The utility of simulation in medical education: what is the evidence?

Medical schools and residencies are currently facing a shift in their teaching paradigm. The increasing amount of medical information and research makes it difficult for medical education to stay current in its curriculum. As patients become increasingly concerned that students and residents are "practicing" on them, clinical medicine is becoming focused more on patient safety and quality than on bedside teaching and education. Educators have faced these challenges by restructuring curricula, developing small-group sessions, and increasing self-directed learning and independent research. Nevertheless, a disconnect still exists between the classroom and the clinical environment. Many students feel that they are inadequately trained in history taking, physical examination, diagnosis, and management. Medical simulation has been proposed as a technique to bridge this educational gap. This article reviews the evidence for the utility of simulation in medical education. We conducted a MEDLINE search of original articles and review articles related to simulation in education with key words such as simulation, mannequin simulator, partial task simulator, graduate medical education, undergraduate medical education, and continuing medical education. Articles, related to undergraduate medical education, graduate medical education, and continuing medical education were used in the review. One hundred thirteen articles were included in this review. Simulation-based training was demonstrated to lead to clinical improvement in 2 areas of simulation research. Residents trained on laparoscopic surgery simulators showed improvement in procedural performance in the operating room. The other study showed that residents trained on simulators were more likely to adhere to the advanced cardiac life support protocol than those who received standard training for cardiac arrest patients. In other areas of medical training, simulation has been demonstrated to lead to improvements in medical knowledge, comfort in procedures, and improvements in performance during retesting in simulated scenarios. Simulation has also been shown to be a reliable tool for assessing learners and for teaching topics such as teamwork and communication. Only a few studies have shown direct improvements in clinical outcomes from the use of simulation for training. Multiple studies have demonstrated the effectiveness of simulation in the teaching of basic science and clinical knowledge, procedural skills, teamwork, and communication as well as assessment at the undergraduate and graduate medical education levels. As simulation becomes increasingly prevalent in medical school and resident education, more studies are needed to see if simulation training improves patient outcomes.

[1]  S Abrahamson,et al.  COMMENTARY , 1969, Quality and Safety in Health Care.

[2]  A W Sajid,et al.  Test of a cardiology patient simulator with students in fourth-year electives. , 1987, Journal of medical education.

[3]  Clifford Goodman,et al.  American Society of Anesthesiologists , 2020, Definitions.

[4]  D. Gaba,et al.  The Response of Anesthesia Trainees to Simulated Critical Incidents , 1988, Anesthesia and analgesia.

[5]  David M. Gaba,et al.  UNPLANNED INCIDENTS DURING COMPREHENSIVE ANESTHESIA SIMULATION , 1989 .

[6]  H A Schwid,et al.  Anesthesiologists' management of simulated critical incidents. , 1992, Anesthesiology.

[7]  D M Gaba,et al.  Improving anesthesiologists' performance by simulating reality. , 1992, Anesthesiology.

[8]  J Spierdijk,et al.  Does training on an anaesthesia simulator lead to improvement in performance? , 1994, British journal of anaesthesia.

[9]  The American Board of Anesthesiology. , 1994 .

[10]  D. Cook,et al.  Does volume of clinical experience affect performance of clinical clerks on surgery exit examinations? , 1996, American journal of surgery.

[11]  Stephan Marsch Team orientated medical simulation , 1998 .

[12]  J. Maher,et al.  The construction and utility of an amniocentesis trainer. , 1998, American journal of obstetrics and gynecology.

[13]  USING SIMULATION TO EVALUATE CLINICAL COMPETENCE AFTER IMPAIRMENT , 1999 .

[14]  Using simulation to evaluate clinical competence after impairment. , 1999, Journal.

[15]  N. Finer,et al.  Video Recording as a Means of Evaluating Neonatal Resuscitation Performance , 2000, Pediatrics.

[16]  D M Gaba,et al.  Time for a New Paradigm in Pediatric Medical Education: Teaching Neonatal Resuscitation in a Simulated Delivery Room Environment , 2000, Pediatrics.

[17]  A. Wall,et al.  Book ReviewTo Err is Human: building a safer health system Kohn L T Corrigan J M Donaldson M S Washington DC USA: Institute of Medicine/National Academy Press ISBN 0 309 06837 1 $34.95 , 2000 .

[18]  L. Kohn,et al.  To Err Is Human : Building a Safer Health System , 2007 .

[19]  H A Schwid,et al.  Screen-Based Anesthesia Simulation With Debriefing Improves Performance in a Mannequin-Based Anesthesia Simulator , 2001, Teaching and learning in medicine.

[20]  D. Misch Andragogy and Medical Education: Are Medical Students Internally Motivated to Learn? , 2002, Advances in health sciences education : theory and practice.

