Lessons from computer simulations of ablation of atrial fibrillation

This paper reviews the simulations of catheter ablation in computer models of the atria, from the first attempts to the most recent anatomical models. It describes how postulated substrates of atrial fibrillation can be incorporated into mathematical models, how modelling studies can be designed to test ablation strategies, what their current trade‐offs and limitations are, and what clinically relevant lessons can be learnt from these simulations. Drawing a parallel between clinical and modelling studies, six ablation targets are considered: pulmonary vein isolation, linear ablation, ectopic foci, complex fractionated atrial electrogram, rotors and ganglionated plexi. The examples presented for each ablation target illustrate a major advantage of computer models, the ability to identify why a therapy is successful or not in a given atrial fibrillation substrate. The integration of pathophysiological data to create detailed models of arrhythmogenic substrates is expected to solidify the understanding of ablation mechanisms and to provide theoretical arguments supporting substrate‐specific ablation strategies.

[1]  Jean-Marc Vesin,et al.  Analysis of electrocardiograms during atrial fibrillation. A biophysical model approach. , 2006, IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Magazine.

[2]  Nicholas S Peters,et al.  The Rotor Revolution: Conduction at the Eye of the Storm in Atrial Fibrillation , 2014, Circulation. Arrhythmia and electrophysiology.

[3]  Nathalie Virag,et al.  Atrial fibrillatory cycle length: computer simulation and potential clinical importance. , 2007, Europace : European pacing, arrhythmias, and cardiac electrophysiology : journal of the working groups on cardiac pacing, arrhythmias, and cardiac cellular electrophysiology of the European Society of Cardiology.

[4]  Kalyanam Shivkumar,et al.  Long-term clinical outcomes of focal impulse and rotor modulation for treatment of atrial fibrillation: A multicenter experience. , 2016, Heart rhythm.

[5]  Trine Krogh-Madsen,et al.  Effects of Electrical and Structural Remodeling on Atrial Fibrillation Maintenance: A Simulation Study , 2012, PLoS Comput. Biol..

[6]  Kyung-In Jang,et al.  3D multifunctional integumentary membranes for spatiotemporal cardiac measurements and stimulation across the entire epicardium , 2014, Nature Communications.

[7]  H. Hachiya,et al.  Role of Arrhythmogenic Superior Vena Cava on Atrial Fibrillation , 2014, Journal of cardiovascular electrophysiology.

[8]  José Jalife,et al.  Ionic determinants of functional reentry in a 2-D model of human atrial cells during simulated chronic atrial fibrillation. , 2005, Biophysical journal.

[9]  José Jalife,et al.  2017 HRS/EHRA/ECAS/APHRS/SOLAECE expert consensus statement on catheter and surgical ablation of atrial fibrillation , 2012, Heart rhythm.

[10]  Z. Qu Critical mass hypothesis revisited: role of dynamical wave stability in spontaneous termination of cardiac fibrillation. , 2006, American journal of physiology. Heart and circulatory physiology.

[11]  Prashanthan Sanders,et al.  Epicardial wave mapping in human long-lasting persistent atrial fibrillation: transient rotational circuits, complex wavefronts, and disorganized activity. , 2014, European heart journal.

[12]  Alexander V Panfilov,et al.  Anisotropy of wave propagation in the heart can be modeled by a Riemannian electrophysiological metric , 2010, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[13]  Peter Spector,et al.  Principles of Cardiac Electric Propagation and Their Implications for Re-entrant Arrhythmias , 2013, Circulation. Arrhythmia and electrophysiology.

[14]  Sanjiv M Narayan,et al.  Stability of Rotors and Focal Sources for Human Atrial Fibrillation: Focal Impulse and Rotor Mapping (FIRM) of AF Sources and Fibrillatory Conduction , 2014, Journal of cardiovascular electrophysiology.

[15]  Edward G Lakatta,et al.  &bgr;-Adrenergic Stimulation Modulates Ryanodine Receptor Ca2+ Release During Diastolic Depolarization to Accelerate Pacemaker Activity in Rabbit Sinoatrial Nodal Cells , 2002, Circulation research.

[16]  J. Bates,et al.  Ablation of multi-wavelet re-entry: general principles and in silico analyses. , 2012, Europace : European pacing, arrhythmias, and cardiac electrophysiology : journal of the working groups on cardiac pacing, arrhythmias, and cardiac cellular electrophysiology of the European Society of Cardiology.

