DOES CORRECTIONAL TREATMENT WORK? A CLINICALLY RELEVANT AND PSYCHOLOGICALLY INFORMED META-ANALYSIS *

Careful reading of the literature on the psychology of criminal conduct and of prior reviews of studies of treatment effects suggests that neither criminal sanctioning without provision of rehabilitative service nor servicing without reference to clinical principles of rehabilitation will succeed in reducing recidivism. What works, in our view, is the delivery of appropriate correctional service, and appropriate service reflects three psychological principles: (1) delivery of service to higher risk cases, (2) targeting of criminogenic needs, and (3) use of styles and modes of treatment (e.g., cognitive and behavioral) that are matched with client need and learning styles. These principles were applied to studies of juvenile and adult correctional treatment, which yielded 154 phi coefficients that summarized the magnitude and direction of the impact of treatment on recidivism. The effect of appropriate correctional service (mean phi = .30) was significantly (p <.05) greater than that of unspecified correctional service (.13), and both were more effective than inappropriate service (−.06) and non-service criminal sanctioning (−.07). Service was effective within juvenile and adult corrections, in studies published before and after 1980, in randomized and nonrandomized designs, and in diversionary, community, and residential programs (albeit, attenuated in residential settings). Clinical sensitivity and a psychologically informed perspective on crime may assist in the renewed service, research, and conceptual efforts that are strongly indicated by our review.

[1]  R. Ross,et al.  Meta-Analysis of Rehabilitation Programs for Juvenile Delinquents , 1990 .

[2]  D. A. Andrews,et al.  Classification for Effective Rehabilitation , 1990 .

[3]  J. Stephen Wormith,et al.  Personality and crime: Knowledge destruction and construction in criminology , 1989 .

[4]  Steven P. Lab,et al.  A Meta-Analysis of Juvenile Correctional Treatment , 1989 .

[5]  Bruce G. Link,et al.  A modified labeling theory approach to mental disorders : an empirical assessment , 1989 .

[6]  E. Currie,et al.  Confronting crime: Looking toward the twenty-first century , 1989 .

[7]  Patrick R. Gartin,et al.  Specifying Specific Deterrence: The Influence of Arrest on Future Criminal Activity , 1989 .

[8]  K. Gustafson,et al.  Home-Based Behavioral-Systems Family Therapy with Disadvantaged Juvenile Delinquents. , 1988 .

[9]  W. Davidson,et al.  Treatment of juvenile offenders: Study outcomes since 1980 , 1988 .

[10]  Robert R. Ross,et al.  Reasoning and Rehabilitation , 1988 .

[11]  Philip W. Harris,et al.  The Interpersonal Maturity Level Classification System I-Level , 1988 .

[12]  Alan W. Leschied,et al.  The Conceptual-Level Matching Model in Corrections , 1988 .

[13]  Steven P. Lab,et al.  An Analysis of Juvenile Correctional Treatment , 1988 .

[14]  John B. Cullen,et al.  Is rehabilitation dead? The myth of the punitive public , 1988 .

[15]  P. Jaffe,et al.  Impact of the Young Offenders Act on recidivism rates of special needs youth: Clinical and policy implications. , 1988 .

[16]  Christy A. Visher.  Incapacitation and crime control: Does a “Lock 'em up” strategy reduce crime? , 1987 .

[17]  Paul Gendreau,et al.  Revivification of rehabilitation: Evidence from the 1980s , 1987 .

[18]  W. Davidson,et al.  Diversion of juvenile offenders: an experimental comparison. , 1987, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[19]  I. D. Shorts.  DELINQUENCY BY ASSOCIATION?Outcome of Joint Participation by At-Risk and Convicted Youths in a Community-Based Programme , 1986 .

[20]  Malcolm W. Klein,et al.  Labeling Theory and Delinquency Policy , 1986 .

[21]  D. Dutton.  The Outcome of Court-Mandated Treatment for Wife Assault: A Quasi-Experimental Evaluation , 1986, Violence and Victims.

[22]  R. Hoge,et al.  A model for conceptualizing interventions in social service agencies. , 1986 .

[23]  C. Garrett,et al.  Effects of Residential Treatment on Adjudicated Delinquents: A Meta-Analysis , 1985 .

[24]  Holly Waldron,et al.  Generalizing treatment effects of functional family therapy: Three replications , 1985 .

[25]  A. Walsh.  An Evaluation of the Effects of Adult Basic Education on Rearrest Rates among Probationers. , 1985 .

