Progress in vibrotactile threshold evaluation techniques: a review.

Vibrotactile threshold (VT) testing has been used for nearly a century to investigate activation of human somatosensory pathways. This use of vibrotactile stimuli provides a versatile tool for detecting peripheral neuropathies, and has been broadly used for investigation of carpal tunnel syndrome. New applications include investigation of drug-induced neuropathies and diabetes-related neuropathies. As a feedback device, the vibrotactile stimuli could be used as an information delivery system for rehabilitative feedback devices for upper limb musculoskeletal disorders or as information channels for the visually impaired. This review provides a comprehensive review of the advancement in VT measurement techniques over time and a comparison of these techniques in terms of various hardware features used and the testing protocols implemented. The advantages and limitations of these methods have been discussed along with specific recommendations for their implementation and suggestions for incorporation into clinical practice.

[1]  J. Zwislocki,et al.  On the Effect of Practice and Motivation on the Threshold of Audibility , 1958 .

[2]  D. Calne,et al.  Vibratory sense: a critical review. , 1966, Brain : a journal of neurology.

[3]  R. Tuckett Response of cutaneous hair and field mechanoreceptors in cat to paired mechanical stimuli. , 1978, Journal of neurophysiology.

[4]  I. Pyykkö,et al.  Vibration-induced neuropathy. Detection by nerve conduction measurements. , 1987, Scandinavian journal of work, environment & health.

[5]  Stanley J. Bolanowski,et al.  Vibrotactile thresholds of the Non-Pacinian I channel: I. Methodological issues , 2005, Somatosensory & motor research.

[6]  Clinical vs quantitative evaluation of cutaneous sensation. , 1976, Archives of neurology.

[7]  K W Horch,et al.  A key to the classification of cutaneous mechanoreceptors. , 1977, The Journal of investigative dermatology.

[8]  Gregory Neely,et al.  Gender differences in subjective responses to hand–arm vibration , 2006 .

[9]  C. R. Daniel,et al.  Vibrometry and Uremic Peripheral Neuropathy , 1977, Southern medical journal.

[10]  R. Letz,et al.  Covariates of human peripheral nerve function: II. Vibrotactile and thermal thresholds. , 1994, Neurotoxicology and teratology.

[11]  H. Sallé,et al.  Comparison of five methods for measurement of vibratory perception , 1984, International archives of occupational and environmental health.

[12]  K. Horch,et al.  An Automated Tactile Tester for evaluation of cutaneous sensibility. , 1992, The Journal of hand surgery.

[13]  Michael J Griffin,et al.  A comparison of vibrotactile thresholds obtained using different diagnostic equipment: the effect of contact conditions , 2002, International archives of occupational and environmental health.

[14]  M. Stuart,et al.  Effects of aging on vibration detection thresholds at various body regions , 2003, BMC geriatrics.

[15]  M SATO,et al.  Response of Pacinian corpuscles to sinusoidal vibration , 1961, The Journal of physiology.

[16]  J. Greening,et al.  Vibration sense in the upper limb in patients with repetitive strain injury and a group of at-risk office workers , 1998, International archives of occupational and environmental health.

[17]  Jeffrey N. Katz,et al.  Carpal tunnel syndrome , 1992 .

[18]  V. Tannan,et al.  A novel device for delivering two-site vibrotactile stimuli to the skin , 2005, Journal of Neuroscience Methods.

[19]  R Lundström,et al.  Vibrotactile perception threshold measurements for diagnosis of sensory neuropathy , 1992, International archives of occupational and environmental health.

[20]  Michael J Griffin,et al.  Normal values for thermotactile and vibrotactile thresholds in males and females , 2008, International archives of occupational and environmental health.

[21]  Stanley Finger,et al.  Origins of neuroscience: A history of explorations into brain function. , 1994 .

[22]  R. Treede,et al.  Quantitative sensory testing: a comprehensive protocol for clinical trials , 2006, European journal of pain.

[23]  R. T. Verrillo,et al.  Effects of root or nerve destruction on vibrotactile sensitivity in trigeminal neuralgia , 1977, Pain.

[24]  C. J. Keemink,et al.  Evidence for different types of mechanoreceptors from measurements of the psychophysical threshold for vibrations under different stimulation conditions. , 1988, The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America.