[17]  L. J. Leon,et al.  Cholinergic Atrial Fibrillation in a Computer Model of a Two-Dimensional Sheet of Canine Atrial Cells With Realistic Ionic Properties , 2002, Circulation research.

[18]  V Jacquemet,et al.  Fully automated initiation of simulated episodes of atrial arrhythmias. , 2012, Europace : European pacing, arrhythmias, and cardiac electrophysiology : journal of the working groups on cardiac pacing, arrhythmias, and cardiac cellular electrophysiology of the European Society of Cardiology.

[19]  D. Geman,et al.  Computational Medicine: Translating Models to Clinical Care , 2012 .

[20]  Frank B. Sachse,et al.  Towards Modeling of Cardiac Micro-Structure With Catheter-Based Confocal Microscopy: A Novel Approach for Dye Delivery and Tissue Characterization , 2009, IEEE Transactions on Medical Imaging.

[21]  Henggui Zhang,et al.  An Image-Based Model of Atrial Muscular Architecture: Effects of Structural Anisotropy on Electrical Activation , 2012, Circulation. Arrhythmia and electrophysiology.

[22]  Henggui Zhang,et al.  3D virtual human atria: A computational platform for studying clinical atrial fibrillation. , 2011, Progress in biophysics and molecular biology.

[23]  K. Nademanee,et al.  A new approach for catheter ablation of atrial fibrillation: mapping of the electrophysiologic substrate. , 2004, Journal of the American College of Cardiology.

[24]  M. Allessie,et al.  Configuration of unipolar atrial electrograms during electrically induced atrial fibrillation in humans. , 1997, Circulation.

[25]  Nathalie Virag,et al.  A biophysical model of atrial fibrillation ablation: what can a surgeon learn from a computer model? , 2007, Europace : European pacing, arrhythmias, and cardiac electrophysiology : journal of the working groups on cardiac pacing, arrhythmias, and cardiac cellular electrophysiology of the European Society of Cardiology.

[26]  Gernot Plank,et al.  Mechanistic inquiry into the role of tissue remodeling in fibrotic lesions in human atrial fibrillation. , 2013, Biophysical journal.

[27]  Tachapong Ngarmukos,et al.  Clinical outcomes of catheter substrate ablation for high-risk patients with atrial fibrillation. , 2008, Journal of the American College of Cardiology.

[28]  Henggui Zhang,et al.  Scroll Waves in 3D Virtual Human Atria: A Computational Study , 2007, FIMH.

[29]  J Clémenty,et al.  Spontaneous initiation of atrial fibrillation by ectopic beats originating in the pulmonary veins. , 1998, The New England journal of medicine.

[30]  Sanjiv M Narayan,et al.  Ablation of rotor and focal sources reduces late recurrence of atrial fibrillation compared with trigger ablation alone: extended follow-up of the CONFIRM trial (Conventional Ablation for Atrial Fibrillation With or Without Focal Impulse and Rotor Modulation). , 2014, Journal of the American College of Cardiology.

[31]  Jean-Marc Vesin,et al.  Systematic comparison of non-invasive measures for the assessment of atrial fibrillation complexity: a step forward towards standardization of atrial fibrillation electrogram analysis. , 2015, Europace : European pacing, arrhythmias, and cardiac electrophysiology : journal of the working groups on cardiac pacing, arrhythmias, and cardiac cellular electrophysiology of the European Society of Cardiology.

[32]  Joshua J. E. Blauer,et al.  Virtual Electrophysiological Study of Atrial Fibrillation in Fibrotic Remodeling , 2015, PloS one.

[33]  Nathalie Virag,et al.  Modeling of Atrial Fibrillation , 2012 .

[34]  Olaf Dössel,et al.  Preventive Ablation Strategies in a Biophysical Model of Atrial Fibrillation Based on Realistic Anatomical Data , 2008, IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering.

[35]  R. Lazzara,et al.  Autonomic mechanism for initiation of rapid firing from atria and pulmonary veins: evidence by ablation of ganglionated plexi. , 2009, Cardiovascular research.

[36]  Ashok J. Shah,et al.  Driver Domains in Persistent Atrial Fibrillation , 2014, Circulation.

[37]  C. Henriquez,et al.  Study of atrial arrhythmias in a computer model based on magnetic resonance images of human atria. , 2002, Chaos.

[38]  Henggui Zhang,et al.  Application of Micro-Computed Tomography With Iodine Staining to Cardiac Imaging, Segmentation, and Computational Model Development , 2013, IEEE Transactions on Medical Imaging.