[26]  Ronald L. Akers,et al.  Adolescent marijuana use: A test of three theories of deviant behavior , 1985 .

[27]  Mark R. Pogrebin,et al.  Using an alternative evaluation measure for assessing juvenile diversion programs , 1985 .

[28]  A. Schneider,et al.  A comparison of programmatic and ‘ad hoc’ restitution in juvenile courts , 1984 .

[29]  J. S. Wormith,et al.  Attitude and behavior change of correctional clientele: A three year follow-up. , 1984 .

[30]  Lawrence J. Severy,et al.  Service Accountability and Recidivism for Diverted Youth , 1984 .

[31]  C. Mitchell.  The dissemination of a social intervention: Process and effectiveness of two types of paraprofessional change agents , 1983, American journal of community psychology.

[32]  Juliette Mott,et al.  Police Decisions for Dealing with Juvenile Offenders , 1983 .

[33]  J. Buckner,et al.  Dramatic Cures for Juvenile Crime , 1983 .

[34]  Roy V. Lewis.  Scared Straight — California Style , 1983 .

[35]  S. McPherson,et al.  Intensive Counseling with Families of Juvenile Offenders , 1983 .

[36]  S. Rausch.  Court Processing Versus Diversion of Status Offenders: a Test of Deterrence and Labeling Theories , 1983 .

[37]  Patrick C. Jackson,et al.  SOME EFFECTS OF PAROLE SUPERVISION ON RECIDIVISM , 1983 .

[38]  A Police Program for Employment of Youth Gang Members , 1982 .

[39]  H. Zeisel,et al.  Disagreement over the Evaluation of a Controlled Experiment , 1982, American Journal of Sociology.

[40]  A. Binder,et al.  Community Restitution for Juveniles: An Approach and Preliminary Evaluation , 1982 .

[41]  P. C. Kratcoski,et al.  The Phoenix Program: An Educational Alternative For Delinquent Youths , 1982 .

[42]  M. M. Wolf,et al.  An evaluation of Teaching-Family (Achievement Place) group homes for juvenile offenders. , 1982, Journal of applied behavior analysis.

[43]  Linda A. M. Perry,et al.  The Effectiveness of Prison Education Programs , 1982 .

[44]  David S. Cordray,et al.  Evaluation of a Juvenile Diversion Program , 1981 .

[45]  J. Kraus.  Police Caution of Juvenile Offenders: A Research Note* , 1981 .

[46]  D. Farrington,et al.  POLICE CAUTIONING OF JUVENILES IN LONDON , 1981 .

[47]  Reed Adams,et al.  Social structure and psychodrama outcome: A ten-year follow-up , 1981 .

[48]  G. Vito,et al.  Shock Probation in Ohio: A Comparison of Outcomes , 1981 .

[49]  T. Collingwood,et al.  Skills training as treatment for juvenile delinquents. , 1980 .

[50]  T. Palmer,et al.  A Differentiated Approach To Juvenile Diversion , 1980 .

[51]  D. Andrews.  Some Experimental Investigations of the Principles of Differential Association Through Deliberate Manipulations of the Structure of Service Systems , 1980 .

[52]  Bob Ross,et al.  Effective Correctional Treatment: Bibliotherapy for Cynics , 1979 .

[53]  J. Druckman.  A Family-Oriented Policy and Treatment Program for Female Juvenile Status Offenders. , 1979 .

[54]  C. O’Donnell,et al.  The Buddy System , 2013 .

[55]  M. F. Shore,et al.  Fifteen years after treatment: a follow-up study of comprehensive vocationally-oriented psychotherapy. , 1979, The American journal of orthopsychiatry.

[56]  Martin Gruher.  Family Counseling and The Status Offender , 1979 .

[57]  M. Wasserman,et al.  The Effect of Social Control on Delinquent Behavior: A Longitudinal Test , 1979 .

[58]  C. R. Tittle,et al.  THE MYTH OF SOCIAL CLASS AND CRIMINALITY: AN EMPIRICAL ASSESSMENT OF THE EMPIRICAL EVIDENCE* , 1978 .

[59]  J. Sorensen.  Outcome evaluation of a referral system for juvenile offenders , 1978, American journal of community psychology.

[60]  J. Kraus.  REMAND IN CUSTODY AS A DETERRENT IN JUVENILE JURISDICTION , 1978 .

[61]  G. H. Bachara,et al.  Learning Disabilities and Juvenile Delinquency , 1978, Journal of learning disabilities.

