A review on effectiveness of best management practices in improving hydrology and water quality: Needs and opportunities.

Best management practices (BMPs) have been widely used to address hydrology and water quality issues in both agricultural and urban areas. Increasing numbers of BMPs have been studied in research projects and implemented in watershed management projects, but a gap remains in quantifying their effectiveness through time. In this paper, we review the current knowledge about BMP efficiencies, which indicates that most empirical studies have focused on short-term efficiencies, while few have explored long-term efficiencies. Most simulation efforts that consider BMPs assume constant performance irrespective of ages of the practices, generally based on anticipated maintenance activities or the expected performance over the life of the BMP(s). However, efficiencies of BMPs likely change over time irrespective of maintenance due to factors such as degradation of structures and accumulation of pollutants. Generally, the impacts of BMPs implemented in water quality protection programs at watershed levels have not been as rapid or large as expected, possibly due to overly high expectations for practice long-term efficiency, with BMPs even being sources of pollutants under some conditions and during some time periods. The review of available datasets reveals that current data are limited regarding both short-term and long-term BMP efficiency. Based on this review, this paper provides suggestions regarding needs and opportunities. Existing practice efficiency data need to be compiled. New data on BMP efficiencies that consider important factors, such as maintenance activities, also need to be collected. Then, the existing and new data need to be analyzed. Further research is needed to create a framework, as well as modeling approaches built on the framework, to simulate changes in BMP efficiencies with time. The research community needs to work together in addressing these needs and opportunities, which will assist decision makers in formulating better decisions regarding BMP implementation in watershed management projects.

[1]  Yanhua Zhuang,et al.  Current patterns and future perspectives of best management practices research: A bibliometric analysis , 2016, Journal of Soil and Water Conservation.

[2]  A. R. Jarrett,et al.  Evaluating bioretention hydrology and nutrient removal at three field sites in North Carolina , 2006 .

[3]  Margaret A. Palmer,et al.  Nitrogen Removal by Stormwater Management Structures: A Data Synthesis , 2014 .

[4]  L. Kalin,et al.  Combined and synergistic effects of climate change and urbanization on water quality in the Wolf Bay watershed, southern Alabama. , 2017, Journal of environmental sciences.

[5]  W. K. Kellogg.  Biogeochemical time lags may delay responses of streams to ecological restoration , 2011 .

[6]  I. Chaubey,et al.  Effectiveness of low impact development practices in two urbanized watersheds: retrofitting with rain barrel/cistern and porous pavement. , 2013, Journal of environmental management.

[7]  Ronald L. Bingner,et al.  A Review of effectiveness of vegetative buffers on sediment trapping in agricultural areas , 2009 .

[8]  Bahram Gharabaghi,et al.  Conservation management practices: Success story of the Hog Creek and Sturgeon River watersheds, Ontario, Canada , 2016, Journal of Soil and Water Conservation.

[9]  Andrew N. Sharpley,et al.  Case study comparison between litigated and voluntary nutrient management strategies , 2012, Journal of Soil and Water Conservation.

[10]  W. Hunt,et al.  Bioretention Technology: Overview of Current Practice and Future Needs , 2009 .

[11]  Christian Stamm,et al.  Future agriculture with minimized phosphorus losses to waters: Research needs and direction , 2015, AMBIO.

[12]  Saied Mostaghimi,et al.  Evaluation of vegetative filter strips as a best management practice for feed lots , 1988 .

[13]  J Stroup,et al.  Nutrient movement and removal in a switchgrass biomass-filter strip system treated with dairy manure. , 2001, Journal of environmental quality.

[14]  Jincai Ma,et al.  Bacterial community composition and structure in an Urban River impacted by different pollutant sources. , 2016, The Science of the total environment.

[15]  Steven K. Mickelson,et al.  Review of Pesticide Retention Processes Occurring in Buffer Strips Receiving Agricultural Runoff 1 , 2010 .

[16]  J M Gathenya,et al.  A modeling approach to evaluate the impact of conservation practices on water and sediment yield in Sasumua Watershed, Kenya , 2015, Journal of Soil and Water Conservation.

[17]  Robert G. Traver,et al.  Multiyear and Seasonal Variation of Infiltration from Storm-Water Best Management Practices , 2008 .

[18]  Xiaoyuan Yan,et al.  Linking river nutrient concentrations to land use and rainfall in a paddy agriculture-urban area gradient watershed in southeast China. , 2016, The Science of the total environment.

[19]  Delia Ivanoff,et al.  Long-term phosphorus removal in the Everglades stormwater treatment areas of South Florida in the United States , 2015 .