[25]  H. Virokannas Vibration perception thresholds in workers exposed to vibration , 1992, International archives of occupational and environmental health.

[26]  Michael J Griffin,et al.  Dependence of vibrotactile thresholds on the psychophysical measurement method , 2002, International archives of occupational and environmental health.

[27]  Setsuo Maeda,et al.  A pilot study of reference vibrotactile perception thresholds on the fingertip obtained with Malaysian healthy people using ISO 13091-1 equipment. , 2004, Industrial health.

[28]  A. Dellon The vibrometer. , 1983, Plastic and reconstructive surgery.

[29]  R Lundström,et al.  Effects of local vibration transmitted from ultrasonic devices on vibrotactile perception in the hands of therapists. , 1985, Ergonomics.

[30]  Vern O. Knudsen,et al.  “Hearing” with the Sense of Touch , 1928 .

[31]  M. Cherniack,et al.  A comparison of traditional electrodiagnostic studies, electroneurometry, and vibrometry in the diagnosis of carpal tunnel syndrome. , 1996, The Journal of hand surgery.

[32]  M Tommerdahl,et al.  Stimulus-dependent effects on tactile spatial acuity , 2005, Behavioral and Brain Functions.

[33]  S. Bolanowski,et al.  The effects of skin temperature on the psychophysical responses to vibration on glabrous and hairy skin. , 1986, The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America.

[34]  Y. Yonekawa,et al.  Thermotactile threshold testing for the evaluation of sensory nerve function in vibration-exposed patients and workers , 2002, International archives of occupational and environmental health.

[35]  D. Rempel,et al.  Effect of wrist posture on carpal tunnel pressure while typing , 2008, Journal of orthopaedic research : official publication of the Orthopaedic Research Society.

[36]  J. Congleton,et al.  Effect of menstruation on vibrotactile threshold in the peripheral median nerve , 1997 .

[37]  G. Miscio,et al.  Obesity and peripheral neuropathy risk: a dangerous liaison , 2005, Journal of the peripheral nervous system : JPNS.

[38]  G A Gescheider,et al.  The effects of a surround on vibrotactile thresholds. , 1978, Sensory processes.

[39]  Jeremy R. Cooperstock,et al.  Touch Is Everywhere: Floor Surfaces as Ambient Haptic Interfaces , 2009, IEEE Transactions on Haptics.

[40]  L. T. Robertson,et al.  Vibration perception thresholds of human maxillary and mandibular central incisors. , 2003, Archives of oral biology.

[41]  Robert A. Werner,et al.  Carpal tunnel syndrome: pathophysiology and clinical neurophysiology , 2002, Clinical Neurophysiology.

[42]  M. Griffin,et al.  Normative vibrotactile thresholds measured at five European test centres , 2003, International archives of occupational and environmental health.

[43]  M. Hollins,et al.  Adaptation-induced enhancement of vibrotactile amplitude discrimination: the role of adapting frequency. , 1996, The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America.

[44]  M. Alexander,et al.  Principles of Neural Science , 1981 .

[45]  G. Sjøgaard,et al.  Vibrotactile sense in patients with different upper limb disorders compared with a control group , 2006, International archives of occupational and environmental health.

[46]  R. Letz,et al.  Sensitivity and Specificity of Vibrometry for Detection of Carpal Tunnel Syndrome , 1995, Journal of Occupational and Environmental Medicine.

[47]  M. Griffin,et al.  Normative data for vascular and neurological tests of the hand-arm vibration syndrome , 2002, International archives of occupational and environmental health.

[48]  I Pyykkö,et al.  Digital vibrogram: a new diagnostic tool for sensory testing in compression neuropathy. , 1986, The Journal of hand surgery.

[49]  K. Horch,et al.  Rapid displacements of the skin lack clear positional information , 1984, Brain Research.

[50]  R. Gelberman,et al.  Sensibility testing in peripheral-nerve compression syndromes. An experimental study in humans. , 1983, The Journal of bone and joint surgery. American volume.

[51]  M Cherniack,et al.  Nerve conduction and sensorineural function in dental hygienists using high frequency ultrasound handpieces. , 2006, American journal of industrial medicine.

