Integrating transcriptomic techniques and k-means clustering in metabolomics to identify markers of abiotic and biotic stress in Medicago truncatula

IntroductionNitrogen-fixing legumes are invaluable crops, but are sensitive to physical and biological stresses. Whilst drought and infection from the soil-borne pathogen Fusarium oxysporum have been studied individually, their combined effects have not been widely investigated.ObjectivesWe aimed to determine the effect of combined stress using methods usually associated with transcriptomics to detect metabolic differences between treatment groups that could not be identified by more traditional means, such as principal component analysis and partial least squares discriminant analysis.MethodsLiquid chromatography-high resolution mass spectrometry data from the root and leaves of model legume Medicago truncatula were analysed using Gaussian Process 2-Sample Test, k-means cluster analysis and temporal clustering by affinity propagation.ResultsMetabolic differences were detected: we identified known stress markers, including changes in concentration for sucrose and citric acid, and showed that combined stress can exacerbate the effect of drought. Changes in roots were found to be smaller than those in leaves, but differences due to Fusarium infection were identified. The transfer of sucrose from leaves to roots can be seen in the time series using transcriptomic techniques with the metabolomics time series. Other metabolite concentrations that change as a result of treatment include phosphoric acid, malic acid and tetrahydroxychalcone.ConclusionsProbing metabolomic data with transcriptomic tools provides new insights and could help to identify resilient plant varieties, thereby increasing future crop yield and improving food security.

[1]  Zoubin Ghahramani,et al.  A Robust Bayesian Two-Sample Test for Detecting Intervals of Differential Gene Expression in Microarray Time Series , 2009, RECOMB.

[2]  Nicolas Rispail,et al.  Rapid and Efficient Estimation of Pea Resistance to the Soil-Borne Pathogen Fusarium oxysporum by Infrared Imaging , 2015, Sensors.

[3]  P. Mullineaux,et al.  Responses of the pea (Pisumsativum L.) leaf metabolome to drought stress assessed by nuclear magnetic resonance spectroscopy , 2008, Metabolomics.

[4]  Christoph Steinbeck,et al.  The role of reporting standards for metabolite annotation and identification in metabolomic studies , 2013, GigaScience.

[5]  Christopher A. Penfold,et al.  High-Resolution Temporal Profiling of Transcripts during Arabidopsis Leaf Senescence Reveals a Distinct Chronology of Processes and Regulation[C][W][OA] , 2011, Plant Cell.

[6]  A. Pietro,et al.  Fusarium oxysporum: exploring the molecular arsenal of a vascular wilt fungus. , 2003, Molecular plant pathology.

[7]  Doreen Ware,et al.  The iPlant Collaborative: Cyberinfrastructure for Enabling Data to Discovery for the Life Sciences , 2016, PLoS biology.

[8]  T. Altmann,et al.  Phenotypic and metabolic responses to drought and salinity of four contrasting lentil accessions , 2015, Journal of experimental botany.

[9]  M. Persicke,et al.  High specificity in plant leaf metabolic responses to arbuscular mycorrhiza , 2014, Nature Communications.

[10]  Y. Martinez,et al.  A study on the susceptibility of the model legume plant Medicago truncatula to the soil-borne pathogen Fusarium oxysporum , 2010, European Journal of Plant Pathology.

[11]  Simon O'Keefe,et al.  A batch correction method for liquid chromatography–mass spectrometry data that does not depend on quality control samples , 2016, Metabolomics.

[12]  P. Casati,et al.  Flavonoids: biosynthesis, biological functions, and biotechnological applications , 2012, Front. Plant Sci..

[13]  Age K. Smilde,et al.  Data-processing strategies for metabolomics studies , 2011 .

[14]  Zoubin Ghahramani,et al.  A Robust Bayesian Two-Sample Test for Detecting Intervals of Differential Gene Expression in Microarray Time Series , 2009, RECOMB.

[15]  Suha Jabaji,et al.  A Metabolic Profiling Strategy for the Dissection of Plant Defense against Fungal Pathogens , 2014, PloS one.

[16]  J. Flexas,et al.  Photosynthesis under drought and salt stress: regulation mechanisms from whole plant to cell. , 2009, Annals of botany.

[17]  Delbert Dueck,et al.  Clustering by Passing Messages Between Data Points , 2007, Science.

[18]  Christopher A. Penfold,et al.  Time-Series Transcriptomics Reveals That AGAMOUS-LIKE22 Affects Primary Metabolism and Developmental Processes in Drought-Stressed Arabidopsis[CC-BY] , 2016, Plant Cell.

[19]  Justyna Mierziak,et al.  Flavonoids as Important Molecules of Plant Interactions with the Environment , 2014, Molecules.

[20]  Ron Wehrens,et al.  Improved batch correction in untargeted MS-based metabolomics , 2016, Metabolomics.

