Opinion dynamics: models, extensions and external effects

Recently, social phenomena have received a lot of attention not only from social scientists, but also from physicists, mathematicians and computer scientists, in the emerging interdisciplinary field of complex system science. Opinion dynamics is one of the processes studied, since opinions are the drivers of human behaviour, and play a crucial role in many global challenges that our complex world and societies are facing: global financial crises, global pandemics, growth of cities, urbanisation and migration patterns, and last but not least important, climate change and environmental sustainability and protection. Opinion formation is a complex process affected by the interplay of different elements, including the individual predisposition, the influence of positive and negative peer interaction (social networks playing a crucial role in this respect), the information each individual is exposed to, and many others. Several models inspired from those in use in physics have been developed to encompass many of these elements, and to allow for the identification of the mechanisms involved in the opinion formation process and the understanding of their role, with the practical aim of simulating opinion formation and spreading under various conditions. These modelling schemes range from binary simple models such as the voter model, to multi-dimensional continuous approaches. Here, we provide a review of recent methods, focusing on models employing both peer interaction and external information, and emphasising the role that less studied mechanisms, such as disagreement, has in driving the opinion dynamics. [...]

[1]  Pawel Bujnowski,et al.  Aspiration and Cooperation in Multiperson Prisoner's Dilemma , 2009 .

[2]  G. R. Luckhurst,et al.  Director alignment by crossed electric and magnetic fields: a deuterium NMR study. , 2011, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[3]  Nuno Crokidakis,et al.  The Sznajd model with limited persuasion: competition between high-reputation and hesitant agents , 2011, ArXiv.

[4]  Kathy P. Wheeler,et al.  Reviews of Modern Physics , 2013 .

[5]  Danuta Kiea,et al.  Acta Physica Polonica B , 2012 .

[6]  H. Hinrichsen,et al.  Critical coarsening without surface tension: the universality class of the voter model. , 2001, Physical review letters.

[7]  J. R. Iglesias,et al.  Compelled to do the right thing , 2012, ArXiv.

[8]  Floriana Gargiulo,et al.  Influence of Opinion Dynamics on the Evolution of Games , 2012, PloS one.

[9]  A. Tustin Automatic Control , 1951, Nature.

[10]  Max Donath,et al.  American Control Conference , 1993 .

[11]  Y. Moreno,et al.  Effects of mass media action on the Axelrod model with social influence. , 2010, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[12]  Romualdo Pastor-Satorras,et al.  Mean-Field Analysis of the q-Voter Model on Networks , 2013, 1301.7563.

[13]  Juli'an Candia,et al.  Mass media influence spreading in social networks with community structure , 2008, 0806.1762.

[14]  Stephan Freytag Critical Mass How One Thing Leads To Another , 2016 .

[15]  Muzafer Sherif,et al.  Attitude and Attitude Change: The Social Judgment-Involvement Approach , 1982 .

[16]  G. G. Stokes "J." , 1890, The New Yale Book of Quotations.

[17]  Krzysztof Kulakowski,et al.  Indifferents as an interface between Contra and Pro , 2009, 0908.3387.

[18]  S. Galam,et al.  Sociophysics: A new approach of sociological collective behaviour. I. mean‐behaviour description of a strike , 1982, 2211.07041.

[19]  Frank Schweitzer,et al.  Coexistence of Social Norms Based on in- and Out-Group Interactions , 2007, Adv. Complex Syst..

[20]  N. Lanchier,et al.  Fixation in the one-dimensional Axelrod model , 2013, 1301.0130.

[21]  Alejandro Radillo-Díaz,et al.  Axelrod models of social influence with cultural repulsion. , 2009, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[22]  J. Boudec,et al.  The Bounded Confidence Model Of Opinion Dynamics , 2010, 1006.3798.

[23]  Nicolas Lanchier,et al.  Stochastic Dynamics on Hypergraphs and the Spatial Majority Rule Model , 2013, 1301.0151.

[24]  Evguenii V. Kurmyshev,et al.  What is a leader of opinion formation in bounded confidence models? , 2013, ArXiv.

