Efficiency comparison between Brushless dc motor and Brushless AC motor considering driving method and machine design

This paper describes an approach to establish high efficient drive such a Brushless AC (BLAC) drive by a Brushless DC (BLDC) drive. BLDC drive which is excited rectangular voltage for 120 electrical degrees per cycle is commonly used for the low cost applications of Permanent Magnet Synchronous Motors (PMSMs). This drive method contains low-order harmonics in the current waveform. These harmonics cause a mechanical vibration and the electrical losses. Therefore, BLDC drive is not applicable to the sinusoidal back-EMF machines. However, considering about a high frequency loss by the PWM carrier and also about the switching loss, BLDC drive has a potential to have higher efficiency than the BLAC drive. This paper compares the overall efficiency which includes PWM carrier frequency loss by using the coupling analysis between Finite Element Analysis (FEA) and a circuit simulator. The tested machines are two of Surface type PMSMs (SPMSM). One has a sinusoidal back-EMF waveform (BLAC machine) and the other has a trapezoidal back-EMF waveform (BLDC machine). The both driving methods of BLDC drive and BLAC drive are adapted to each machine, their efficiencies are compared by both simulation and experiments. The results show that the BLDC machine with BLDC drive has higher efficiency than BLAC machine with BLAC drive.

[1]  H. Akagi,et al.  An approach to position sensorless drive for brushless DC motors , 1990, Conference Record of the 1990 IEEE Industry Applications Society Annual Meeting.

[2]  Yen-Shin Lai,et al.  Quicken the pulse , 2008, IEEE Industry Applications Magazine.

[3]  D. Howe,et al.  Flux-Weakening Characteristics of Trapezoidal Back-EMF Machines in Brushless DC and AC Modes , 2006, 2006 CES/IEEE 5th International Power Electronics and Motion Control Conference.

[4]  D. Howe,et al.  Torque-Speed Characteristics of Interior-Magnet Machines in Brushless AC and DC Modes, with Particular Reference to Their Flux-Weakening Performance , 2006, 2006 CES/IEEE 5th International Power Electronics and Motion Control Conference.

[5]  K. Akatsu,et al.  Comparing Coupled Analysis With Experimental Results for an Interior PM Machine , 2009, IEEE Transactions on Industry Applications.

[6]  Kinjiro Yoshida,et al.  Cogging Torque and Rotor Core Reduction of Segment type Surface-Mounted-PM Motor , 2004 .

[7]  Ruifang Liu,et al.  Modeling of Eddy-Current Loss of Electrical Machines and Transformers Operated by Pulsewidth-Modulated Inverters , 2008, IEEE Transactions on Magnetics.

[8]  Yen-Shin Lai,et al.  Novel PWM technique without causing reversal DC-link current for brushless DC motor drives with bootstrap driver , 2005, Fourtieth IAS Annual Meeting. Conference Record of the 2005 Industry Applications Conference, 2005..

[9]  Takashi Yamada,et al.  Iron loss calculation of PM motor by coupling analysis between magnetic field simulator and control simulator , 2008, 2009 International Conference on Electrical Machines and Systems.