[52]  K. Horch,et al.  Response of cutaneous hair and field mechanoreceptors in cat to threshold stimuli. , 1978, Journal of neurophysiology.

[53]  J C Arezzo,et al.  Quantitative sensory testing , 2003, Neurology.

[54]  Jeffrey N Katz,et al.  Clinical practice. Carpal tunnel syndrome. , 2002, The New England journal of medicine.

[55]  M. Rowe,et al.  Vibrotactile frequency discrimination in human hairy skin. , 2006, Journal of neurophysiology.

[56]  E. Gregg Absolute measurement of the vibratory threshold. , 1951, A.M.A. archives of neurology and psychiatry.

[57]  V. Tannan,et al.  A portable tactile sensory diagnostic device , 2007, Journal of Neuroscience Methods.

[58]  R W Cholewiak,et al.  Vibrotactile threshold in young and old observers: the effects of spatial summation and the presence of a rigid surround. , 1996, The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America.

[59]  J. Bell-Krotoski Advances in sensibility evaluation. , 1991, Hand clinics.

[60]  W. Trojaborg,et al.  Long-term neurotoxicity in patients treated with cisplatin, vinblastine, and bleomycin for metastatic germ cell cancer. , 1989, Journal of clinical oncology : official journal of the American Society of Clinical Oncology.

[61]  M. Pilegaard,et al.  An 18-month follow-up study on vibrotactile sense, muscle strength and symptoms in computer users with and without symptoms , 2005, International archives of occupational and environmental health.

[62]  R. Letz,et al.  Vibrotactile threshold measurement for detecting neurotoxicity: reliability and determination of age- and height-standardized normative values. , 1990, Archives of environmental health.

[63]  W L Buford,et al.  The force/time relationship of clinically used sensory testing instruments. , 1997, Journal of hand therapy : official journal of the American Society of Hand Therapists.

[64]  H. Hämäläinen,et al.  Vibrotactile atonal interval correlated with activity in peripheral mechanoreceptive units innervating the human hand , 1985, Brain Research.

[65]  B L Whitsel,et al.  Time course and action spectrum of vibrotactile adaptation. , 1990, Somatosensory & motor research.

[66]  P. Haggard,et al.  Tactile sensitivity in Asperger syndrome , 2006, Brain and Cognition.

[67]  D. Rempel,et al.  Temperature effects on vibrotactile sensitivity threshold measurements: implications for carpal tunnel screening tests. , 1996, The Journal of hand surgery.

[68]  J. Duke,et al.  Vibrotactile threshold measurement for detecting peripheral neuropathy: defining variability and a normal range for clinical and research use , 2007, Diabetologia.

[69]  Ronnie Lundström,et al.  Neurological diagnosis – aspects of quantitative sensory testing methodology in relation to hand-arm vibration syndrome , 2002, International archives of occupational and environmental health.

[70]  J. A. Temlett An assessment of vibration threshold using a biothesiometer compared to a C128-Hz tuning fork , 2009, Journal of Clinical Neuroscience.

[71]  D. Cros,et al.  Technology literature review: Quantitative sensory testing , 2004, Muscle & nerve.

[72]  R. Letz,et al.  Covariates of human peripheral nerve function: III. Effects of reported drinking. , 1994, Neurotoxicology and teratology.

[73]  G. Lundborg,et al.  Vibrotactile function of the hand in compression and vibration-induced neuropathy. Sensibility index--a new measure. , 1992, Scandinavian journal of plastic and reconstructive surgery and hand surgery.

[74]  M. Pilegaard,et al.  Vibrotactile sense and mechanical functional state of the arm and hand among computer users compared with a control group , 2002, International archives of occupational and environmental health.

[75]  R. Tuckett,et al.  Quantitative threshold changes in cutaneous sensation of patients with burns. , 1991, The Journal of burn care & rehabilitation.

[76]  J. Lacourse,et al.  A high resolution vibrometry system for detecting carpal tunnel syndrome , 1995, Proceedings of 17th International Conference of the Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society.

[77]  M.D. Pottenger,et al.  Vibration absorbing brace for study of work-related upper extremity musculoskeletal disorders , 2004, The 26th Annual International Conference of the IEEE Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society.