[25]  B. Latané,et al.  Statistical mechanics of social impact. , 1992, Physical review. A, Atomic, molecular, and optical physics.

[26]  K. Malarz,et al.  The Sznajd Dynamics on a Directed Clustered Network , 2007, 0710.5703.

[27]  Bruno Lombard,et al.  INTERACTION BETWEEN PERIODIC ELASTIC WAVES AND TWO CONTACT NONLINEARITIES , 2012 .

[28]  Krzysztof Kulakowski,et al.  Competing of Sznajd and voter dynamics in the Watts-Strogatz network , 2013, ArXiv.

[29]  Gerardo J. Vázquez,et al.  Induced Cultural Globalization by an External Vector Field in an Enhanced Axelrod Model , 2008, PAAMS.

[30]  S. Galam Collective beliefs and individual stubbornness in the dynamics of public debates , 2010, 1006.2332.

[31]  Guillaume Deffuant,et al.  Mixing beliefs among interacting agents , 2000, Adv. Complex Syst..

[32]  Naoki Masuda,et al.  Complex dynamics of a nonlinear voter model with contrarian agents. , 2013, Chaos.

[33]  Andre C. R. Martins A middle option for choices in the Continuous Opinions and Discrete Actions model , 2009 .

[34]  Dirk Helbing Managing Complexity: Insights, Concepts, Applications , 2007 .

[35]  Bernhard Maschke,et al.  Proceedings of the 2nd IFAC Workshop on Distributed Estimation and Control in Networked Systems , 2010 .

[36]  André C. R. Martins,et al.  The Importance of Disagreeing: Contrarians and Extremism in the Coda Model , 2009, Adv. Complex Syst..

[37]  Katarzyna Sznajd-Weron,et al.  Phase transitions in the q-voter model with two types of stochastic driving. , 2012, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[38]  M. G. Cosenza,et al.  Local versus global interactions in nonequilibrium transitions: A model of social dynamics. , 2006, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[39]  J. Candia,et al.  Effects Of Mass Media And Cultural Drift In A Model For Social Influence , 2006, physics/0611189.

[40]  Dietrich Stauffer,et al.  GENERALIZATION TO SQUARE LATTICE OF SZNAJD SOCIOPHYSICS MODEL , 2000 .

[41]  Harry Eugene Stanley,et al.  Non-consensus Opinion Models on Complex Networks , 2012, Journal of Statistical Physics.

[42]  S. Huet,et al.  When group level is different from the population level: an adaptive network with the Deffuant model , 2010, 1002.1896.

[43]  Raul Toral,et al.  Mass media and repulsive interactions in continuous-opinion dynamics , 2010, 1004.0103.

[44]  Nuno Crokidakis,et al.  Role of noise and agents’ convictions on opinion spreading in a three-state voter-like model , 2013, 1306.4025.

[45]  C. Durniak,et al.  Soliton interaction in a complex plasma. , 2010, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[46]  A. M. J. Paans Acta Physica Polonica B , 2012 .

[47]  Marsili,et al.  Nonequilibrium phase transition in a model for social influence , 2000, Physical review letters.

[48]  Walter Quattrociocchi,et al.  Opinions Manipulation: Media, Power and Gossip , 2011, Adv. Complex Syst..

[49]  J. Urry Complexity , 2006, Interpreting Art.

[50]  Katarzyna Sznajd-Weron,et al.  Phase transition in the Sznajd model with independence , 2011, ArXiv.

[51]  J. Argüelles Science and Culture , 1946, Nature.

[52]  Niloy Ganguly,et al.  Dynamics On and Of Complex Networks , 2009 .

[53]  Andrea Baronchelli,et al.  Generalized voter-like models on heterogeneous networks , 2012, ArXiv.

[54]  José F. Fontanari,et al.  Culture–area relation in Axelrod’s model for culture dissemination , 2009, Theory in Biosciences.

[55]  Michael G. Rabbat,et al.  Voter model with arbitrary degree dependence: clout, confidence and irreversibility , 2013, The European Physical Journal B.

[56]  M. Fishwick Critical Mass: How One Thing Leads to Another , 2004 .