[39]  Stefano Pedretti,et al.  Onset mechanism of paroxysmal atrial fibrillation detected by ambulatory Holter monitoring. , 2006, Europace : European pacing, arrhythmias, and cardiac electrophysiology : journal of the working groups on cardiac pacing, arrhythmias, and cardiac cellular electrophysiology of the European Society of Cardiology.

[40]  Jichao Zhao,et al.  Atrial fibrillation driven by micro-anatomic intramural re-entry revealed by simultaneous sub-epicardial and sub-endocardial optical mapping in explanted human hearts. , 2015, European heart journal.

[41]  S. Nattel,et al.  Importance of refractoriness heterogeneity in the enhanced vulnerability to atrial fibrillation induction caused by tachycardia-induced atrial electrical remodeling. , 1998, Circulation.

[42]  W. Rappel,et al.  Clinical Mapping Approach To Diagnose Electrical Rotors and Focal Impulse Sources for Human Atrial Fibrillation , 2012, Journal of cardiovascular electrophysiology.

[43]  N. Virag,et al.  Evaluation of Ablation Patterns Using a Biophysical Model of Atrial Fibrillation , 2005, Annals of Biomedical Engineering.

[44]  Soon-Sung Kwon,et al.  Virtual ablation for atrial fibrillation in personalized in-silico three-dimensional left atrial modeling: comparison with clinical catheter ablation. , 2014, Progress in biophysics and molecular biology.

[45]  Mathias Wilhelms,et al.  Benchmarking electrophysiological models of human atrial myocytes , 2013, Front. Physio..

[46]  Nathalie Virag,et al.  A biophysical model of atrial fibrillation to define the appropriate ablation pattern in modified maze. , 2007, European journal of cardio-thoracic surgery : official journal of the European Association for Cardio-thoracic Surgery.

[47]  Kawal S. Rhode,et al.  Personalization of Atrial Anatomy and Electrophysiology as a Basis for Clinical Modeling of Radio-Frequency Ablation of Atrial Fibrillation , 2013, IEEE Transactions on Medical Imaging.

[48]  N. Peters,et al.  Intrinsic Cardiac Autonomic Stimulation Induces Pulmonary Vein Ectopy and Triggers Atrial Fibrillation in Humans , 2011, Journal of cardiovascular electrophysiology.

[49]  B. Knight,et al.  Approaches to catheter ablation of persistent atrial fibrillation. , 2009, Heart rhythm.

[50]  P. Santangeli,et al.  Adjunct ablation strategies for persistent atrial fibrillation-beyond pulmonary vein isolation. , 2015, Journal of thoracic disease.

[51]  Stanley Nattel,et al.  The effect of vagally induced dispersion of action potential duration on atrial arrhythmogenesis. , 2004, Heart rhythm.

[52]  J. Jalife,et al.  Human Atrial Action Potential and Ca2+ Model: Sinus Rhythm and Chronic Atrial Fibrillation , 2011, Circulation research.

[53]  P B Corr,et al.  The surgical treatment of atrial fibrillation. III. Development of a definitive surgical procedure. , 1991, The Journal of thoracic and cardiovascular surgery.

[54]  M. Lesh,et al.  Fractionated electrograms from a computer model of heterogeneously uncoupled anisotropic ventricular myocardium. , 1995, Circulation.

[55]  A. Holden,et al.  Heterogeneous three-dimensional anatomical and electrophysiological model of human atria , 2006, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A: Mathematical, Physical and Engineering Sciences.

[56]  Michel Haïssaguerre,et al.  Impact of Varying Ablation Patterns in a Simulation Model of Persistent Atrial Fibrillation , 2007, Pacing and clinical electrophysiology : PACE.

[57]  Sanjiv M. Narayan,et al.  Panoramic Electrophysiological Mapping but Not Electrogram Morphology Identifies Stable Sources for Human Atrial Fibrillation: Stable Atrial Fibrillation Rotors and Focal Sources Relate Poorly to Fractionated , 2022 .

[58]  Gernot Plank,et al.  Methodology for patient-specific modeling of atrial fibrosis as a substrate for atrial fibrillation. , 2012, Journal of electrocardiology.

[59]  Cristian Lorenz,et al.  Modeling Atrial Fiber Orientation in Patient-Specific Geometries: A Semi-automatic Rule-Based Approach , 2011, FIMH.

[60]  C. Tai,et al.  Predictors of non-pulmonary vein ectopic beats initiating paroxysmal atrial fibrillation: implication for catheter ablation. , 2005, Journal of the American College of Cardiology.

