How Doctors Generate Diagnostic Hypotheses: A Study of Radiological Diagnosis with Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging

Background In medical practice, diagnostic hypotheses are often made by physicians in the first moments of contact with patients; sometimes even before they report their symptoms. We propose that generation of diagnostic hypotheses in this context is the result of cognitive processes subserved by brain mechanisms that are similar to those involved in naming objects or concepts in everyday life. Methodology and Principal Findings To test this proposal we developed an experimental paradigm with functional magnetic resonance imaging (fMRI) using radiological diagnosis as a model. Twenty-five radiologists diagnosed lesions in chest X-ray images and named non-medical targets (animals) embedded in chest X-ray images while being scanned in a fMRI session. Images were presented for 1.5 seconds; response times (RTs) and the ensuing cortical activations were assessed. The mean response time for diagnosing lesions was 1.33 (SD ±0.14) seconds and 1.23 (SD ±0.13) seconds for naming animals. 72% of the radiologists reported cogitating differential diagnoses during trials (3.5 seconds). The overall pattern of cortical activations was remarkably similar for both types of targets. However, within the neural systems shared by both stimuli, activation was significantly greater in left inferior frontal sulcus and posterior cingulate cortex for lesions relative to animals. Conclusions Generation of diagnostic hypotheses and differential diagnoses made through the immediate visual recognition of clinical signs can be a fast and automatic process. The co-localization of significant brain activation for lesions and animals suggests that generating diagnostic hypotheses for lesions and naming animals are served by the same neuronal systems. Nevertheless, diagnosing lesions was cognitively more demanding and associated with more activation in higher order cortical areas. These results support the hypothesis that medical diagnoses based on prompt visual recognition of clinical signs and naming in everyday life are supported by similar brain systems.

[1]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Statistical parametric mapping , 2013 .

[2]  Kalanit Grill-Spector,et al.  Object Categorization: What Has fMRI Taught Us About Object Recognition? , 2009 .

[3]  Brian H. Ross,et al.  The effects of category use on learned categories , 2000, Memory & cognition.

[4]  G. Gorry,et al.  Clinical problem solving: a behavioral analysis. , 1978, Annals of internal medicine.

[5]  A. Markman,et al.  Category use and category learning. , 2003, Psychological bulletin.

[6]  Sven J. Dickinson,et al.  Object Categorization: Computer and Human Vision Perspectives , 2009 .

[7]  I. Gauthier,et al.  Visual object understanding , 2004, Nature Reviews Neuroscience.

[8]  Susy Macqueen,et al.  Validity , 1973, Just Algorithms.

[9]  W. Glaser.  Picture naming , 1992, Cognition.

[10]  W J Levelt,et al.  Spoken word production: A theory of lexical access , 2001, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[11]  K. Eva.  What every teacher needs to know about clinical reasoning , 2005, Medical education.

[12]  M. Arnold.  Nosology , 1998, BMJ.

[13]  Lee Brooks,et al.  Non‐analytical models of clinical reasoning: the role of experience , 2007, Medical education.

[14]  R. Shepard.  Recognition memory for words, sentences, and pictures , 1967 .

[15]  Kevin R. Smith,et al.  Word length modulates neural activity in auditory cortex during covert object naming , 2003, Neuroreport.

[16]  Sven Haller,et al.  What is different about a radiologist's brain? , 2005, Radiology.

[17]  L. Standing.  Learning 10000 pictures , 1973 .

[18]  M. Chun,et al.  Selecting and perceiving multiple visual objects , 2009, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[19]  David L. Post,et al.  Medical Problem Solving: An Analysis of Clinical Reasoning , 1979 .

[20]  G Bordage,et al.  The structure of medical knowledge in the memories of medical students and general practitioners: categories and prototypes , 1984, Medical education.

[21]  Daniel L. Schacter,et al.  Graded recall success: an event-related fMRI comparison of tip of the tongue and feeling of knowing , 2005, NeuroImage.

[22]  T. Braver,et al.  Anterior Cingulate and the Monitoring of Response Conflict: Evidence from an fMRI Study of Overt Verb Generation , 2000, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience.

[23]  E. Smith,et al.  Psychiatric diagnosis as prototype categorization. , 1980, Journal of abnormal psychology.

[24]  Lawrence E M Grierson,et al.  Action representations in perception, motor control and learning: implications for medical education , 2011, Medical education.

[25]  Tilo Kircher,et al.  Task-dependent Modulations of Prefrontal and Hippocampal Activity during Intrinsic Word Production , 2009, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience.

[26]  M. Dragovic,et al.  Towards an improved measure of the Edinburgh Handedness Inventory: A one‐factor congeneric measurement model using confirmatory factor analysis , 2004, Laterality.

[27]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Modelling Geometric Deformations in Epi Time Series , 2022 .

[28]  Timo Mäantylä,et al.  Optimizing Cue Effectiveness: Recall of 500 and 600 Incidentally Learned Words , 1986 .

[29]  Karl J. Friston,et al.  Statistical parametric mapping , 2013 .

[30]  Emiliano Macaluso,et al.  Item Retrieval and Competition in Noun and Verb Generation: An fMRI Study , 2010, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience.

[31]  Allan Collins,et al.  A spreading-activation theory of semantic processing , 1975 .

[32]  Nikolaus Weiskopf,et al.  Optimal EPI parameters for reduction of susceptibility-induced BOLD sensitivity losses: A whole-brain analysis at 3 T and 1.5 T , 2006, NeuroImage.