[57]  Milton Friedman,et al.  Tyranny of the status quo , 1983 .

[58]  Armin Bunde,et al.  Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and its Applications: Preface , 2003 .

[59]  M. Mézard,et al.  Journal of Statistical Mechanics: Theory and Experiment , 2011 .

[60]  David H. Wolpert,et al.  Collective Intelligence , 1999 .

[61]  Serge Galam,et al.  Real space renormalization group and totalitarian paradox of majority rule voting , 2000 .

[62]  John N. Tsitsiklis,et al.  On Krause's Multi-Agent Consensus Model With State-Dependent Connectivity , 2008, IEEE Transactions on Automatic Control.

[63]  André C. R. Martins,et al.  Bayesian updating as basis for opinion dynamics models , 2012 .

[64]  Anirban Chakraborti,et al.  Opinion formation in kinetic exchange models: spontaneous symmetry-breaking transition. , 2010, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[65]  J. Nadal,et al.  International Journal of Modern Physics C C World Scientiic Publishing Company Neural Networks as Optimal Information Processors , 1994 .

[66]  Guido Caldarelli,et al.  Opinion dynamics on interacting networks: media competition and social influence , 2014, Scientific Reports.

[67]  John N. Tsitsiklis,et al.  Continuous-Time Average-Preserving Opinion Dynamics with Opinion-Dependent Communications , 2009, SIAM J. Control. Optim..

[68]  Frank Westerhoff,et al.  Controlling tax evasion fluctuations , 2008, 0805.0998.

[69]  Jan Lorenz,et al.  Tipping diffusivity in information accumulation systems: more links, less consensus , 2009, 0909.1252.

[70]  M. San Miguel,et al.  Neighborhood models of minority opinion spreading , 2004, cond-mat/0403339.

[71]  Timoteo Carletti,et al.  How to make an efficient propaganda , 2006 .

[72]  S. Redner,et al.  On the role of zealotry in the voter model , 2007 .

[73]  Damon Centola,et al.  A Simple Model of Stability in Critical Mass Dynamics , 2013 .

[74]  Mauro Mobilia,et al.  Fixation and polarization in a three-species opinion dynamics model , 2011, ArXiv.

[75]  Andrzej Nowak,et al.  Modeling Social Change with Cellular Automata , 1996 .

[76]  Muzafer Sherif,et al.  Attitude and Attitude Change , 1966 .

[77]  Robert M. Entman,et al.  Political Disagreement: The Survival of Diverse Opinions within Communication Networks , 2005 .

[78]  A. Bray Theory of phase-ordering kinetics , 1994, cond-mat/9501089.

[79]  V. Latora,et al.  VECTOR OPINION DYNAMICS IN A BOUNDED CONFIDENCE CONSENSUS MODEL , 2005, physics/0504017.

[80]  F. Lima Majority-vote model with heterogeneous agents on square lattice , 2013, 1307.1776.

[81]  Yérali Gandica,et al.  Cluster size entropy in the Axelrod model of social influence: small-world networks and mass media , 2011, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[82]  Physical Review , 1965, Nature.

[83]  Francesco Bullo,et al.  Opinion Dynamics in Heterogeneous Networks: Convergence Conjectures and Theorems , 2011, SIAM J. Control. Optim..

[84]  Hyunsuk Hong,et al.  Conformists and contrarians in a Kuramoto model with identical natural frequencies. , 2011, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[85]  Wander Jager,et al.  Uniformity, Bipolarization and Pluriformity Captured as Generic Stylized Behavior with an Agent-Based Simulation Model of Attitude Change , 2005, Comput. Math. Organ. Theory.

[86]  Andre C. R. Martins,et al.  CONTINUOUS OPINIONS AND DISCRETE ACTIONS IN OPINION DYNAMICS PROBLEMS , 2007, 0711.1199.

[87]  Andrea Baronchelli,et al.  Connect and win: The role of social networks in political elections , 2012, ArXiv.

[88]  R. Mantegna Presentation of the English translation of Ettore Majorana's paper: The value of statistical laws in physics and social sciences , 2005 .