[21]  K. Abrams,et al.  The Use of a Human Patient Simulator in the Evaluation of and Development of a Remedial Prescription for an Anesthesiologist with Lapsed Medical Skills , 2002, Anesthesia and analgesia.

[22]  John Zimmerman,et al.  An online heart simulator for augmenting first-year medical and dental education , 2002, AMIA.

[23]  William F Bond,et al.  The use of simulation for emergency medicine resident assessment. , 2002, Academic emergency medicine : official journal of the Society for Academic Emergency Medicine.

[24]  William C. McGaghie,et al.  Effectiveness of a Cardiology Review Course for Internal Medicine Residents Using Simulation Technology and Deliberate Practice , 2002, Teaching and learning in medicine.

[25]  Doreen Cleave-Hogg,et al.  A worldwide survey of the use of simulation in anesthesia , 2002, Canadian journal of anaesthesia = Journal canadien d'anesthesie.

[26]  David Murray,et al.  An acute care skills evaluation for graduating medical students: a pilot study using clinical simulation , 2002, Medical education.

[27]  R. Sanson-Fisher,et al.  Translating learning principles into practice: a new strategy for learning clinical skills , 2002, Medical education.

[28]  R. Rovinelli,et al.  Computer-based testing in family practice certification and recertification. , 2003, The Journal of the American Board of Family Practice.

[29]  D. Gaba,et al.  Emergency medicine crisis resource management (EMCRM): pilot study of a simulation-based crisis management course for emergency medicine. , 2003, Academic emergency medicine : official journal of the Society for Academic Emergency Medicine.

[30]  A. Ziv,et al.  Simulation-based medical education: an ethical imperative. , 2006, Simulation in healthcare : journal of the Society for Simulation in Healthcare.

[31]  David Murray,et al.  Reliability and Validity of a Simulation-based Acute Care Skills Assessment for Medical Students and Residents , 2003, Anesthesiology.

[32]  M. Gordon,et al.  Bedside cardiology skills training for the osteopathic internist using simulation technology , 2003, The Journal of the American Osteopathic Association.

[33]  R. Kneebone Simulation in surgical training: educational issues and practical implications , 2003, Medical education.

[34]  Michael A Gisondi,et al.  Assessment of resident professionalism using high-fidelity simulation of ethical dilemmas. , 2004, Academic emergency medicine : official journal of the Society for Academic Emergency Medicine.

[35]  J. Weller,et al.  Simulation-based training to improve acute care skills in medical undergraduates. , 2004, The New Zealand medical journal.

[36]  K. A. Ericsson,et al.  Deliberate practice and the acquisition and maintenance of expert performance in medicine and related domains. , 2004, Academic medicine : journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges.

[37]  Jeffrey B Cooper,et al.  Crisis resource management training for an anaesthesia faculty: a new approach to continuing education , 2004, Medical education.

[38]  J B Cooper,et al.  A brief history of the development of mannequin simulators for clinical education and training , 2004, Quality and Safety in Health Care.

[39]  D B Swanson,et al.  Simulations in the United States Medical Licensing Examination™ (USMLE™) , 2004, Quality and Safety in Health Care.

[40]  D. Gaba The future vision of simulation in health care , 2004, Quality and Safety in Health Care.

[41]  Gavin C. Barr,et al.  Using Simulation to Instruct Emergency Medicine Residents in Cognitive Forcing Strategies , 2004, Academic medicine : journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges.

[42]  Ake Grenvik,et al.  From Resusci-Anne to Sim-Man: the evolution of simulators in medicine. , 2004, Critical care medicine.

[43]  Richard R Kyle,et al.  Using High-Fidelity Patient Simulation and an Advanced Distance Education Network to Teach Pharmacology to Second-Year Medical Students. , 2004, The journal of education in perioperative medicine : JEPM.

[44]  A. K. Sachdeva Invited commentary: Educational interventions to address the core competencies in surgery. , 2004, Surgery.

[45]  Improving Resident Competency in the Management of Shoulder Dystocia With Simulation Training , 2004, Obstetrics and gynecology.

[46]  Recurrent obstetric management mistakes identified by simulation , 2004 .

[47]  William R McIvor,et al.  Experience with medical student simulation education. , 2004, Critical care medicine.

[48]  A. Ziv,et al.  Features and uses of high-fidelity medical simulations that lead to effective learning: a BEME systematic review , 2005, Medical teacher.

[49]  Incorporating Simulation Technology in a Canadian Internal Medicine Specialty Examination: A Descriptive Report , 2005, Academic medicine : journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges.

[50]  James R Korndorffer,et al.  Simulator training for laparoscopic suturing using performance goals translates to the operating room. , 2005, Journal of the American College of Surgeons.

[51]  M. Graber,et al.  Does simulator training for medical students change patient opinions and attitudes toward medical student procedures in the emergency department? , 2005, Academic emergency medicine : official journal of the Society for Academic Emergency Medicine.

