, Neuropsychology Review.

[59]  R. A. Groeneveld,et al.  Practical Nonparametric Statistics (2nd ed). , 1981 .

[60]  Tania B. Huedo-Medina,et al.  Assessing heterogeneity in meta-analysis: Q statistic or I2 index? , 2006, Psychological methods.

[61]  P. Anderson.  Assessment and Development of Executive Function (EF) During Childhood , 2002, Child neuropsychology : a journal on normal and abnormal development in childhood and adolescence.

[62]  Michael E. Miller,et al.  Changes in cognitive function in a randomized trial of physical activity: results of the lifestyle interventions and independence for elders pilot study. , 2009, The journals of gerontology. Series A, Biological sciences and medical sciences.

[63]  C. Bottino,et al.  Cognitive rehabilitation combined with drug treatment in Alzheimer's disease patients: a pilot study , 2005, Clinical rehabilitation.

[64]  Donald B. Rubin,et al.  Meta-Analytic Procedures for Combining Studies With Multiple Effect Sizes , 1986 .

[65]  Martin Orrell,et al.  Cognitive rehabilitation interventions targeting memory functioning in early-stage Alzheimer's disease and vascular dementia , 2001 .

[66]  J. Nigg.  On inhibition/disinhibition in developmental psychopathology: views from cognitive and personality psychology and a working inhibition taxonomy. , 2000, Psychological bulletin.

[67]  R. Rosenthal.  The file drawer problem and tolerance for null results , 1979 .

[68]  Klaus Hauer,et al.  Dual-task performances can be improved in patients with dementia , 2010, Neurology.

[69]  J A Rodgers,et al.  A Dyadic Remediation Program for Care Recipients with Dementia , 1995, Nursing research.

[70]  V. Moro,et al.  Cognitive Stimulation in a-MCI , 2012, American journal of Alzheimer's disease and other dementias.

[71]  Patricia A Tun,et al.  Histories of social engagement and adult cognition: midlife in the U.S. study. , 2011, The journals of gerontology. Series B, Psychological sciences and social sciences.

[72]  Raja Parasuraman,et al.  Neuronal and Cognitive Plasticity: A Neurocognitive Framework for Ameliorating Cognitive Aging , 2010, Front. Ag. Neurosci..

[73]  S R Lord,et al.  The effect of group-based exercise on cognitive performance and mood in seniors residing in intermediate care and self-care retirement facilities: a randomised controlled trial , 2008, British Journal of Sports Medicine.

[74]  J. Thom,et al.  Rationale for Combined Exercise and Cognition-Focused Interventions to Improve Functional Independence in People with Dementia , 2010, Gerontology.

[75]  Peter Graf,et al.  Resistance training and executive functions: a 12-month randomized controlled trial. , 2010, Archives of internal medicine.

[76]  L. Yágüez,et al.  The effects on cognitive functions of a movement‐based intervention in patients with Alzheimer's type dementia: a pilot study , 2011, International journal of geriatric psychiatry.

[77]  R. Hamman,et al.  Executive Cognitive Abilities and Functional Status Among Community‐Dwelling Older Persons in the San Luis Valley Health and Aging Study , 1998, Journal of the American Geriatrics Society.

[78]  J. Karr,et al.  Omega-3 polyunsaturated fatty acids and cognition throughout the lifespan: A review , 2011, Nutritional neuroscience.

[79]  Catherine R. Harrison,et al.  Ageing, fitness and neurocognitive function , 1999, Nature.

[80]  D. Molloy,et al.  The effects of a three-month exercise programme on neuropsychological function in elderly institutionalized women: a randomized controlled trial. , 1988, Age and ageing.

[81]  M P Quayhagen,et al.  Differential effects of family-based strategies on Alzheimer's disease. , 1989, The Gerontologist.

[82]  Ingrid R Olson,et al.  Working memory training and transfer in older adults. , 2011, Psychology and aging.

[83]  J. Sergeant,et al.  Physical activity and executive functions in the elderly with mild cognitive impairment , 2005, Aging & mental health.

[84]  Takao Suzuki,et al.  Effects of multicomponent exercise on cognitive function in older adults with amnestic mild cognitive impairment: a randomized controlled trial , 2012, BMC Neurology.

[85]  T. Braver,et al.  A theory of cognitive control, aging cognition, and neuromodulation , 2002, Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews.

