REPLY: MARINE INFLUENCE IN THE UPPER ORDOVICIAN JUNIATA FORMATION (POTTERS MILLS, PENNSYLVANIA): IMPLICATIONS FOR THE HISTORY OF LIFE ON LAND: PALAIOS, v. 25, no. 8, p. 527–539, 2010

We thank Retallack (2011) for his comment on the paper by Davies et al. (2010). Davies et al. (2010) cast doubts on the terrestrial interpretation of trace-fossil bearing strata of the Ordovician Juniata Formation and thus on their applicability to the study of early terrestrial ecosystems. We do not think that Retallack's (2011) comment on this paper dispels these doubts, for the reasons listed herein. If sedimentary facies analysis were as straightforward as inferred by Retallack (2011) in the first paragraph of his comment, then it would be easy to determine, one way or another, the depositional environment of the sedimentary succession at Potters Mills. Although Retallack (2011) implies that such phenomena as “turbidites, hummocky cross-bedding, and flaser and lenticular bedding” are diagnostic of marine conditions, none of them are (e.g., Greenwood and Sherman, 1986; Martin, 2000). We highlight this misapprehension to emphasize that sedimentary structures generated by hydrodynamic processes are rarely diagnostic of particular environments and must be used to this end with great caution. In the case of the Juniata Formation at Potters Mills, as illustrated by Davies et al. (2010), there are no physical sedimentary structures in the succession that are diagnostic of any specific depositional environment, marine or continental. This observation alone casts doubt on studies that have previously offered firm sedimentological interpretations of the Potters Mills succession. Retallack (2011) is correct to point out that better exposed outcrops of parts of the Juniata Formation have permitted interpretations of deposition within braided fluvial systems (Cotter, 1978), but fluvial deposition does not account for the whole formation (e.g., Thompson, 1970; Driese and Foreman, 1991, 1992; Ettensohn, 2004; Davies et al., 2011). Our contention remains that while sedimentological signatures in the Potters Mills section do not permit unequivocal diagnosis of either …

[1]  G. Retallack COMMENT: MARINE INFLUENCE IN THE UPPER ORDOVICIAN JUNIATA FORMATION (POTTERS MILLS, PENNSYLVANIA): IMPLICATIONS FOR THE HISTORY OF LIFE ON LAND: PALAIOS, v. 25, no. 8, p. 527–539, 2010 , 2011 .

[2]  Scott D. Elrick,et al.  REPLY: NO MAJOR STRATIGRAPHIC GAP EXISTS NEAR THE MIDDLE–UPPER PENNSYLVANIAN (DESMOINESIAN–MISSOURIAN) BOUNDARY IN NORTH AMERICA: PALAIOS, v. 26, no. 3, p. 125–139, 2011 , 2011 .

[3]  A. Brasier Searching for travertines, calcretes and speleothems in deep time: processes, appearances, predictions and the impact of plants , 2011 .

[4]  Michael C. Rygel,et al.  Alluvial facies evolution during the Palaeozoic greening of the continents: case studies, conceptual models and modern analogues , 2011 .

[5]  M. Gibling,et al.  MARINE INFLUENCE IN THE UPPER ORDOVICIAN JUNIATA FORMATION (POTTERS MILLS, PENNSYLVANIA): IMPLICATIONS FOR THE HISTORY OF LIFE ON LAND , 2010 .

[6]  J. Hagadorn,et al.  DEAD IN THEIR TRACKS—CAMBRIAN ARTHROPODS AND THEIR TRACES FROM INTERTIDAL SANDSTONES OF QUEBEC AND WISCONSIN , 2010 .

[7]  M. Gibling,et al.  Cambrian to Devonian evolution of alluvial systems: The sedimentological impact of the earliest land plants , 2010 .

[8]  G. Retallack Cambrian–Ordovician non-marine fossils from South Australia , 2009 .

[9]  G. Retallack Cambrian paleosols and landscapes of South Australia , 2008 .

[10]  H. Wilson JULIFORMIAN MILLIPEDES FROM THE LOWER DEVONIAN OF EURAMERICA: IMPLICATIONS FOR THE TIMING OF MILLIPEDE CLADOGENESIS IN THE PALEOZOIC , 2006, Journal of Paleontology.

[11]  Anthony J. Martin,et al.  Colonization of Brackish-Water Systems through Time: Evidence from the Trace-Fossil Record , 2005 .

[12]  F. Ettensohn Modeling the nature and development of major Paleozoic clastic wedges in the Appalachian Basin, USA , 2004 .

[13]  R. MacNaughton,et al.  First steps on land: Arthropod trackways in Cambrian-Ordovician eolian sandstone, southeastern Ontario, Canada , 2002 .

[14]  G. Retallack Scoyenia burrows from Ordovician palaeosols of the Juniata Formation in Pennsylvania , 2001 .

[15]  Aaron J. Martin Flaser and wavy bedding in ephemeral streams: a modern and an ancient example , 2000 .

[16]  R. Haszeldine,et al.  Regional distribution of diagenetic carbonate cement in Palaeocene deepwater sandstones: North Sea , 2000, Clay Minerals.

[17]  Thomas N. Taylor,et al.  The ichnologic record of the continental invertebrate invasion; evolutionary trends in environmental expansion, ecospace utilization, and behavioral complexity , 1998 .

[18]  J. Wright,et al.  Non-marine arthropod traces from the subaerial Ordovician Borrowdale Volcanic Group, English Lake District , 1994, Geological Magazine.

[19]  N. Trewin,et al.  Arthropods invade the land: trace fossils and palaeoenvironments of the Tumblagooda Sandstone (?late Silurian) of Kalbarri, Western Australia , 1994, Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh: Earth Sciences.

[20]  S. Driese,et al.  Paleopedology and paleoclimatic implications of Late Ordovician vertic Paleosols, Juniata Formation, Southern Appalachians , 1992 .

[21]  S. Driese,et al.  Traces and related chemical changes in a Late Ordovician paleosol, Glossifungites ichnofacies, southern Appalachians, USA , 1991 .

[22]  G. Nabi,et al.  The Anatomy of an Early Dinantian Terraced Floodplain: Palaeo‐Environment and Early Diagenesis , 1991 .

[23]  D. Sherman,et al.  Hummocky cross‐stratification in the surf zone: flow parameters and bedding genesis , 1986 .

[24]  Edward Cotter,et al.  The Evolution of Fluvial Style, With Special Reference to the Central Appalachian Paleozoic , 1977 .

[25]  A. M. Thompson Tidal-flat Deposition and Early Dolomitization in Upper Ordovician Rocks of Southern Appalachian Valley and Ridge , 1970 .

[26]  J. Balfour Transactions of the Royal Society of Edinburgh , 1870, Nature.