[61]  Yi Shen,et al.  Meta-analysis of the therapeutic effects of various methods for the treatment of chronic atrial fibrillation , 2013, Experimental and therapeutic medicine.

[62]  S Nattel,et al.  Mathematical analysis of canine atrial action potentials: rate, regional factors, and electrical remodeling. , 2000, American journal of physiology. Heart and circulatory physiology.

[63]  Natalia A Trayanova,et al.  Mechanisms of Human Atrial Fibrillation Initiation: Clinical and Computational Studies of Repolarization Restitution and Activation Latency , 2012, Circulation. Arrhythmia and electrophysiology.

[64]  Vincent Jacquemet,et al.  Genesis of complex fractionated atrial electrograms in zones of slow conduction: a computer model of microfibrosis. , 2009, Heart rhythm.

[65]  Richard Sutton,et al.  International consensus on nomenclature and classification of atrial fibrillation: A collaborative project of the Working Group on Arrhythmias and the Working Group of Cardiac Pacing of the European Society of Cardiology and the North American Society of Pacing and Electrophysiology. , 2003, Journal of cardiovascular electrophysiology.

[66]  S Nattel,et al.  Ionic targets for drug therapy and atrial fibrillation-induced electrical remodeling: insights from a mathematical model. , 1999, Cardiovascular research.

[67]  B. Lindsay,et al.  Noninvasive Characterization of Epicardial Activation in Humans With Diverse Atrial Fibrillation Patterns , 2010, Circulation.

[68]  Sabine Ernst,et al.  Catheter-induced linear lesions in the left atrium in patients with atrial fibrillation: an electroanatomic study. , 2003, Journal of the American College of Cardiology.

[69]  Mathias Wilhelms,et al.  Computational modeling of the human atrial anatomy and electrophysiology , 2012, Medical & Biological Engineering & Computing.

[70]  Qi-na Zhou,et al.  A Meta‐Analysis of the Comparative Efficacy of Ablation for Atrial Fibrillation with and without Ablation of the Ganglionated Plexi , 2011, Pacing and clinical electrophysiology : PACE.

[71]  V. Jacquemet,et al.  Modeling Atrial Arrhythmias: Impact on Clinical Diagnosis and Therapies , 2008, IEEE Reviews in Biomedical Engineering.

[72]  Christopher McGann,et al.  Atrial Fibrillation Ablation Outcome Is Predicted by Left Atrial Remodeling on MRI , 2014, Circulation. Arrhythmia and electrophysiology.

[73]  Robert Plonsey,et al.  Bioelectricity: A Quantitative Approach Duke University’s First MOOC , 2013 .

[74]  Vadim V Fedorov,et al.  Chessboard of atrial fibrillation: reentry or focus? Single or multiple source(s)? Neurogenic or myogenic? , 2005, American journal of physiology. Heart and circulatory physiology.

[75]  Nathalie Virag,et al.  Wavelength and vulnerability to atrial fibrillation: Insights from a computer model of human atria. , 2005, Europace : European pacing, arrhythmias, and cardiac electrophysiology : journal of the working groups on cardiac pacing, arrhythmias, and cardiac cellular electrophysiology of the European Society of Cardiology.

[76]  Natalia A Trayanova,et al.  Mathematical approaches to understanding and imaging atrial fibrillation: significance for mechanisms and management. , 2014, Circulation research.

[77]  Vincent Jacquemet,et al.  Eikonal-based initiation of fibrillatory activity in thin-walled cardiac propagation models. , 2011, Chaos.

[78]  Cristian Lorenz,et al.  Automatic Segmentation of Cardiac CTs - Personalized Atrial Models Augmented with Electrophysiological Structures , 2011, FIMH.

[79]  Christopher X. Wong,et al.  Paroxysmal lone atrial fibrillation is associated with an abnormal atrial substrate: characterizing the "second factor". , 2009, Journal of the American College of Cardiology.

[80]  S. Knecht,et al.  Long-term follow-up of persistent atrial fibrillation ablation using termination as a procedural endpoint. , 2009, European heart journal.

[81]  Carlos Sánchez,et al.  Inter-Subject Variability in Human Atrial Action Potential in Sinus Rhythm versus Chronic Atrial Fibrillation , 2014, PloS one.

[82]  P Coumel,et al.  Paroxysmal atrial fibrillation: a disorder of autonomic tone? , 1994, European heart journal.

[83]  J Clémenty,et al.  Mapping and ablation of left atrial flutters. , 2000, Circulation.

