High dose methotrexate with and without BCG therapy in advanced head and neck malignancy

Twenty‐three patients with advanced recurrent head and neck carcinoma were randomized to receive either high dose methotrexate with calcium leucovorin rescue (HDMTX) or HDMTX in combination with bacilli Calmette Guerin (HDMTX/BCG). An additional eight patients were treated with escalating doses of HDMTX ranging from 1 to 7 g of methotrexate. Of 12 patients receiving HDMTX, one complete response and two partial responses were noted. Of 11 patients in the HDMTX/BCG group, one complete response and two partial responses were observed. Only one partial response was noted in eight patients receiving escalating doses of the drug. Responses were brief and no significant difference in response duration was seen in any particular group. Toxicities in all groups were tolerable. BCG did not improve response rate, median duration of response, or median survival in these patients. Reported experiences with high dose methotrexate have been reviewed and again, responses to “high dose methotrexate” were found to be of brief duration. Despite acceptable toxicity, the brief duration of response and cost of such therapy raises serious question on the usefulness of chemoimmunotherapy utilizing high dose methotrexate with leucovorin rescue and BCG in the management of advanced recurrent carcinomas of the head and neck region. Cancer 43:1095–1100, 1979.