[33]  Howard B. Lee,et al.  Foundations of Behavioral Research , 1973 .

[34]  Michael J Cortese,et al.  Visual word recognition of single-syllable words. , 2004, Journal of experimental psychology. General.

[35]  N. Gee,et al.  Interpreting the influence of implicitly activated memories on recall and recognition. , 1998, Psychological review.

[36]  Thomas E. Nichols,et al.  Optimization of experimental design in fMRI: a general framework using a genetic algorithm , 2003, NeuroImage.

[37]  L. Brooks,et al.  Role of specific similarity in a medical diagnostic task. , 1991, Journal of experimental psychology. General.

[38]  Jonathan Evans.  Dual-processing accounts of reasoning, judgment, and social cognition. , 2008, Annual review of psychology.

[39]  L. Brooks,et al.  Influence of a Single Example on Subsequent Electrocardiogram Interpretation , 1999 .

[40]  G. Murphy,et al.  The Big Book of Concepts , 2002 .

[41]  Kara D. Federmeier,et al.  Timed picture naming in seven languages , 2003, Psychonomic bulletin & review.

[42]  E. Krupinski,et al.  Perceptual skill, radiology expertise, and visual test performance with NINA and WALDO. , 1998, Academic radiology.

[43]  L R Brooks,et al.  Coordination of Analytic and Similarity-Based Processing Strategies and Expertise in Dermatological Diagnosis , 2001, Teaching and learning in medicine.

[44]  Arthur S Elstein,et al.  Thinking about diagnostic thinking: a 30-year perspective , 2009, Advances in health sciences education : theory and practice.

[45]  Kenichi Ohki,et al.  Neural Correlates for Feeling-of-Knowing An fMRI Parametric Analysis , 2002, Neuron.

[46]  G. Norman.  Research in clinical reasoning: past history and current trends , 2005, Medical education.

[47]  Paul Boersma,et al.  Praat, a system for doing phonetics by computer , 2002 .

[48]  S. Sloman.  The empirical case for two systems of reasoning. , 1996 .

[49]  E. Conant,et al.  Holistic component of image perception in mammogram interpretation: gaze-tracking study. , 2007, Radiology.

[50]  Denis Fize,et al.  Speed of processing in the human visual system , 1996, Nature.

[51]  Norman M. Weinberger,et al.  Consequences of failures to meet standards in learning and memory , 2004, Nature Reviews Neuroscience.

[52]  A. Paivio,et al.  Cognitive components of picture naming. , 1996, Psychological bulletin.

[53]  L. Standing.  Learning 10,000 pictures. , 1973, The Quarterly journal of experimental psychology.

[54]  Mark W. Altom,et al.  Correlated symptoms and simulated medical classification. , 1982, Journal of experimental psychology. Learning, memory, and cognition.

[55]  F. Craik,et al.  The Oxford handbook of memory , 2006 .

[56]  M. Seghier,et al.  Developmental dyslexia in Chinese and English populations: dissociating the effect of dyslexia from language differences , 2010, Brain : a journal of neurology.

[57]  M. Bar.  Visual objects in context , 2004, Nature Reviews Neuroscience.

[58]  E. Weber,et al.  Toward a theory of hypothesis generation in diagnostic decision making. , 1993, Investigative radiology.

[59]  S. Jeune,et al.  Diagnostic , 1982, Thromboses Veineuses Distales et Superficielles.

[60]  W. Francis,et al.  Decomposition of repetition priming components in picture naming. , 2008, Journal of experimental psychology. General.

[61]  Irene P. Kan,et al.  Effects of Repetition and Competition on Activity in Left Prefrontal Cortex during Word Generation , 1999, Neuron.

[62]  J W Oestmann,et al.  Lung lesions: correlation between viewing time and detection. , 1988, Radiology.

[63]  Dhiraj Joshi,et al.  Object Categorization: Computer and Human Vision Perspectives , 2008 .

[64]  Angela R Laird,et al.  Meta‐analyses of object naming: Effect of baseline , 2005, Human brain mapping.

[65]  Jean K. Gordon,et al.  A Neural Signature of Phonological Access: Distinguishing the Effects of Word Frequency from Familiarity and Length in Overt Picture Naming , 2007, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience.

[66]  S. Harvey.  Nosography—The Evolution of Clinical Medicine in Modern Times , 1930, The Yale Journal of Biology and Medicine.

[67]  Christopher Hoolihan,et al.  Companion Encyclopedia of the History of Medicine. , 1994 .

[68]  V R Neufeld,et al.  The clinical reasoning of randomly selected physicians in general medical practice. , 1982, Clinical and investigative medicine. Medecine clinique et experimentale.

[69]  H L Kundel,et al.  Interpreting chest radiographs without visual search. , 1975, Radiology.

[70]  G. Fernández,et al.  How to achieve synergy between medical education and cognitive neuroscience? An exercise on prior knowledge in understanding , 2010, Advances in health sciences education : theory and practice.

[71]  Philippe G Schyns,et al.  Diagnostic recognition: task constraints, object information, and their interactions , 1998, Cognition.

[72]  L. Brooks,et al.  The development of expertise in dermatology. , 1989, Archives of dermatology.

[73]  D. Mikulis,et al.  Visual-spatial ability and fMRI cortical activation in surgery residents. , 2007, American journal of surgery.

[74]  Paul Ogden,et al.  What can medical education learn from the neurobiology of learning? , 2011, Academic medicine : journal of the Association of American Medical Colleges.