Early history of transylvania medical college: The saga of a disputed autopsy precipitating a duel and grave robbing

At the beginning of the 19th century, there were only five medical schools in America. The Medical Department of Transylvania University in Lexington, Kentucky, was the first in the West; however, it had few students or faculty until it was restructured in 1815. In 1817–1818, three of its faculty members (Benjamin Dudley, Daniel Drake, and William Richardson) quickly developed a highly dysfunctional relationship. Dudley tried to have Richardson fired, with Drake blocking this. Drake then criticized Dudley's performance of a coroner's autopsy, resulting in both parties publishing derogatory comments about each other. Dudley then challenged Drake to a pistol duel but Drake, not believing in dueling, declined. Richardson, wanting to defend his friend's honor, accepted the challenge and was mortally wounded in August 1818. Dudley, a prominent surgeon, saved his life. Both Dudley and Richardson were important Kentuckian Freemasons and the brotherhood felt compelled to punish them for un‐Masonic behavior. Drake left and started his own medical school in Cincinnati in 1819, in direct completion with and destabilizing Transylvania's school. This saga is dissected in the context of the bizarre history of dueling as part of the Code of Honor by which gentlemen in the Old South often resolved their differences. The essay analyzes the autopsy dispute and reviews politics within the medical school, the University, and newer competing medical schools. Transylvania's medical school was recognized as one of the best in the US during the first half of the 1800s, but by 1859, it had permanently closed its doors. Clin. Anat. 32:489–500, 2019. © 2019 Wiley Periodicals, Inc.

[1]  S. Mcdonald,et al.  Matthew baillie's specimens and engravings , 2018, Clinical anatomy.

[2]  James R. Wright.  “Osler Warned”: Was William Osler a Grave Robber While at McGill or Was He a Victim (or Perpetrator) of One Final Practical Joke? , 2018, Clinical anatomy.

[3]  W. Leslie.  Horace Holley: Transylvania University and the Making of Liberal Education in the Early American Republic , 2017, The New England Quarterly.

[4]  James R. Wright.  The Pennsylvania Anatomy Act of 1883: Weighing the Roles of Professor William Smith Forbes and Senator William James McKnight , 2016, Journal of the history of medicine and allied sciences.

[5]  Patrick Hansma.  The Evolution of the Autopsy , 2015 .

[6]  C. Ambrose.  Grave Robbing in Lexington and Elsewhere , 2012 .

[7]  H. Kelly.  A Cyclopedia Of American Medical Biography - Comprising The Lives Of Eminent Deceased Physicians And Surgeons From 1610 To 1910 , 2009 .

[8]  O. Juettner.  Daniel Drake and His Followers; Historical and Biographical Sketches, 1785-1909 , 2007 .

[9]  S. D. Gross.  Lives of Eminent American Physicians and Surgeons of the Nineteenth Century , 2007 .

[10]  J. Keane,et al.  Dueling Doctors , 2000, Southern medical journal.

[11]  A. Desmond.  Granville Sharp Pattison: anatomist and antagonist 1791–1851 , 1988, Medical History.

[12]  J. McSherry.  Granville Sharp Pattison: Anatomist and Antagonist, 1791-1851 F. L. M. PattisonGranville Sharp Pattison: Anatomist and Antagonist, 1791-1851 F. L. M. Pattison Edinburgh and Tuscaloosa: Canongate Publishing Limited and the University of Alabama Press (History of American Science and Technology Series , 1988 .

[13]  J. Williams.  Dueling in the Old South: Vignettes of Social History , 1980 .

[14]  G. Mukherjee.  The rise of surgery. From empiric craft to scientific discipline , 1980, Medical History.

[15]  O. Wangensteen,et al.  The Rise of Surgery: From Empire Craft to Scientific Discipline , 1981 .

[16]  J. Wright.  Transylvania, tutor to the West , 1975 .

[17]  M. Baillie.  The morbid anatomy in some of the most important parts of the human body , 1974 .

[18]  H. Peckham.  Physician to the West: Selected Writings of Daniel Drake on Science & Society by Henry D. Shapiro and Zane L. Miller , 1970 .

[19]  Barbara Skalitzsky.  The Evolution of Surgery in the United States , 1964 .

[20]  J TITLEY,et al.  THE LIBRARY OF THE LOUISVILLE MEDICAL INSTITUTE, 1837-46. , 1964, Bulletin of the Medical Library Association.

[21]  A. Wójcik.  A History of American Pathology , 1962 .

[22]  Lester S. King.  Daniel DRAKE. , 1985, JAMA.

[23]  E. Horine.  Daniel Drake : 1785-1852 : pioneer physician of the Midwest , 1961 .

[24]  H. Cushing.  The Life of Sir William Osler , 1926, Nature.

[25]  E. M'dowell,et al.  The Father of Ovariotomy , 1922, Edinburgh medical journal.

[26]  F. H. Garrison.  A Cyclopedia of American Medical Biography, Comprising the Lives of Eminent Deceased Physicians and Surgeons from 1610 to 1910 , 1912 .

[27]  W. B. Saunders.  Post-Mortem Examinations , 1910, The Hospital.

[28]  M. Koch.  Post Mortem Examinations, with Special Reference to Medico-Legal Practice , 1880, Atlanta Medical and Surgical Journal.

[29]  F. Delafield.  A Handbook of Post Mortem Examinations and of Morbid Anatomy , 1873, Buffalo Medical and Surgical Journal.

[30]  S. Williams.  Lives of Eminent American Physicians and Surgeons of the Nineteenth Century , 1861, The British and foreign medico-chirurgical review.