[21]  Kwanjeera Wanichthanarak,et al.  Genomic, Proteomic, and Metabolomic Data Integration Strategies , 2015, Biomarker insights.

[22]  Maria Manuela Chaves,et al.  Effects of Water Deficits on Carbon Assimilation , 1991 .

[23]  Malika Charrad,et al.  NbClust: An R Package for Determining the Relevant Number of Clusters in a Data Set , 2014 .

[24]  B. S. Manjunath,et al.  The iPlant Collaborative: Cyberinfrastructure for Plant Biology , 2011, Front. Plant Sci..

[25]  D. Klessig,et al.  Environmentally sensitive, SA-dependent defense responses in the cpr22 mutant of Arabidopsis. , 2001, The Plant journal : for cell and molecular biology.

[26]  Reinhard Laubenbacher,et al.  Bioinformatics tools for cancer metabolomics , 2011, Metabolomics.

[27]  P. Trost,et al.  Dehydroascorbate Influences the Plant Cell Cycle through a Glutathione-Independent Reduction Mechanism , 2004, Plant Physiology.

[28]  Sach Mukherjee,et al.  Temporal clustering by affinity propagation reveals transcriptional modules in Arabidopsis thaliana , 2010, Bioinform..

[29]  A. Fernie,et al.  Metabolomics-assisted breeding: a viable option for crop improvement? , 2009, Trends in genetics : TIG.

[30]  M. Crespi,et al.  Abiotic Stress Responses in Legumes: Strategies Used to Cope with Environmental Challenges , 2015 .

[31]  Alvaro J. González,et al.  The Medicago Genome Provides Insight into the Evolution of Rhizobial Symbioses , 2011, Nature.

[32]  Synan F. AbuQamar,et al.  Crosstalk between biotic and abiotic stress responses in tomato is mediated by the AIM1 transcription factor. , 2009, The Plant journal : for cell and molecular biology.

[33]  C. H. Beckman,et al.  The Nature of Wilt Diseases of Plants , 1987 .

[34]  V. Pastor,et al.  Jasmonate signaling in plant development and defense response to multiple (a)biotic stresses , 2013, Plant Cell Reports.

[35]  Chunji Liu,et al.  Effects of Drought-Stress on Fusarium Crown Rot Development in Barley , 2016, PloS one.

[36]  E. Barile,et al.  Flavonoids from carnation (Dianthus caryophyllus) and their antifungal activity , 2008 .

[37]  M. M. Chaves,et al.  Alterations in carbon and nitrogen metabolism induced by water deficit in the stems and leaves of Lupinus albus L. , 2001, Journal of experimental botany.

[38]  R. Mittler,et al.  Genetic engineering for modern agriculture: challenges and perspectives. , 2010, Annual review of plant biology.

[39]  Nicholas A. Heard,et al.  Iterative Reclassification in Agglomerative Clustering , 2011 .

[40]  Susanne Rasmussen,et al.  REVIEW: PART OF A HIGHLIGHT ON BREEDING STRATEGIES FOR FORAGE AND GRASS IMPROVEMENT Metabolomics of forage plants: a review , 2012 .

[41]  A. Weber,et al.  Transcriptional profiling of Arabidopsis heat shock proteins and transcription factors reveals extensive overlap between heat and non-heat stress response pathways , 2007, BMC Genomics.

[42]  Peng Gao,et al.  Application of fuzzy c-means clustering in data analysis of metabolomics. , 2009, Analytical chemistry.

[43]  Johan Trygg,et al.  Chemometrics in metabolomics--a review in human disease diagnosis. , 2010, Analytica chimica acta.

[44]  Henning Redestig,et al.  Integrative functional genomics of salt acclimatization in the model legume Lotus japonicus. , 2007, The Plant journal : for cell and molecular biology.

[45]  J. A. Westerhuis,et al.  Bagged K-Means Clustering of Metabolome Data , 2006 .

[46]  Alisdair R Fernie,et al.  Metabolic and phenotypic responses of greenhouse-grown maize hybrids to experimentally controlled drought stress. , 2012, Molecular plant.

[47]  S. Munné-Bosch,et al.  Distinctive phytohormonal and metabolic profiles of Arabidopsis thaliana and Eutrema salsugineum under similar soil drying , 2019, Planta.

[48]  Emily L. Kang,et al.  Computational and statistical analysis of metabolomics data , 2015, Metabolomics.

[49]  P. Mullineaux,et al.  The influence of the light environment and photosynthesis on oxidative signalling responses in plant-biotrophic pathogen interactions , 2005 .

[50]  A. Di Pietro,et al.  A MAP kinase of the vascular wilt fungus Fusarium oxysporum is essential for root penetration and pathogenesis , 2001, Molecular microbiology.