Performance/Cost Comparison between Single-Stage and Conventional High Power Factor Correction Rectifiers

A cost review and performance comparison between Single-Stage and Conventional High Power Factor Correction Rectifiers is presented in this paper. A new family of converters is often presented detailing electrical performance, yet discounting a cost evaluation of the topology; this paper attempts to address this issue. Detailed is an overview of two such topologies based upon a Boost Converter, for Input Current Shaping, ICS, and a Forward Converter for output regulation. The paper outlines essential design equations for the Single-Stage approach, discussing issues of importance and predicted behavior of such a design. The focus then moves onto measured operational performances of two 170W prototype PFC rectifiers, a Two-Stage and a Single-Stage respectively. Results obtained display comparable electrical performance, both in their abilities to limit input current harmonics and regulate the output voltage. However, a cost analysis that was performed indicated that monetary savings with the Single-Stage variants are not as significant as one would first expect. The unexpectedly small savings are a combination of the requirement for components with ratings that can withstand the stresses applied to them, and current market trends.

[1]  Lars Petersen,et al.  Advantages of using a two-switch forward in single-stage power factor corrected power supplies , 2000, INTELEC. Twenty-Second International Telecommunications Energy Conference (Cat. No.00CH37131).

[2]  R. Redl,et al.  Design considerations for single-stage isolated power-factor-corrected power supplies with fast regulation of the output voltage , 1995, Proceedings of 1995 IEEE Applied Power Electronics Conference and Exposition - APEC'95.

[3]  Slobodan Cuk.  New magnetic structures for switching converters , 1983 .

[4]  D. E. Macpherson,et al.  Comparison of Two Single-Stage PFC Topologies with Conventional PFC Solutions for Low Power Isolated Supplies , 2003 .

[5]  E. Santi,et al.  Issues in flat integrated magnetics design , 1996, PESC Record. 27th Annual IEEE Power Electronics Specialists Conference.

[6]  E. Rodriguez,et al.  A novel isolated high quality rectifier with fast dynamic output response , 1997, PESC97. Record 28th Annual IEEE Power Electronics Specialists Conference. Formerly Power Conditioning Specialists Conference 1970-71. Power Processing and Electronic Specialists Conference 1972.

[7]  R. Redl,et al.  A new family of single-stage isolated power-factor correctors with fast regulation of the output voltage , 1994, Proceedings of 1994 Power Electronics Specialist Conference - PESC'94.

[8]  L. Huber,et al.  Single-stage, single-switch input-current-shaping technique with reduced switching loss , 1999, APEC '99. Fourteenth Annual Applied Power Electronics Conference and Exposition. 1999 Conference Proceedings (Cat. No.99CH36285).

[9]  R. Redl.  An economical single-phase passive power-factor-corrected rectifier: topology, operation, extensions, and design for compliance , 1998, APEC '98 Thirteenth Annual Applied Power Electronics Conference and Exposition.

[10]  Tsai-Fu Wu,et al.  Analysis and design of an isolated single-stage converter achieving power-factor correction and fast regulation , 1999, IEEE Trans. Ind. Electron..