[62]  J. Berman.  An Experiment in Parole Supervision , 1978 .

[63]  Herbert C. Quay,et al.  The Effect of a Juvenile Diversion Program On Rearrests , 1977 .

[64]  J. F. Alexander,et al.  Impact of family systems intervention on recidivism and sibling delinquency: a model of primary prevention and program evaluation. , 1977, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[65]  G. Gilbert.  Alternate Routes , 1977 .

[66]  Nolan Stringfield.  The Impact of Family Counseling in Resocializing Adolescent Offenders within a Positive Peer Treatment Milieu , 1977 .

[67]  William E. Wright,et al.  Community Prevention and Treatment of Juvenile Delinquency , 1977 .

[68]  P. Duckro,et al.  Family Counseling as an Alternative to Legal Action for the Juvenile Status Offender. , 1977 .

[69]  W. Davidson,et al.  Evaluation of a community-based behavior modification program for prevention of delinquency: The failure of success , 1977, Community mental health journal.

[70]  Lawrence J. Barkwell.  Differential Treatment of Juveniles on Probatin: An Evaluative Study , 1976 .

[71]  Dennis A. Romig.  Length of Institutionalization, Treatment Program Completion, and Recidivism among Delinquent Adolescent Males , 1976 .

[72]  E. Lichtenstein,et al.  Comparative effects of rapid and normal smoking on heart rate and carboxyhemoglobin. , 1976, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[73]  Robert R. Ross,et al.  A Study of Institutional Treatment Programs , 1976 .

[74]  T. Tripodi,et al.  Changing adolescent deviant behaviour through reprogramming the behaviour of parents and teachers: An experimental evaluation. , 1976 .

[75]  M. Maskin.  The differential impact of work-oriented vs. communication-oriented juvenile correction programs upon recidivism rates in delinquent males. , 1976, Journal of clinical psychology.

[76]  Carl F. Jeness.  Comparative effectiveness of behavior modification and transactional analysis programs for delinquents. , 1975 .

[77]  E. Viano.  Growing up in an affluent society--Delinquency and recidivism in suburban America , 1975 .

[78]  C. O’Donnell,et al.  The buddy system: Effect of community intervention on delinquent offenses , 1975 .

[79]  D. Baer,et al.  Instructors' Ratings of Delinquents after Outward Bound Survival Training and Their Subsequent Recidivism , 1975, Psychological reports.

[80]  J. Hagan,et al.  Work and Teaching Machines as Delinquency Prevention Tools: A Four-Year Follow-Up , 1975, Social Service Review.

[81]  C. Wellford.  Labelling Theory and Criminology: An Assessment , 1975 .

[82]  D. Glaser.  Remedies for the Key Deficiency in Criminal Justice Evaluation Research , 1974 .

[83]  I. Sarason,et al.  Modeling And Group Discussion In The Rehabilitation Of Juvenile Delinquents. , 1973 .

[84]  D. L. Redfering.  Durability of effects of group counseling with institutionalized delinquent females. , 1973, Journal of abnormal psychology.

[85]  N. Azrin,et al.  A community-reinforcement approach to alcoholism. , 1973, Behaviour research and therapy.

[86]  Charles H. Logan,et al.  Evaluation Research in Crime and Delinquency: A Reappraisal , 1972 .

[87]  C. Steele,et al.  Modification of Delinquent Behavior1 , 1971 .

[88]  J. Gill,et al.  Institutional and community adjustment of delinquents following counseling. , 1970, Journal of consulting and clinical psychology.

[89]  M. Q. Warren.  The Case for Differential Treatment of Delinquents , 1969 .

[90]  R. Persons.  Relationship between psychotherapy with institutionalized boys and subsequent community adjustment. , 1967, Journal of consulting psychology.

[91]  G. Patterson,et al.  The reinforcement of behavior in institutional settings. , 1966, Behaviour research and therapy.

[92]  Walter C. Bailey,et al.  Correctional Outcome: An Evaluation of 100 Reports , 1966 .

[93]  Frederic L. Faust.  Group Counseling with Juveniles , 1965 .

[94]  M. Craft,et al.  A CONTROLLED TRIAL OF AUTHORITARIAN AND SELF-GOVERNING REGIMES WITH ADOLESCENT PSYCHOPATHS. , 1964, The American journal of orthopsychiatry.

[95]  M. Grant,et al.  A Group Dynamics Approach to the Treatment of Nonconformists in the Navy , 1959 .