[78]  G. Lundborg,et al.  Nerve growth factor impregnated fibronectin grafts as an alternative to nerve grafts for peripheral nerve repair in primates , 1997, Scandinavian journal of work, environment & health.

[79]  S J Bolanowski,et al.  Effects of hydration on tactile sensation. , 1998, Somatosensory & motor research.

[80]  A. Dellon The moving two-point discrimination test: clinical evaluation of the quickly adapting fiber/receptor system. , 1978, The Journal of hand surgery.

[81]  Donald S Bloswick,et al.  Effects of prolonged wrist flexion on transmission of sensory information in carpal tunnel syndrome. , 2007, The journal of pain : official journal of the American Pain Society.

[82]  Method for detecting small changes in vibrotactile perception threshold related to tactile acuity. , 2007, The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America.

[83]  R H Gelberman,et al.  The pathophysiology of nerve entrapment syndromes. , 1987, The Journal of hand surgery.

[84]  M. Millan,et al.  Vasopressin and oxytocin in the rat spinal cord: analysis of their role in the control of nociception , 1984, Brain Research.

[85]  Ren G Dong,et al.  Analysis of the biodynamic interaction between the fingertip and probe in the vibrotactile tests: the influences of the probe/fingertip contact orientation and static indentation. , 2009, Journal of biomechanics.

[86]  R. L. Wegel,et al.  The Frequency-sensitivity of Normal Ears. , 1922, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[87]  D. Cros,et al.  Quantitative sensory testing. , 2003, Physical medicine and rehabilitation clinics of North America.

[88]  R. T. Verrillo Psychophysics of vibrotactile stimulation. , 1985, The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America.

[89]  C B Novak,et al.  Evaluation of hand sensibility: a review. , 2001, Journal of hand therapy : official journal of the American Society of Hand Therapists.

[90]  B. Harazin,et al.  Measurements of vibrotactile perception thresholds at the fingertips in Poland. , 2005, Industrial health.

[91]  S. Bolanowski,et al.  Assessment of vibrotactile sensitivity in patients with carpal tunnel syndrome. , 1996, Journal of occupational and environmental medicine.

[92]  G. Lundborg,et al.  The Two-Point Discrimination Test – Time For a Re-Appraisal? , 2004, Journal of hand surgery.

[93]  S. Goldblatt Studies in pallesthesia; pallometer threshold values in 60 proved normal subjects. , 1956, The Journal of investigative dermatology.

[94]  M. Miyao,et al.  Digital nerve conduction velocity as a sensitive indication of peripheral neuropathy in vibration syndrome. , 1994, American journal of industrial medicine.

[95]  Vaughan G Macefield,et al.  Physiological characteristics of low‐threshold mechanoreceptors in joints, muscle and skin in human subjects , 2005, Clinical and experimental pharmacology & physiology.

[96]  R T Verrillo,et al.  Change in vibrotactile thresholds as a function of age. , 1979, Sensory processes.

[97]  J DE VECCHI,et al.  [Carpal tunnel syndrome]. , 1960, La Semana medica.

[98]  M. Swash,et al.  Slowed nerve conduction with wrist flexion in carpal tunnel syndrome , 1980, Annals of neurology.

[99]  M. Hollins,et al.  Perceived intensity of vibrotactile stimuli: the role of mechanoreceptive channels. , 1996, Somatosensory & motor research.

[100]  S. Bolanowski,et al.  Four channels mediate the mechanical aspects of touch. , 1988, The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America.

[101]  C. Spence,et al.  Attentional limitations in processing sequentially presented vibrotactile targets , 2002, Perception & psychophysics.

[102]  M. Hagberg,et al.  Vibrotactile perception and effects of short-term exposure to hand-arm vibration. , 2009, The Annals of occupational hygiene.

[103]  G. Schwartz,et al.  Lateralized sensitivity to vibrotactile stimulation: Individual differences revealed by interaction of threshold and signal detection tasks , 1981, Neuropsychologia.

[104]  S. Goldblatt Studies in pallesthesia; depression of vibratory sense levels in lupus erythematosus. , 1954, The Journal of investigative dermatology.

[105]  L. Cohen,et al.  Studies in Vibratory Sensibility , 1938 .