[89]  André C R Martins,et al.  Mobility and social network effects on extremist opinions. , 2008, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[90]  Giovanni Luca Ciampaglia,et al.  A Framework for the Calibration of Social Simulation Models , 2013, Adv. Complex Syst..

[91]  C. P. Prado,et al.  Axelrod's model with surface tension. , 2012, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[92]  A. Gumel Journal of Difference Equations and Applications: Preface , 2003 .

[93]  R. Baxter Exactly solved models in statistical mechanics , 1982 .

[94]  Klaus G. Troitzsch,et al.  Modelling and simulation in the social sciences from the philosophy of science point of view , 1996 .

[95]  S. Fortunato,et al.  Statistical physics of social dynamics , 2007, 0710.3256.

[96]  Claudio J. Tessone,et al.  How can Social Herding Enhance Cooperation? , 2012, Adv. Complex Syst..

[97]  Soumyajyoti Biswas,et al.  Disorder induced phase transition in kinetic models of opinion dynamics , 2011, 1102.0902.

[98]  Angel Sánchez,et al.  Diversity-Induced Resonance in the Response to Social Norms , 2012, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[99]  Mauro Mobilia,et al.  Commitment Versus Persuasion in the Three-Party Constrained Voter Model , 2012, 1207.6270.

[100]  P. Nyczka,et al.  A Model of Opinion Dynamics with Bounded Confidence and Noise , 2011, 1106.0008.

[101]  Vijay Kumar Mago,et al.  Theories and Simulations of Complex Social Systems , 2013, Theories and Simulations of Complex Social Systems.

[102]  Serge Gallam Majority rule, hierarchical structures, and democratic totalitarianism: a statistical approach , 1986 .

[103]  Guillaume Deffuant,et al.  A Rejection Mechanism in 2D Bounded Confidence Provides More Conformity , 2008, Adv. Complex Syst..

[104]  M. A. Muñoz,et al.  Nonlinear q-voter model. , 2009, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[105]  K. Pearson,et al.  Biometrika , 1902, The American Naturalist.

[106]  Jakob Grazzini,et al.  Jakob Grazzini ( 2012 ) Analysis of the Emergent Properties : Stationarity and Ergodicity Journal of Artificial Societies and Social Simulation , 2015 .

[108]  Juan Fern'andez-Gracia,et al.  Timing Interactions in Social Simulations: The Voter Model , 2013, 1306.4735.

[109]  Vito Latora,et al.  Dynamical organization towards consensus in the Axelrod model on complex networks. , 2010, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[110]  D. Stauffer,et al.  Simulation of majority vote disturbed by power-law noise , 2007, 0709.3811.

[111]  Serge Galam,et al.  SOCIOPHYSICS: A REVIEW OF GALAM MODELS , 2008, 0803.1800.

[112]  Katarzyna Sznajd-Weron,et al.  Opinion dynamics as a movement in a bistable potential. , 2011, 1103.0417.

[113]  Jan Lorenz,et al.  Continuous Opinion Dynamics under Bounded Confidence: A Survey , 2007, 0707.1762.

[114]  A. Châtelain,et al.  The European Physical Journal D , 1999 .

[115]  S. Galam Application of statistical physics to politics , 1999, cond-mat/0004306.

[116]  S. Redner,et al.  Dynamics of Strategic Three-Choice Voting , 2008 .

[117]  Lucas R. Peres,et al.  The mass media destabilizes the cultural homogenous regime in Axelrod's model , 2009, 0910.0866.

[118]  Peter J. Mucha,et al.  Role of social environment and social clustering in spread of opinions in co-evolving networks , 2013, Chaos.

[119]  Parongama Sen Phase transitions in a two-parameter model of opinion dynamics with random kinetic exchanges. , 2011, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[120]  Serge Galam,et al.  Market efficiency, anticipation and the formation of bubbles-crashes , 2011, ArXiv.

[121]  Boleslaw K. Szymanski,et al.  Accelerating consensus on co-evolving networks: the effect of committed individuals , 2011, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[122]  Francisco W. S. Lima,et al.  Controlling the Tax Evasion Dynamics via Majority-Vote Model on Various Topologies , 2012 .

