A Meta-Analysis of Clinical Studies on the Caries-Inhibiting Effect of Fluoride Gel treatment

A meta-analysis was performed on published data on the caries-inhibiting effect of fluoride gel treatment in 6- to 15-year-old children. The purposes of this meta-analysis were: (1) to calculate the overall caries-inhibiting effect of clinical fluoride gel treatment studies, based on explicit selection criteria, and (2) to explore factors potentially modifying the effect of fluoride gel treatment in caries prevention, concerning the baseline caries prevalence of the target population, the general fluoride regimen, and application features. The caries-inhibiting effect of fluoride gel application was assessed by the prevented fraction and the ‘number needed to treat’. The overal prevented fraction of the fluoride gel treatment studies, indicating the reduction of caries incidence by fluoride gel treatment relative to the incidence in the control group, was 22% (95% CI = 18–25%). Multiple regression analysis showed no significant influence on the prevented fractions for the variables ‘baseline caries prevalence’, ‘general fluoride regimen’, ‘application method’, and ‘application frequency’. The ‘number needed to treat’ (NNT), indicating the number of patients that need to be treated in order to prevent 1 DMFS, estimated the efficiency of fluoride gel treatment according to the caries incidence of the target population, including cost/effect relations. It was found that the NNT = 18 in a population with caries incidence 0.25 DMFS per year, and NNT = 3 in a population with caries incidence = 1.5 DMFS per year (treatment duration 1 year). From the standpoint of cost-effectiveness, the additional effect of fluoride gel treatment in current low and even moderate caries incidence child populations must be questioned.

[1]  J. E. Williams,et al.  An evaluation of the utility of application and cariostatic effectiveness of phosphate-fluorides in solution and gel states. , 1970, Journal - Tennessee State Dental Association.

[2]  P. Keyes,et al.  Clinical anticaries effect of repeated topical sodium fluoride applications by mouthpieces. , 1967, Journal of the American Dental Association.

[3]  D L Sackett,et al.  An assessment of clinically useful measures of the consequences of treatment. , 1988, The New England journal of medicine.

[4]  G. Truin,et al.  The prevalence of dental caries in Europe 1990-1995 , 1996 .

[5]  R. Rozier,et al.  A clinical study of the caries preventive effects of an APF solution and APF thixotropic gel. , 1980, Pediatric dentistry.

[6]  H. R. Fogels,et al.  The relative caries-inhibiting effects of a stannous fluoride dentifrice in a silica gel base. , 1979, The Journal of the American Dental Association (1939).

[7]  M. R. Smith,et al.  Caries inhibition of a dentifrice containing 0.78% sodium monofluorophosphate in a silica base. , 1984, Community dentistry and oral epidemiology.

[8]  Williams Je,et al.  An evaluation of the utility of application and cariostatic effectiveness of phosphate-fluorides in solution and gel states. , 1970 .

[9]  E. Rantala.  Caries incidence in 7-9-year-old children after fissure sealing and topical fluoride therapy in Finland. , 1979, Community Dentistry and Oral Epidemiology.

[10]  T. Marthaler.  Cariostatic Efficacy of the Combined Use of Fluorides , 1990, Journal of dental research.

[11]  E. T. Bryan,et al.  The cariostatic effectiveness of a phosphate-fluoride gel administered annually to school children. I. The results of the first year. , 1968, Journal of public health dentistry.

[12]  C Rouquette,et al.  [Epidemiologic research]. , 1970, Bulletin de l'Institut national de la sante et de la recherche medicale.

[13]  A. Howat,et al.  Caries prevention by daily supervised use of a MFP gel dentifrice. Report of a 3-year clinical trial , 1978, British Dental Journal.

[14]  J. Mellberg,et al.  Observations on Dental Caries in Primary Teeth After Frequent Fluoride Toplications in a Program Involving Other Preventives , 1978, Journal of dental research.

[15]  I. Gedalia,et al.  Effectiveness of fortnightly tooth brushing with amine fluorides in caries-prone subjects. , 1991, Journal of oral rehabilitation.

[16]  M. A. van 't Hof,et al.  Time Trends in Caries Experience of 6- and 12-Year-Old Children of Different Socioeconomic Status in The Hague , 1997, Caries Research.

[17]  M. Naylor,et al.  A three-year clinical study to determine the separate and combined caries-inhibiting effects of sodium monofluorophosphate toothpaste and an acidulated phosphate-fluoride gel. , 1978, Caries research.

[18]  G H Guyatt,et al.  Users' guides to the medical literature. II. How to use an article about therapy or prevention. B. What were the results and will they help me in caring for my patients? Evidence-Based Medicine Working Group. , 1994, JAMA.

[19]  H. Horowitz,et al.  Two-year evaluation of a self-administered procedure for the topical application of acidulated phosphate-fluoride; final report. , 1970, Journal of public health dentistry.

[20]  F. Brudevold,et al.  The use of topically applied acidulated phosphate-fluoride preceded by mild etching of the enamel: a one-year clinical trial. , 1971, Archives of oral biology.