[52]  J. Vozenilek,et al.  Addressing the systems-based practice core competency: a simulation-based curriculum. , 2005, Academic emergency medicine : official journal of the Society for Academic Emergency Medicine.

[53]  A. K. Sachdeva,et al.  Acquiring skills in new procedures and technology: the challenge and the opportunity. , 2005, Archives of surgery.

[54]  Ole Jakob Elle,et al.  Simulators in surgery , 2005, Minimally invasive therapy & allied technologies : MITAT : official journal of the Society for Minimally Invasive Therapy.

[55]  M. Devita,et al.  Improving medical emergency team (MET) performance using a novel curriculum and a computerized human patient simulator , 2005, Quality and Safety in Health Care.

[56]  James R Korndorffer,et al.  Skill retention following proficiency-based laparoscopic simulator training. , 2005, Surgery.

[57]  R. Steadman,et al.  Simulation-based training is superior to problem-based learning for the acquisition of critical assessment and management skills* , 2006, Critical care medicine.

[58]  J. Feinglass,et al.  Mastery learning of advanced cardiac life support skills by internal medicine residents using simulation technology and deliberate practice , 2006, Journal of General Internal Medicine.

[59]  Jake Olivier,et al.  Surgical Residents’ Perception of Simulation Training , 2006, The American surgeon.

[60]  William C McGaghie,et al.  Emergency and critical care pediatrics: use of medical simulation for training in acute pediatric emergencies , 2006, Current opinion in pediatrics.

[61]  Lifelong learning. , 2006, Emergency medicine clinics of North America.

[62]  William C McGaghie,et al.  Effect of practice on standardised learning outcomes in simulation‐based medical education , 2006, Medical education.

[63]  Robert Fox,et al.  Training for Shoulder Dystocia: A Trial of Simulation Using Low-Fidelity and High-Fidelity Mannequins , 2006, Obstetrics and gynecology.

[64]  William C McGaghie,et al.  A Longitudinal Study of Internal Medicine Residents’ Retention of Advanced Cardiac Life Support Skills , 2006, Academic medicine : journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges.

[65]  Pamela J Morgan,et al.  Applying theory to practice in undergraduate education using high fidelity simulation , 2006, Medical teacher.

[66]  Roger Chow,et al.  Value of Debriefing during Simulated Crisis Management: Oral versus Video-assisted Oral Feedback , 2006, Anesthesiology.

[67]  Tanneguy Redarce,et al.  A new obstetric forceps for the training of junior doctors: a comparison of the spatial dispersion of forceps blade trajectories between junior and senior obstetricians. , 2006, American journal of obstetrics and gynecology.

[68]  Amitai Ziv,et al.  Incorporating Simulation-Based Objective Structured Clinical Examination into the Israeli National Board Examination in Anesthesiology , 2006, Anesthesia and analgesia.

[69]  J. Sexton,et al.  Teamwork and quality during neonatal care in the delivery room , 2006, Journal of Perinatology.

[70]  B. Dunkin,et al.  Surgical simulation: a current review , 2007, Surgical Endoscopy.

[71]  C. Daniel Smith,et al.  The Pretrained Novice: Using Simulation-Based Training to Improve Learning in the Operating Room , 2006, Surgical innovation.

[72]  The validation process of incorporating simulation-based accreditation into the anesthesiology Israeli national board exams. , 2006, The Israel Medical Association journal : IMAJ.

[73]  J. Delapena,et al.  Procedure lab used to improve confidence in the performance of rarely performed procedures , 2006, European journal of emergency medicine : official journal of the European Society for Emergency Medicine.

[74]  E. Sinz Anesthesiology national CME program and ASA activities in simulation. , 2007, Anesthesiology clinics.

[75]  D. Rothenberg,et al.  Education of trainees in the intensive care unit , 2007, Critical care medicine.

[76]  G. Lighthall,et al.  Evaluating the management of septic shock using patient simulation , 2007, Critical care medicine.

[77]  E. Hunt,et al.  Simulation: translation to improved team performance. , 2007, Anesthesiology clinics.

[78]  L D Britt,et al.  Central Line Simulation: A New Training Algorithm , 2007, The American surgeon.

[79]  Medical Residency: When Are Program Administrators Liable? , 2007 .

[80]  M. Fitch,et al.  Using high-fidelity emergency simulation with large groups of preclinical medical students in a basic science course , 2007, Medical teacher.

[81]  Akira Nishisaki,et al.  Does simulation improve patient safety? Self-efficacy, competence, operational performance, and patient safety. , 2007, Anesthesiology clinics.

[82]  Todd Dorman,et al.  Effectiveness of continuing medical education. , 2007, Evidence report/technology assessment.