[84]  Jens Eckstein,et al.  Role of endo-epicardial dissociation of electrical activity and transmural conduction in the development of persistent atrial fibrillation. , 2014, Progress in biophysics and molecular biology.

[85]  Andrew D McCulloch,et al.  Structural contributions to fibrillatory rotors in a patient-derived computational model of the atria. , 2014, Europace : European pacing, arrhythmias, and cardiac electrophysiology : journal of the working groups on cardiac pacing, arrhythmias, and cardiac cellular electrophysiology of the European Society of Cardiology.

[86]  Prashanthan Sanders,et al.  Long‐term Outcomes of Catheter Ablation of Atrial Fibrillation: A Systematic Review and Meta‐analysis , 2013, Journal of the American Heart Association.

[87]  C. Henriquez,et al.  A computer model of normal conduction in the human atria. , 2000, Circulation research.

[88]  Vincent Jacquemet,et al.  Dynamics of atrial arrhythmias modulated by time-dependent acetylcholine concentration: a simulation study. , 2014, Europace : European pacing, arrhythmias, and cardiac electrophysiology : journal of the working groups on cardiac pacing, arrhythmias, and cardiac cellular electrophysiology of the European Society of Cardiology.

[89]  Wei-Shiang Lin,et al.  Catheter Ablation of Paroxysmal Atrial Fibrillation Initiated by Non–Pulmonary Vein Ectopy , 2003, Circulation.

[90]  Jian-zeng Dong,et al.  Additional Ablation of Complex Fractionated Atrial Electrograms After Pulmonary Vein Isolation in Patients With Atrial Fibrillation: A Meta-Analysis , 2011, Circulation. Arrhythmia and electrophysiology.

[91]  Gunnar Seemann,et al.  Patient-specific modeling of atrial fibrosis increases the accuracy of sinus rhythm simulations and may explain maintenance of atrial fibrillation. , 2014, Journal of electrocardiology.

[92]  Alan Garfinkel,et al.  Mechanism Underlying Initiation of Paroxysmal Atrial Flutter/Atrial Fibrillation by Ectopic Foci: A Simulation Study , 2007, Circulation.

[93]  Stanley Nattel,et al.  The clinical profile and pathophysiology of atrial fibrillation: relationships among clinical features, epidemiology, and mechanisms. , 2014, Circulation research.

[94]  Nathalie Virag,et al.  Use of a biophysical model of atrial fibrillation in the interpretation of the outcome of surgical ablation procedures. , 2007, European journal of cardio-thoracic surgery : official journal of the European Association for Cardio-thoracic Surgery.

[95]  Mark Potse,et al.  A Comparison of Monodomain and Bidomain Reaction-Diffusion Models for Action Potential Propagation in the Human Heart , 2006, IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering.

[96]  M. Courtemanche,et al.  Ionic mechanisms underlying human atrial action potential properties: insights from a mathematical model. , 1998, The American journal of physiology.

[97]  R. Cardinal,et al.  Simultaneous Epicardial and Noncontact Endocardial Mapping of the Canine Right Atrium: Simulation and Experiment , 2014, PloS one.

[98]  L V Chireikin,et al.  Morphology of inter-atrial conduction routes in patients with atrial fibrillation. , 2002, Europace : European pacing, arrhythmias, and cardiac electrophysiology : journal of the working groups on cardiac pacing, arrhythmias, and cardiac cellular electrophysiology of the European Society of Cardiology.

[99]  Rodrigo Weber dos Santos,et al.  Electroanatomical Characterization of Atrial Microfibrosis in a Histologically Detailed Computer Model , 2013, IEEE Transactions on Biomedical Engineering.

[100]  Craig S Henriquez,et al.  A microstructural model of reentry arising from focal breakthrough at sites of source-load mismatch in a central region of slow conduction. , 2014, American journal of physiology. Heart and circulatory physiology.

[101]  Henggui Zhang,et al.  Pro-arrhythmogenic effects of atrial fibrillation-induced electrical remodelling: insights from the three-dimensional virtual human atria , 2013, The Journal of physiology.

[102]  Adarsh Krishnamurthy,et al.  A three-dimensional finite element model of human atrial anatomy: New methods for cubic Hermite meshes with extraordinary vertices , 2013, Medical Image Anal..

[103]  Jichao Zhao,et al.  Optimization of Catheter Ablation of Atrial Fibrillation: Insights Gained from Clinically-Derived Computer Models , 2015, International journal of molecular sciences.

[104]  V. Jacquemet,et al.  Analysis of electrocardiograms during atrial fibrillation , 2006, IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Magazine.