Synthesis, part of a Special Feature on New Methods for Adaptive Water Management From Premise to Practice: a Critical Assessment of Integrated Water Resources Management and Adaptive Management Approaches in the Water Sector

The complexity of natural resource use processes and dynamics is now well accepted and described in theories ranging across the sciences from ecology to economics. Based upon these theories, management frameworks have been developed within the research community to cope with complexity and improve natural resource management outcomes. Two notable frameworks, Integrated Water Resource Management (IWRM) and Adaptive Management (AM) have been developed within the domain of water resource management over the past thirty or so years. Such frameworks provide testable statements about how best to organise knowledge production and use to facilitate the realisation of desirable outcomes including sustainable resource use. However evidence for the success of IWRM and AM is mixed and they have come under criticism recently as failing to provide promised benefits. This paper critically reviews the claims made for IWRM and AM against evidence from their implementation and explores whether or not criticisms are rooted in problems encountered during the translation from research to practice. To achieve this we review the main issues that challenge the implementation of both frameworks. More specifically, we analyse the various definitions and descriptions of IWRM and AM. Our findings suggest that similar issues have affected the lack of success that practitioners have experienced throughout the implementation process for both frameworks. These findings are discussed in the context of the broader societal challenge of effective translation of research into practice, science into policy and ambition into achievement.

[1]  R. Griffiths,et al.  Using adaptive management to determine requirements of re‐introduced populations: the case of the New Zealand hihi , 2007 .

[2]  Lewis Jonker Integrated water resources management: theory, practice, cases , 2002 .

[3]  C. Walters Challenges in adaptive management of riparian and coastal ecosystems , 1997 .

[4]  K Shea,et al.  Management of populations in conservation, harvesting and control. , 1998, Trends in ecology & evolution.

[5]  Carl J. Walters,et al.  Valuation of experimental management options for ecological systems , 1997 .

[6]  Geoffrey M. Hodgson,et al.  Why the problem of reductionism in biology has implications for economics , 1993 .

[7]  Carl J. Walters,et al.  Large‐Scale Management Experiments and Learning by Doing , 1990 .

[8]  Thomas B. Starr,et al.  Hierarchy: Perspectives for Ecological Complexity , 1982 .

[9]  C. S. Holling Two Cultures of Ecology , 1998 .

[10]  Adil Al Radif,et al.  Integrated water resources management (IWRM): an approach to face the challenges of the next century and to avert future crises☆ , 1999 .

[11]  N.A.D. Connell,et al.  Evaluating soft OR: some reflections on an apparently ‘unsuccessful’ implementation using a Soft Systems Methodology (SSM) based approach , 2001, J. Oper. Res. Soc..

[12]  M. Everard,et al.  Rivers as living systems , 2002 .

[13]  C. Halbert,et al.  How adaptive is adaptive management? Implementing adaptive management in Washington State and British Columbia , 1993 .

[14]  A. Parma What can adaptive management do for our fish, forests, food, and biodiversity? , 1998 .

[15]  C. S. Holling Adaptive Environmental Assessment and Management , 2005 .

[16]  S. Hurlbert Pseudoreplication and the Design of Ecological Field Experiments , 1984 .

[17]  T. Prato ADAPTIVE MANAGEMENT OF LARGE RIVERS WITH SPECIAL REFERENCE TO THE MISSOURI RIVER 1 , 2003 .

[18]  Robert E. Goodin,et al.  The Theory of Institutional Design , 1998 .

[19]  Carl J. Walters,et al.  ECOLOGICAL OPTIMIZATION AND ADAPTIVE MANAGEMENT , 1978 .

[20]  Daniel Ward Ohlson,et al.  Exploring the application of adaptive management and decision analysis to integrated watershed management , 1999 .

[21]  Olli Varis,et al.  Integrated water resources management on the Tonle Sap Lake, Cambodia , 2006 .

[22]  Bruce Shindler,et al.  Integrating Citizens in Adaptive Management: A Propositional Analysis , 1999 .

[23]  C. S. Holling Resilience and Stability of Ecological Systems , 1973 .

[24]  G. Wilhere Adaptive Management in Habitat Conservation Plans , 2002, Conservation biology : the journal of the Society for Conservation Biology.

[25]  Michael Williams,et al.  Problems of knowledge : a critical introduction to epistemology , 2001 .

[26]  Carl J. Walters,et al.  Adaptive Management of Renewable Resources , 1986 .

[27]  Jerome R. Ravetz,et al.  Uncertainty, complexity and post-normal science , 1994 .

[28]  Graham Jewitt,et al.  Can Integrated Water Resources Management sustain the provision of ecosystem goods and services , 2002 .

[29]  Gilbert F. White,et al.  Reflections on the 50-year international search for integrated water management , 1998 .

[30]  Kai N. Lee Appraising Adaptive Management , 2000 .

[31]  R J Ormerod,et al.  The success and failure of methodologies—a comment on Connell (2001): evaluating soft OR , 2001, J. Oper. Res. Soc..

[32]  S. Winter,et al.  An Evolutionary Theory of Economic Change.by Richard R. Nelson; Sidney G. Winter , 1987 .

[33]  Larry L Irwin,et al.  Toward an Experimental Basis for Protecting Forest Wildlife. , 1993, Ecological applications : a publication of the Ecological Society of America.

[34]  A. Biswas Integrated Water Resources Management: A Reassessment , 2004 .

[35]  Geoffrey Habron Role of Adaptive Management for Watershed Councils , 2003, Environmental management.