[123]  Marcelo del Castillo-Mussot,et al.  Continuous opinion model in small-world directed networks , 2010, 1006.5441.

[124]  Evguenii V. Kurmyshev,et al.  Dynamics of bounded confidence opinion in heterogeneous social networks: concord against partial antagonism , 2011, ArXiv.

[125]  R. Axelrod The Dissemination of Culture , 1997 .

[126]  B. Latané The psychology of social impact. , 1981 .

[127]  Katarzyna Sznajd-Weron,et al.  Spontaneous Reorientations In A Model Of Opinion Dynamics With Anticonformists , 2010 .

[128]  Serge Galam,et al.  Two-Opinions-dynamics Generated by Inflexibles and non-contrarian and contrarian Floaters , 2008, Adv. Complex Syst..

[129]  Celia Anteneodo,et al.  Role of conviction in non-equilibrium models of opinion formation , 2012, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[130]  André M. Timpanaro,et al.  Connections between the Sznajd model with general confidence rules and graph theory. , 2012, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[131]  Serge Galam,et al.  The Drastic Outcomes from Voting Alliances in Three-Party Democratic Voting (1990 → 2013) , 2013, 1304.6648.

[132]  Jon M. Kleinberg,et al.  Selection and influence in cultural dynamics , 2013, EC '13.

[133]  R. Holley,et al.  Ergodic Theorems for Weakly Interacting Infinite Systems and the Voter Model , 1975 .

[134]  Timoteo Carletti,et al.  Emerging Structures in Social Networks Guided by Opinions' Exchanges , 2011, Adv. Complex Syst..

[135]  F. Schweitzer,et al.  Nonlinear voter models: the transition from invasion to coexistence , 2003, cond-mat/0307742.

[136]  R. Gillan New Editor-in-Chief for Journal of Physics A: Mathematical and Theoretical , 2014 .

[137]  Raul Toral,et al.  Noisy continuous-opinion dynamics , 2009, 0906.0441.

[138]  Heiko Rauhut,et al.  Does ignorance promote norm compliance? , 2010, Comput. Math. Organ. Theory.

[139]  Sujeet Akula,et al.  Dynamics of and on Complex Networks , 2011 .

[140]  Guillaume Deffuant,et al.  Meet, discuss, and segregate! , 2002, Complex..

[141]  S. Galam Social paradoxes of majority rule voting and renormalization group , 1990 .

[142]  M. G. Cosenza,et al.  Spontaneous ordering against an external field in non-equilibrium systems , 2008, 0811.2726.

[143]  Andre C. R. Martins,et al.  Modelling Epistemic Systems , 2012, Theories and Simulations of Complex Social Systems.

[144]  Raducanu Razvan,et al.  MATHEMATICAL MODELS and METHODS in APPLIED SCIENCES , 2012 .

[145]  Parongama Sen,et al.  A non-conservative kinetic exchange model of opinion dynamics with randomness and bounded confidence , 2012, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[146]  S. Redner,et al.  Dynamics of confident voting , 2011, 1111.3883.

[147]  Physics Letters , 1962, Nature.

[148]  R. Toral,et al.  Diffusing opinions in bounded confidence processes , 2010, 1004.1102.

[149]  V. Eguíluz,et al.  Update rules and interevent time distributions: slow ordering versus no ordering in the voter model. , 2011, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[150]  N. Lanchier The Axelrod model for the dissemination of culture revisited. , 2010, 1004.0365.

[151]  Europhysics Letters PREPRINT , 2002 .

[152]  Taro Takaguchi,et al.  Voter model with non-Poissonian inter-event intervals , 2010, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[153]  Michael Frankfurter,et al.  A First Look At Communication Theory , 2016 .

[154]  José F. Fontanari,et al.  The media effect in Axelrod's model explained , 2011, ArXiv.

[155]  Gerd Zschaler,et al.  Early fragmentation in the adaptive voter model on directed networks. , 2011, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[156]  F. W. S. Lima,et al.  Tax evasion dynamics and Zaklan model on Opinion-dependent Network , 2012, ArXiv.