[86]  Denise C. Park,et al.  The adaptive brain: aging and neurocognitive scaffolding. , 2009, Annual review of psychology.

[87]  George W Rebok,et al.  Results of a Randomized Placebo-Controlled Study of Memory Training for Mildly Impaired Alzheimer's Disease Patients , 2003, Applied neuropsychology.

[88]  R. Powell.  Psychological effects of exercise therapy upon institutionalized geriatric mental patients. , 1974, Journal of gerontology.

[89]  Stephen Salloway,et al.  Executive dysfunction and apathy predict functional impairment in Alzheimer disease. , 2003, The American journal of geriatric psychiatry : official journal of the American Association for Geriatric Psychiatry.

[90]  Catherine Sherrington,et al.  Reliability of the PEDro scale for rating quality of randomized controlled trials. , 2003, Physical therapy.

[91]  B. Winblad,et al.  An active and socially integrated lifestyle in late life might protect against dementia , 2004, The Lancet Neurology.

[92]  M. Mattson.  Neuroprotective signaling and the aging brain: take away my food and let me run 1 1 Published on the World Wide Web on 24 August 2000. , 2000, Brain Research.

[93]  Shuichiro Watanabe,et al.  The influence of short-term strength training on health-related quality of life and executive cognitive function. , 2010, Journal of physiological anthropology.

[94]  P. Briss,et al.  Data collection instrument and procedure for systematic reviews in the Guide to Community Preventive Services. Task Force on Community Preventive Services. , 2000, American journal of preventive medicine.

[95]  Kristine Yaffe,et al.  A Cognitive Training Program Based on Principles of Brain Plasticity: Results from the Improvement in Memory with Plasticity‐based Adaptive Cognitive Training (IMPACT) Study , 2009, Journal of the American Geriatrics Society.

[96]  Gordon Winocur,et al.  Cognitive rehabilitation in the elderly: Effects on memory , 2006, Journal of the International Neuropsychological Society.

[97]  E. Miller,et al.  An integrative theory of prefrontal cortex function. , 2001, Annual review of neuroscience.

[98]  K. Chamari,et al.  Improvement of cognitive function by mental and/or individualized aerobic training in healthy elderly subjects. , 2002, International journal of sports medicine.

[99]  S. Lord,et al.  Otago Home‐Based Strength and Balance Retraining Improves Executive Functioning in Older Fallers: A Randomized Controlled Trial , 2008, Journal of the American Geriatrics Society.

[100]  P. Goldman-Rakic.  The prefrontal landscape: implications of functional architecture for understanding human mentation and the central executive. , 1996, Philosophical transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological sciences.

[101]  J. Borkowski,et al.  Theories, models, and measurements of executive functioning: An information processing perspective. , 1996 .

[102]  R. N. Spreng,et al.  Executive functions and neurocognitive aging: dissociable patterns of brain activity , 2012, Neurobiology of Aging.

[103]  D. Moher,et al.  Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: the PRISMA Statement , 2009, BMJ : British Medical Journal.

[104]  D. Jeste,et al.  Cognitive training in Alzheimer's disease: a meta‐analysis of the literature , 2006, Acta psychiatrica Scandinavica.

[105]  Cristina Buiza,et al.  A randomized, two‐year study of the efficacy of cognitive intervention on elderly people: the Donostia Longitudinal Study , 2008, International journal of geriatric psychiatry.

[106]  P. Heyn,et al.  Endurance and strength training outcomes on cognitively impaired and cognitively intact older adults: A meta-analysis , 2008, The journal of nutrition, health & aging.

[107]  K. Rodahl,et al.  The effects of physical conditioning on older individuals. II. Motor performance and cognitive function. , 1966, Journal of gerontology.

[108]  R. Rupprecht,et al.  Differential effects of single versus combined cognitive and physical training with older adults: the SimA study in a 5-year perspective , 2006, European journal of ageing.

[109]  J. Kray,et al.  How useful is executive control training? Age differences in near and far transfer of task-switching training. , 2009, Developmental science.

[110]  Kristine Yaffe,et al.  Executive function, more than global cognition, predicts functional decline and mortality in elderly women. , 2007, The journals of gerontology. Series A, Biological sciences and medical sciences.

[111]  D J Madden,et al.  Cardiovascular and behavioral effects of aerobic exercise training in healthy older men and women. , 1989, Journal of gerontology.