[83]  A. K. Sachdeva,et al.  Safe introduction of new procedures and emerging technologies in surgery: education, credentialing, and privileging. , 2007, The Surgical clinics of North America.

[84]  K. Rzechula,et al.  High fidelity simulation can discriminate between novice and experienced residents when assessing competency in patient care , 2007, Medical teacher.

[85]  Jeffrey S. Young,et al.  The use of "war games" to evaluate performance of students and residents in basic clinical scenarios: a disturbing analysis. , 2007, The Journal of trauma.

[86]  Rajesh Aggarwal,et al.  Proving the Effectiveness of Virtual Reality Simulation for Training in Laparoscopic Surgery , 2007, Annals of surgery.

[87]  Kathleen A. Johnson,et al.  Support for Simulation-based Surgical Education through American College of Surgeons – Accredited Education Institutes , 2008, World Journal of Surgery.

[88]  Steven M. Downing,et al.  Validation of a Colonoscopy Simulation Model for Skills Assessment , 2007, The American Journal of Gastroenterology.

[89]  John R Boulet,et al.  Performance of Residents and Anesthesiologists in a Simulation-based Skill Assessment , 2007, Anesthesiology.

[90]  S. Russo,et al.  Self-reported changes in attitude and behavior after attending a simulation-aided airway management course. , 2007, Journal of clinical anesthesia.

[91]  H. Berkenstadt,et al.  Credentialing and certifying with simulation. , 2007, Anesthesiology clinics.

[92]  C. Bekes Simulation-based training is superior to problem-based learning for the acquisition of critical assessment and management skills , 2007 .

[93]  John Vozenilek,et al.  National growth in simulation training within emergency medicine residency programs, 2003-2008. , 2008, Academic emergency medicine : official journal of the Society for Academic Emergency Medicine.

[94]  Emily Hayden,et al.  Simulation in graduate medical education 2008: a review for emergency medicine. , 2008, Academic emergency medicine : official journal of the Society for Academic Emergency Medicine.

[95]  Amy L. Seybert,et al.  Human patient simulation in a pharmacotherapy course. , 2008, American journal of pharmaceutical education.

[96]  R. Simon,et al.  Obstetric Simulation as a Risk Control Strategy: Course Design and Evaluation , 2008, Simulation in healthcare : journal of the Society for Simulation in Healthcare.

[97]  B. Flanagan,et al.  Review of mannequin‐based high‐fidelity simulation in emergency medicine , 2008, Emergency medicine Australasia : EMA.

[98]  A. Levine,et al.  Standardized patients: the "other" simulation. , 2008, Journal of critical care.

[99]  R. Fox,et al.  Documentation of simulated shoulder dystocia: accurate and complete? , 2008, BJOG : an international journal of obstetrics and gynaecology.

[100]  Dena Goffman,et al.  Improving shoulder dystocia management among resident and attending physicians using simulations. , 2007, American journal of obstetrics and gynecology.

[101]  David E. Kern,et al.  A Systematic Review of Teamwork Training Interventions in Medical Student and Resident Education , 2008, Journal of General Internal Medicine.

[102]  Yasuharu Okuda,et al.  The use of simulation in the education of emergency care providers for cardiac emergencies , 2008, International journal of emergency medicine.

[103]  Ethan Oliver Bryson,et al.  The simulation theater: a theoretical discussion of concepts and constructs that enhance learning. , 2008, Journal of critical care.

[104]  J. Barsuk,et al.  Simulation-based education improves quality of care during cardiac arrest team responses at an academic teaching hospital: a case-control study. , 2008, Chest.

[105]  Daniel B Raemer,et al.  Simulation in obstetrics and gynecology. , 2008, Obstetrics and gynecology clinics of North America.

[106]  Karim Bensalah,et al.  Virtual reality training improves simulated laparoscopic surgery performance in laparoscopy naïve medical students. , 2008, Journal of endourology.

[107]  Robert Hanscom,et al.  Medical simulation from an insurer's perspective. , 2008, Academic emergency medicine : official journal of the Society for Academic Emergency Medicine.

[108]  R. Fox,et al.  Observations from 450 shoulder dystocia simulations: lessons for skills training. , 2008, Obstetrics and gynecology.

[109]  A. Fanaroff Management of Shoulder Dystocia: Skill Retention 6 and 12 Months After Training , 2008 .

[110]  Andrew Whitelaw,et al.  Improving Neonatal Outcome Through Practical Shoulder Dystocia Training , 2008, Obstetrics and gynecology.

[111]  Gynecologists ACOG PRACTICE BULLETIN , 2009 .

[112]  Post Partum Hemorrhage , 2009 .

[113]  M. Kreuter,et al.  Integrating Adult Learning Principles Into Training for Public Health Practice , 2009, Health promotion practice.

[114]  Zsófia Osváth,et al.  DOI: 10 , 2011 .