[157]  Jstor The journal of conflict resolution , 1957 .

[158]  S. Galam,et al.  Towards a theory of collective phenomena: Consensus and attitude changes in groups , 1991 .

[159]  S. Galam Minority opinion spreading in random geometry , 2002, cond-mat/0203553.

[160]  Jan Lorenz Heterogeneous bounds of confidence: Meet, discuss and find consensus! , 2010 .

[161]  Jacky Mazars,et al.  Journal of Statistical Mechanics : Theory and Experiment Predicting the drag coefficient of a granular flow using the discrete element method , 2009 .

[162]  Dr A. Alavi,et al.  Statistical Mechanics and its applications , 2007 .

[163]  S. Snyder,et al.  Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences , 1999 .

[164]  Frantisek Slanina,et al.  Dynamical phase transitions in Hegselmann-Krause model of opinion dynamics and consensus , 2014, 1401.4324.

[165]  George A. Baker,et al.  RISE OF THE CENTRIST: FROM BINARY TO CONTINUOUS OPINION DYNAMICS , 2008 .

[166]  P. Clifford,et al.  A model for spatial conflict , 1973 .

[167]  J. T. Cox,et al.  Coalescing Random Walks and Voter Model Consensus Times on the Torus in $\mathbb{Z}^d$ , 1989 .

[168]  M. Carley Kathleen,et al.  Computational and mathematical organization theory , 2001 .

[169]  André C. R. Martins,et al.  Trust in the CODA model: Opinion Dynamics and the reliability of other agents , 2013, ArXiv.

[170]  Estefania Argente,et al.  7TH INTERNATIONAL CONFERENCE ON PRACTICAL APPLICATIONS OF AGENTS AND MULTI-AGENT SYSTEMS (PAAMS 2009) , 2009 .

[171]  Ericka Stricklin-Parker,et al.  Ann , 2005 .

[172]  S. Galam Sociophysics and the Forming of Public Opinion: Threshold versus Non Threshold Dynamics , 2008, 0803.2453.

[173]  Katarzyna Sznajd-Weron,et al.  Opinion evolution in closed community , 2000, cond-mat/0101130.

[174]  Stefan Bornholdt,et al.  Opinion formation model for markets with a social temperature and fear , 2012, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[175]  R. Weron,et al.  Outflow dynamics in modeling oligopoly markets: the case of the mobile telecommunications market in Poland , 2008, 0809.1534.

[176]  Vittorio Loreto,et al.  Opinion Dynamics with Disagreement and Modulated Information , 2012, ArXiv.

[177]  Tobias Galla,et al.  Effects of noise and confidence thresholds in nominal and metric Axelrod dynamics of social influence. , 2007, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[178]  E. Kandel,et al.  Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America. Annual subject and author indexes. , 1990, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[179]  Yun Liu,et al.  An opinion diffusion model with clustered early adopters , 2013 .

[180]  Jari Saramäki,et al.  Temporal Networks , 2011, Encyclopedia of Social Network Analysis and Mining.

[181]  Walter Quattrociocchi,et al.  Opinions within Media, Power and Gossip , 2011, ArXiv.

[182]  I. J. Benczik,et al.  Opinion dynamics on an adaptive random network. , 2009, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[183]  Giorgio Parisi,et al.  Physica A: Statistical Mechanics and its Applications: Editorial note , 2005 .

[184]  Serge Galam,et al.  Public debates driven by incomplete scientific data: the cases of evolution theory, global warming and H1N1 pandemic influenza , 2010, ArXiv.

[185]  Adrian Carro,et al.  The Role of Noise and Initial Conditions in the Asymptotic Solution of a Bounded Confidence, Continuous-Opinion Model , 2012, Journal of Statistical Physics.

[186]  Raúl Toral,et al.  Global culture: a noise-induced transition in finite systems. , 2003, Physical review. E, Statistical, nonlinear, and soft matter physics.

[187]  Vittorio Loreto,et al.  Cohesion, Consensus and Extreme Information in Opinion Dynamics , 2013, Adv. Complex Syst..