[20]  H. Kazemi,et al.  Evaluating the effectiveness and hydrological performance of green infrastructure stormwater control measures. , 2014 .

[21]  N. Syversen,et al.  Effect and design of buffer zones in the Nordic climate: The influence of width, amount of surface runoff, seasonal variation and vegetation type on retention efficiency for nutrient and particle runoff , 2005 .

[22]  Indrajeet Chaubey,et al.  A Tool for Estimating Best Management Practice Effectiveness in Arkansas , 2006 .

[23]  R. Reedy,et al.  Impact of land use and land cover change on groundwater recharge and quality in the southwestern US , 2005 .

[24]  Robert G. Traver,et al.  Evaluation of Seasonal and Large Storm Runoff Volume Capture of an Infiltration Green Infrastructure System , 2016 .

[25]  Brian M. Adams.  Sensitivity and Uncertainty Methods. , 2013 .

[26]  Jaana Uusi-Kämppä,et al.  Long-term monitoring of buffer zone efficiency under different cultivation techniques in boreal conditions , 2010 .

[27]  M. Arabi,et al.  Representation of agricultural conservation practices with SWAT , 2008 .

[28]  Wenhui Kuang,et al.  Individual and combined effects of land use/cover and climate change on Wolf Bay watershed streamflow in southern Alabama , 2014 .

[29]  Stane Krasovec.  The Future of Agriculture , 1929, Nature.

[30]  Marie Venner,et al.  Long-Term Performance and Life-Cycle Costs of Stormwater Best Management Practices , 2014 .

[31]  D. Meals,et al.  Lag time in water quality response to best management practices: a review. , 2010, Journal of environmental quality.

[32]  John S. Gulliver,et al.  Review of dissolved pollutants in urban storm water and their removal and fate in bioretention cells , 2015 .

[33]  John S. Gulliver,et al.  Maintenance of Stormwater BMPs: Frequency, Effort and Cost , 2008 .

[34]  M. Halling,et al.  Measuring conservation program best management practice implementation and maintenance at the watershed scale , 2010, Journal of Soil and Water Conservation.

[35]  Dwayne R. Edwards,et al.  Performance of Vegetative Filter Strips with Varying Pollutant Source and Filter Strip Lengths , 1996 .

[36]  A. N. Sharpley,et al.  Conservation practice effectiveness and adoption: unintended consequences and implications for sustainable phosphorus management , 2015, Nutrient Cycling in Agroecosystems.

[37]  Ruijie Zeng,et al.  Infrastructure planning for drought mitigation under climate change , 2012 .

[38]  Latif Kalin,et al.  Modelling effects of land use/cover changes under limited data , 2011 .

[39]  Mohsin Tanveer,et al.  Aluminum and Chromium Toxicity in Maize: Implications for Agronomic Attributes, Net Photosynthesis, Physio-Biochemical Oscillations, and Metal Accumulation in Different Plant Parts , 2016, Water, Air, & Soil Pollution.

[40]  Li Zhang,et al.  Validation of the ecosystem services of created wetlands: Two decades of plant succession, nutrient retention, and carbon sequestration in experimental riverine marshes , 2014 .

[41]  Gerhard Kammerer,et al.  Hydraulic Performance and Pollutant Concentration Profile in a Stormwater Runoff Filtration Systems , 2015, Water, Air, & Soil Pollution.

[42]  J. W. Gilliam,et al.  Sediment and Chemical Load Reduction by Grass and Riparian Filters , 1996 .

[43]  R. L. Bengtson,et al.  Effects of different management practices on surface water quality from rice fields in south Louisiana , 1992 .

[44]  S. Grimmond.  Urbanization and global environmental change: local effects of urban warming , 2007 .

[45]  Robert L. Blevins,et al.  Soil and fecal coliform trapping by grass filter strips during simulated rain , 1995 .

[46]  Giovanni Ravazzani,et al.  Regionalization of Flow-Duration Curves through Catchment Classification with Streamflow Signatures and Physiographic–Climate Indices , 2016 .

[47]  J. K. Cronk,et al.  Constructed wetlands to treat wastewater from dairy and swine operations: a review , 1996 .

[48]  A. R. Jarrett,et al.  A tool for estimating best management practice effectiveness for phosphorus pollution control , 2005 .

[49]  Nandita B. Basu,et al.  Catchment Legacies and Time Lags: A Parsimonious Watershed Model to Predict the Effects of Legacy Storage on Nitrogen Export , 2015, PloS one.