[106]  M. Rowe,et al.  Perceived pitch of vibrotactile stimuli: effects of vibration amplitude, and implications for vibration frequency coding. , 1990, The Journal of physiology.

[107]  C. Fowler,et al.  Cisplatin neurotoxicity in the treatment of metastatic germ cell tumour: time course and prognosis , 2001, British Journal of Cancer.

[108]  A L Dellon,et al.  Reliability of two-point discrimination measurements. , 1987, The Journal of hand surgery.

[109]  S. S. Stevens The Psychophysics of Sensory Function. , 1960 .

[110]  Kenneth O. Johnson,et al.  The roles and functions of cutaneous mechanoreceptors , 2001, Current Opinion in Neurobiology.

[111]  Kenneth O. Johnson,et al.  Tactile Functions of Mechanoreceptive Afferents Innervating the Hand , 2000, Journal of clinical neurophysiology : official publication of the American Electroencephalographic Society.

[112]  K. Horch,et al.  A study of sensory recovery following carpal tunnel release. , 1993, Journal of hand therapy : official journal of the American Society of Hand Therapists.

[113]  M. Botte,et al.  Carpal tunnel syndrome. An evaluation of the provocative diagnostic tests. , 1986, The Journal of bone and joint surgery. American volume.

[114]  Rocío Alcalá-Quintana,et al.  A comparison of fixed-step-size and Bayesian staircases for sensory threshold estimation. , 2007, Spatial vision.

[115]  M. Tommerdahl,et al.  Human vibrotactile frequency discriminative capacity after adaptation to 25 Hz or 200 Hz stimulation , 2005, Brain Research.

[116]  T. Cook,et al.  Vibration sensibility testing in the workplace. Day-to-day reliability. , 1994, Journal of occupational medicine. : official publication of the Industrial Medical Association.

[117]  M. Hollins,et al.  Vibrotactile adaptation enhances frequency discrimination. , 1994, The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America.

[118]  P. Wild,et al.  Vibrotactile perception thresholds in four non-exposed populations of working age , 2001, Ergonomics.

[119]  T. Spector,et al.  The genetic contribution to carpal tunnel syndrome in women: a twin study. , 2002, Arthritis and rheumatism.

[120]  M. Hirata,et al.  Affected segments of the median nerve detected by fractionated nerve conduction measurement in vibration-induced neuropathy. , 1998, Industrial health.

[121]  J. Macdermid,et al.  Quantitative vibration threshold testing in carpal tunnel syndrome: analysis strategies for optimizing reliability. , 2004, Journal of hand therapy : official journal of the American Society of Hand Therapists.

[122]  S. Y. Kao,et al.  Carpal tunnel syndrome as an occupational disease. , 2003, The Journal of the American Board of Family Practice.

[123]  B G Green Vibrotactile temporal summation: effect of frequency. , 1976, Sensory processes.

[124]  William L. Buford Clinical assessment, objectivity, and the ubiquitous laws of instrumentation. , 1995, Journal of hand therapy : official journal of the American Society of Hand Therapists.

[125]  I Pyykkö,et al.  A new principle for assessing vibrotactile sense in vibration-induced neuropathy. , 1987, Scandinavian journal of work, environment & health.

[126]  L. Ferrucci,et al.  Physiological correlates of age-related decline in vibrotactile sensitivity , 2008, Neurobiology of Aging.

[127]  Ulf Lindblom,et al.  Increase of vibration threshold during wrist flexion in patients with carpal tunnel syndrome , 1986, Pain.

[128]  K. Anderson Vibration induced neuropathy , 1985 .

[129]  I. Pyykkö,et al.  Quantitative test for sensory hand symptoms based on mechanoreceptor-specific vibrotactile thresholds. , 2010, The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America.

[130]  Donna Mergler,et al.  Measurement precision of a portable instrument to assess vibrotactile perception threshold , 2004, European Journal of Applied Physiology and Occupational Physiology.

[131]  R Letz,et al.  Vibrotactile threshold testing in occupational health: a review of current issues and limitations. , 1993, Environmental research.

[132]  M. Griffin,et al.  Effect of contact location on vibrotactile thresholds at the fingertip , 2006, Somatosensory & motor research.