[36]  R. Norgaard Development betrayed: the end of progress and a coevolutionary revisioning of the future. , 1994 .

[37]  D. Roush Making collaboration work : lessons from innovation in natural resource management , 2002 .

[38]  J. Levine,et al.  Adaptive management in river restoration : theory vs. practice in western North America , 2004 .

[39]  Ockie J. H. Bosch,et al.  Integrating science and management through collaborative learning and better information management , 2003 .

[40]  C. S. Holling,et al.  Barriers and bridges to the renewal of ecosystems and institutions , 1997 .

[41]  Catherine Allan,et al.  Adaptive Management and Watersheds: A Social Science Perspective 1 , 2008 .

[42]  Peter M. Allen,et al.  Evolutionary dynamics and sustainable development: a systems approach. , 1995 .

[43]  Michael Baumann On Nature, Models, and Simplicity , 2000 .

[44]  John B. Miner,et al.  The Validity and Usefulness of Theories in an Emerging Organizational Science , 1984 .

[45]  Pierre Walther,et al.  Against idealistic beliefs in the problem-solving capacities of integrated resource management , 1987 .

[46]  Kai N. Lee Compass and Gyroscope: Integrating Science and Politics for the Environment, Kai N. Lee. 1993. Island Press, Washington, DC. 290 pages. ISBN: 1-59963-197-X. $25.00 , 1993 .

[47]  H. Savenije,et al.  Water and sustainable development , 1992 .

[48]  C. Sullivan,et al.  The sharing of water between society and ecosystems: from conflict to catchment-based co-management. , 2003, Philosophical transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological sciences.

[49]  Robin Gregory,et al.  Learning as an objective within a structured risk management decision process. , 2004, Environmental science & technology.

[50]  Benedito P. F. Braga,et al.  Integrated Urban Water Resources Management: A Challenge into the 21st Century , 2001 .

[51]  R. McLain,et al.  Adaptive management: Promises and pitfalls , 1996, Environmental management.

[52]  Carl J. Walters,et al.  Adaptive Management of Stock–Recruitment Systems , 1981 .

[53]  Dominic Stead,et al.  The integration of land use planning, transport and environment in European policy and research , 2003 .

[54]  Gilberto C. Gallopín,et al.  International Workshop Integrated Conceptual Framework for Tropical Agroecosystem Research Based on Complex Systems Theories: A CIAT/University of Guelph Project (1, 1997, Cali, Colombia). Proceedings , 1997 .

[55]  Neil S. Grigg Integrated Water Resources Management who Should Lead, who Should Pay? , 1999 .

[56]  James H. Brown,et al.  The Report of the Ecological Society of America Committee on the Scientific Basis for Ecosystem Management , 1996 .

[57]  Bruce Durham,et al.  Integrated Water Resource Management: looking at the whole picture , 2003 .

[58]  Asit K. Biswas,et al.  28. Integrated Water Resources Management: A Reassessment – A Water Forum Contribution , 2004 .

[59]  Richard Margoluis,et al.  Measures of Success: Designing, Managing, and Monitoring Conservation and Development Projects , 1998 .

[60]  Lotfi A. Zadeh,et al.  General System Theory , 1962 .

[61]  Kai N. Lee Appraising Adaptive Management , 1999 .

[62]  M. Gibbons,et al.  Re-Thinking Science: Knowledge and the Public in an Age of Uncertainty , 2003 .

[63]  Barry L. Johnson,et al.  The Role of Adaptive Management as an Operational Approach for Resource Management Agencies , 1999 .

[64]  M. Giampietro Using hierarchy theory to explore the concept of sustainable development , 1994 .

[65]  A. Kashyap,et al.  Water governance: learning by developing adaptive capacity to incorporate climate variability and change. , 2004, Water science and technology : a journal of the International Association on Water Pollution Research.

[66]  C. S. Holling,et al.  Panarchy Understanding Transformations in Human and Natural Systems , 2002 .

[67]  Pieter van der Zaag,et al.  Integrated Water Resources Management: Relevant concept or irrelevant buzzword? A capacity building and research agenda for Southern Africa , 2005 .

[68]  L. Gunderson Resilience, Flexibility and Adaptive Management - - Antidotes for Spurious Certitude? , 1999 .

[69]  Rob C. de Loë,et al.  Closing the circle: linking land use planning and water management at the local level , 2005 .

[70]  S. Pickett,et al.  Ecological Understanding: The Nature of Theory and the Theory of Nature , 1994 .

[71]  P Jeffrey,et al.  Integrated water resources management: lost on the road from ambition to realisation? , 2006, Water science and technology : a journal of the International Association on Water Pollution Research.

[72]  David L. Galat,et al.  Evaluating Success Criteria and Project Monitoring in River Enhancement Within an Adaptive Management Framework , 2008, Environmental management.

[73]  R. Hilborn,et al.  Sustainable Exploitation of Renewable Resources , 1995 .

[74]  Thomas G. Cummings,et al.  We See Dead People? , 2007 .

[75]  T. Jonch-Clausen,et al.  Firming up the Conceptual Basis of Integrated Water Resources Management , 2001 .

[76]  R. Gregory,et al.  Adaptive management and environmental decision making: A case study application to water use planning , 2006 .

[77]  Claudia Pahl-Wostl,et al.  Towards sustainability in the water sector – The importance of human actors and processes of social learning , 2002, Aquatic Sciences.