[50]  Brian Kronvang,et al.  Phosphorus retention in riparian buffers: review of their efficiency. , 2009, Journal of environmental quality.

[51]  Randy A. Dahlgren,et al.  Influence of legacy phosphorus, land use, and climate change on anthropogenic phosphorus inputs and riverine export dynamics , 2014, Biogeochemistry.

[52]  Greg Lindsey,et al.  Maintenance of stormwater BMPs in four Maryland counties: A status report , 1992 .

[53]  Bernard A Engel,et al.  Optimal selection and placement of green infrastructure to reduce impacts of land use change and climate change on hydrology and water quality: An application to the Trail Creek Watershed, Indiana. , 2016, The Science of the total environment.

[54]  Lei Chen,et al.  Simulation of spatial and temporal distributions of non-point source pollution load in the Three Gorges Reservoir Region. , 2014, The Science of the total environment.

[55]  Hans-Georg Frede,et al.  Mitigation strategies to reduce pesticide inputs into ground- and surface water and their effectiveness; a review. , 2007, The Science of the total environment.

[56]  Robert G. Traver,et al.  Long-Term Orthophosphate Removal in a Field-Scale Storm-Water Bioinfiltration Rain Garden , 2012 .

[57]  Linda May,et al.  Phosphorus legacy: overcoming the effects of past management practices to mitigate future water quality impairment. , 2013, Journal of environmental quality.

[58]  Marc Voltz,et al.  Using grassed strips to limit pesticide transfer to surface water: a review , 2005 .

[59]  Bernard A. Engel,et al.  EVALUATION OF STRUCTURAL BEST MANAGEMENT PRACTICES 20 YEARS AFTER INSTALLATION: BLACK CREEK WATERSHED, INDIANA , 2004 .

[60]  Bernard A Engel,et al.  Urbanization impacts on surface runoff of the contiguous United States. , 2017, Journal of environmental management.

[61]  Saied Mostaghimi,et al.  Vegetative Filter Strips for Agricultural Nonpoint Source Pollution Control , 1989 .

[62]  D. Trevisan,et al.  The effect of grass buffer strips on phosphorus dynamics—A critical review and synthesis as a basis for application in agricultural landscapes in France , 2006 .

[63]  Peter T. Weiss,et al.  Cost and Pollutant Removal of Storm-Water Treatment Practices , 2007 .

[64]  Mazdak Arabi,et al.  Modeling long-term water quality impact of structural BMPs , 2006 .

[65]  Tone Merete Muthanna,et al.  The hydrological performance of bioretention cells in regions with cold climates: seasonal variation and implications for design , 2016 .

[66]  Ronald L. Bingner,et al.  Cost effectiveness of agricultural BMPs for sediment reduction in the mississippi delta , 2002 .

[67]  G. Viviani,et al.  Influence of the Height of Municipal Solid Waste Landfill on the Formation of Perched Leachate Zones , 2015 .

[68]  T. A. Dillaha,et al.  Reduction in Sediment and Chemical Load Agricultural Field Runoff by Vegetative Filterstrips , 1994 .

[69]  Yanpeng Cai,et al.  An enhanced export coefficient based optimization model for supporting agricultural nonpoint source pollution mitigation under uncertainty. , 2017, The Science of the total environment.

[70]  Indrajeet Chaubey,et al.  Sensitivity and Uncertainty Analysis of the L-THIA-LID 2.1 Model , 2016, Water Resources Management.

[71]  Jaana Uusi-Kämppä,et al.  Phosphorus purification in buffer zones in cold climates , 2005 .

[72]  Virginia H. Dale,et al.  Hypoxia in the Northern Gulf of Mexico , 2010 .

[73]  Tommy Dalgaard,et al.  Review of scenario analyses to reduce agricultural nitrogen and phosphorus loading to the aquatic environment. , 2016, The Science of the total environment.

[74]  Minghua Zhang,et al.  Major factors influencing the efficacy of vegetated buffers on sediment trapping: a review and analysis. , 2008, Journal of environmental quality.

[75]  Reeho Kim,et al.  Low Impact Development Practices: A Review of Current Research and Recommendations for Future Directions , 2015 .

[76]  Keunyea Song,et al.  Creating Wetlands: Primary Succession, Water Quality Changes and Self-Design over 15 Years , 2012 .

[77]  Margaret W. Gitau,et al.  Water Quality Indices as Tools for Decision Making and Management , 2016, Water Resources Management.

[78]  Bernard A Engel,et al.  Enhancing a rainfall-runoff model to assess the impacts of BMPs and LID practices on storm runoff. , 2015, Journal of environmental management.