[21]  H. Horowitz,et al.  The effect on dental caries of topically applied acidulated phosphate-fluoride: results after three years. , 1969, Journal of the American Dental Association.

[22]  A. Trubman,et al.  Effect on dental caries of self-application of acidulated phosphate fluoride paste and gel. , 1973, Journal of the American Dental Association.

[23]  L. Ripa.  A critique of topical fluoride methods (dentifrices, mouthrinses, operator-, and self-applied gels) in an era of decreased caries and increased fluorosis prevalence. , 1991, Journal of public health dentistry.

[24]  Hagan Pp,et al.  The caries-preventive effects of full- and half-strength topical acidulated phosphate fluoride. , 1985 .

[25]  T. Marthaler,et al.  The prevalence of dental caries in Europe 1990-1995. ORCA Saturday afternoon symposium 1995. , 1996, Caries research.

[26]  R. Rozier,et al.  The caries-preventive effects of full- and half-strength topical acidulated phosphate fluoride. , 1985, Pediatric dentistry.

[27]  C. Crysler,et al.  Effects of a thrice yearly application of fluoride gel. , 1978, Dental hygiene.

[28]  J. Brodeur,et al.  Efficacy of APF treatments without prior toothcleaning targeted to high-risk children. , 1992, Community dentistry and oral epidemiology.

[29]  H. Horowitz.  The effect on dental caries of topically applied acidulated phosphate-fluoride: results after one year. , 1968, Journal of oral therapeutics and pharmacology.

[30]  J. Mellberg,et al.  Incremental rates of dental caries after repeated topical sodium fluoride applications in children with lifelong consumption of fluoridated water. , 1971, Journal of the American Dental Association.

[31]  R. Senning,et al.  Clinical study of an amine fluoride gel and acidulated phosphate fluoride gel. , 1976, Community dentistry and oral epidemiology.

[32]  Abrams Rg,et al.  Caries-inhibiting effect of a stannous fluoride silica gel dentifrice: a three-year clinical study. , 1980 .

[33]  Binder Re.  Serial extraction in preventive dentistry. , 1979 .

[34]  B. McClendon,et al.  Evaluation of self-administered prophylaxis and supervised toothbrushing with acidulated phosphate fluoride. , 1974, Caries research.

[35]  M. van Leeuwen,et al.  The anticaries effect of single and combined topical fluoride systems in school children. , 1980, Archives of oral biology.

[36]  L. Ripa.  Review of the anticaries effectiveness of professionally applied and self-applied topical fluoride gels. , 1989, Journal of public health dentistry.

[37]  T. Marthaler,et al.  The effect of a fluoride gel used for supervised toothbrushing 15 or 30 times per year. , 1970, Helvetica odontologica acta.

[38]  L. F. Szwejda.  Fluorides in community programs; a study of four years of various fluorides applied topically to the teeth of children in fluoridated communities. , 1972, Journal of public health dentistry.

[39]  J. Brunelle,et al.  Combined anticariogenic effect of fluoride gel-trays and fluoride mouthrinsing in an optimally fluoridated community. , 1979, Clinical preventive dentistry.

[40]  J. Mellberg,et al.  Short intensive topical APF applications and dental caries in a fluoridated area. , 1978, Community dentistry and oral epidemiology.

[41]  J. E. Williams,et al.  The cariostatic effectiveness of a phosphate-fluoride gel administered annually to school children; final results. , 1970, Journal of public health dentistry.

[42]  Bawden Jw,et al.  A clinical study of the caries preventive effects of an APF solution and APF thixotropic gel. , 1980 .

[43]  J. Mellberg,et al.  Residual anticaries effect of repeated topical sodium fluoride applications by mouthpieces , 1969 .

[44]  H. Sundberg,et al.  Reasons for the caries decline: what do the experts believe? , 1996, European journal of oral sciences.

[45]  P. Sudha,et al.  Fluoride varnish versus acidulated phosphate fluoride for schoolchildren in Manipal. , 1987, Journal of the Indian Dental Association.

[46]  H. Hs.  The effect on dental caries of topically applied acidulated phosphate-fluoride: results after one year. , 1968 .

[47]  R. Bagramian.  A 5-year school-based comprehensive preventive program in Michigan, U.S.A. , 1982, Community dentistry and oral epidemiology.

[48]  G. Daculsi,et al.  Report on caries reduction in French schoolchildren 3 years after the introduction of a preventive program. , 1985, Community dentistry and oral epidemiology.

[49]  S. Koenigsberg,et al.  The effect of prior toothcleaning on the efficacy of topical fluoride treatment. Two-year results. , 1983, Clinical preventive dentistry.

[50]  D. Janerich,et al.  Albany topical fluoride study. , 1970, Journal of the American Dental Association.

[51]  L. F. Szwejda,et al.  Fluorides in community programs; results from a fluoride gel applied topically. , 1967, Journal of public health dentistry.

[52]  L. F. Szwejda.  Fluorides in community programs: results after two years from a fluoride gel applied topically. , 1971, Journal of public health dentistry.