[79]  J. C. Berndtsson.  Green roof performance towards management of runoff water quantity and quality: A review , 2010 .

[80]  A. J. Duncan,et al.  Mitigation strategies to reduce methane emission from dairy cows. , 2007 .

[81]  Marci Cole Ekberg,et al.  Opportunities and challenges for managing nitrogen in urban stormwater: A review and synthesis , 2010 .

[82]  Indrajeet Chaubey,et al.  Effectiveness of Vegetative Filter Strips in Controlling Losses of Surface-applied Poultry Litter Constituents , 1995 .

[83]  Indrajeet Chaubey,et al.  Comparison of Computer Models for Estimating Hydrology and Water Quality in an Agricultural Watershed , 2017, Water Resources Management.

[84]  Leo Stroosnijder,et al.  Soil Conservation Through Sediment Trapping: A Review , 2015 .

[85]  Bruno Cheviron,et al.  Vegetated filter effects on sedimentological connectivity of agricultural catchments in erosion modelling: a review , 2011 .

[86]  L. Mhadhbi,et al.  Uptake Kinetics, Bioconcentration and Debromination of BDE-47 in Juvenile Marine Fish Psetta maxima , 2014, Water, Air, & Soil Pollution.

[87]  Bernard W. Sweeney,et al.  Streamside Forest Buffer Width Needed to Protect Stream Water Quality, Habitat, and Organisms: A Literature Review , 2014 .

[88]  R. Droste,et al.  Pollution loads in urban runoff and sanitary wastewater. , 2004, The Science of the total environment.

[89]  Richard H. McCuen,et al.  Spatio-temporal effects of low impact development practices , 2009 .

[90]  Bernard A. Engel,et al.  Optimal selection and placement of BMPs and LID practices with a rainfall-runoff model , 2016, Environ. Model. Softw..

[91]  John L. Nieber,et al.  Field infiltration measurements in grassed roadside drainage ditches: Spatial and temporal variability , 2015 .

[92]  Bernard A Engel,et al.  Retrofitting LID Practices into Existing Neighborhoods: Is It Worth It? , 2016, Environmental Management.

[93]  Shirley E. Clark,et al.  Clogging Mechanism of Stormwater Filter Media by NaCl as a Deicing Salt , 2015 .

[94]  Saied Mostaghimi,et al.  SEDIMENT AND NITROGEN TRANSPORT IN GRASS FILTER STRIPS 1 , 1999 .

[95]  I. Chaubey,et al.  Effectiveness of Low Impact Development Practices: Literature Review and Suggestions for Future Research , 2012, Water, Air, & Soil Pollution.

[96]  B. Engel,et al.  Evaluating the effectiveness of management practices on hydrology and water quality at watershed scale with a rainfall-runoff model. , 2015, The Science of the total environment.

[97]  D. Sample,et al.  Review and Research Needs of Bioretention Used for the Treatment of Urban Stormwater , 2014 .

[98]  Paul Kay,et al.  A review of the efficacy of contemporary agricultural stewardship measures for ameliorating water pollution problems of key concern to the UK water industry , 2009 .

[99]  P. Haygarth,et al.  Phosphorus retention and remobilization in vegetated buffer strips: a review. , 2012, Journal of environmental quality.

[100]  Andrew N Sharpley,et al.  Phosphorus mitigation to control river eutrophication: murky waters, inconvenient truths, and "postnormal" science. , 2013, Journal of environmental quality.

[101]  J. Gulliver,et al.  Assessment of the Hydraulic and Toxic Metal Removal Capacities of Bioretention Cells After 2 to 8 Years of Service , 2013, Water, Air, & Soil Pollution.

[102]  Donald W. Meals,et al.  Watershed-scale response to agricultural diffuse pollution control programs in Vermont, USA , 1996 .

[103]  Allen L. Thompson,et al.  Grass Barrier and Vegetative Filter Strip Effectiveness in Reducing Runoff, Sediment, Nitrogen, and Phosphorus Loss , 2004 .

[104]  Benjamin M. Gramig,et al.  Why do farmers adopt conservation tillage? An experimental investigation of framing effects , 2013, Journal of Soil and Water Conservation.

[105]  Andrew N. Sharpley,et al.  Effectiveness of Agricultural Best Management Practices in Reducing Phosphorous Loading to Lake Champlain , 2004 .

[106]  Robert G. Traver,et al.  Hydraulic evolution and total suspended solids capture of an infiltration trench , 2010 .