Fear Generalization in Humans: Systematic Review and Implications for Anxiety Disorder Research.

Fear generalization, in which conditioned fear responses generalize or spread to related stimuli, is a defining feature of anxiety disorders. The behavioral consequences of maladaptive fear generalization are that aversive experiences with one stimulus or event may lead one to regard other cues or situations as potential threats that should be avoided, despite variations in physical form. Theoretical and empirical interest in the generalization of conditioned learning dates to the earliest research on classical conditioning in nonhumans. Recently, there has been renewed focus on fear generalization in humans due in part to its explanatory power in characterizing disorders of fear and anxiety. Here, we review existing behavioral and neuroimaging empirical research on the perceptual and non-perceptual (conceptual and symbolic) generalization of fear and avoidance in healthy humans and patients with anxiety disorders. The clinical implications of this research for understanding the etiology and treatment of anxiety is considered and directions for future research described.

[1]  Jennifer Y. F. Lau,et al.  Trait Anxiety and Fear Responses to Safety Cues: Stimulus Generalization or Sensitization? , 2012, Journal of Psychopathology and Behavioral Assessment.

[2]  S. Hayes,et al.  Why behavior analysts should study emotion: the example of anxiety. , 1998, Journal of applied behavior analysis.

[3]  J. de Houwer,et al.  What is learning? On the nature and merits of a functional definition of learning , 2013, Psychonomic Bulletin & Review.

[4]  Robert Whelan,et al.  The Spread of Fear: Symbolic Generalization Mediates Graded Threat-Avoidance in Specific Phobia , 2014, Quarterly journal of experimental psychology.

[5]  Daniel S Pine,et al.  Generalization of conditioned fear-potentiated startle in humans: experimental validation and clinical relevance. , 2008, Behaviour research and therapy.

[6]  J. Beritoff ON THE FUNDAMENTAL NERVOUS PROCESSES IN THE CORTEX OF THE CEREBRAL HEMISPHERESI.—THE PRINCIPAL STAGES OF THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE INDIVIDUAL REFLEX: ITS GENERALIZATION AND DIFFERENTIATION , 1924 .

[7]  B. Vervliet,et al.  Generalization of extinguished skin conductance responding in human fear conditioning. , 2004, Learning & memory.

[8]  D. Hermans,et al.  From bad to worse: Symbolic equivalence and opposition in fear generalisation , 2015, Cognition & emotion.

[9]  B. Vervliet,et al.  Aversive learning and generalization predict subclinical levels of anxiety: a six-month longitudinal study. , 2014, Journal of anxiety disorders.

[10]  M. Paulus,et al.  An Insular View of Anxiety , 2006, Biological Psychiatry.

[11]  R. McNally Anxiety and Its Disorders: The Nature and Treatment of Anxiety and Panic, 2nd ed. , 2002 .

[12]  S. Mineka,et al.  A contemporary learning theory perspective on the etiology of anxiety disorders: it's not what you thought it was. , 2006, The American psychologist.

[13]  C. I. Hovland The Generalization of Conditioned Responses: I. The Sensory Generalization of Conditioned Responses with Varying Frequencies of Tone , 1937 .

[14]  B. Rothbaum,et al.  Behavioral/cognitive conceptualizations of post-traumatic stress disorder , 1989 .

[15]  Iole Indovina,et al.  Fear-Conditioning Mechanisms Associated with Trait Vulnerability to Anxiety in Humans , 2011, Neuron.

[16]  Joseph E LeDoux The Emotional Brain: The Mysterious Underpinnings of Emotional Life , 1996 .

[17]  K. LaBar,et al.  Conceptual similarity promotes generalization of higher order fear learning. , 2011, Learning & memory.

[18]  G. Eifert,et al.  Acceptance and Commitment Therapy for Anxiety Disorders: A Practitioner's Treatment Guide to Using Mindfulness, Acceptance, and Values-Based Behavior Change Strategies , 2005 .

[19]  Joshua M. Carlson,et al.  Circuit-Wide Structural and Functional Measures Predict Ventromedial Prefrontal Cortex Fear Generalization: Implications for Generalized Anxiety Disorder , 2014, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[20]  Stephen R Mitroff,et al.  Generalization of Conditioned Fear along a Dimension of Increasing References , 2022 .

[21]  H. Merckelbach,et al.  The etiology of specific fears and phobias in children: a critique of the non-associative account. , 2002, Behaviour research and therapy.

[22]  B. Skinner,et al.  Principles of Behavior , 1944 .

[23]  Simon Dymond,et al.  A contemporary behavior analysis of anxiety and avoidance , 2009, The Behavior analyst.

[24]  A. Field Is conditioning a useful framework for understanding the development and treatment of phobias? , 2006, Clinical psychology review.

[25]  Joshua M. Carlson,et al.  VENTROMEDIAL PREFRONTAL CORTEX REACTIVITY IS ALTERED IN GENERALIZED ANXIETY DISORDER DURING FEAR GENERALIZATION , 2013, Depression and anxiety.

[26]  J. Vlaeyen,et al.  The acquisition and generalization of cued and contextual pain-related fear: An experimental study using a voluntary movement paradigm , 2013, PAIN.

[27]  Robert Stickgold,et al.  Sleep promotes generalization of extinction of conditioned fear. , 2009, Sleep.

[28]  S. Mineka,et al.  The relevance of recent developments in classical conditioning to understanding the etiology and maintenance of anxiety disorders. , 2008, Acta psychologica.

[29]  S. Hayes,et al.  Acceptance and Commitment Therapy: The Process and Practice of Mindful Change , 2011 .

[30]  B. Roche,et al.  A Comparison of “Direct” Versus “Derived” Extinction of Avoidance Responding , 2008 .

[31]  C. Grillon,et al.  Generalized Anxiety Disorder Is Associated With Overgeneralization of Classically Conditioned Fear , 2014, Biological Psychiatry.

[32]  P. Lang The Cognitive Psychophysiology of Emotion , 2019, Anxiety and the Anxiety Disorders.

[33]  Michael B. Stadler,et al.  Encoding of conditioned fear in central amygdala inhibitory circuits , 2010, Nature.

[34]  J. Houwer,et al.  Transfer of avoidance responding to a sensory preconditioned cue: Evidence for the role of S-S and R-S knowledge in avoidance learning , 2009 .

[35]  Michael E. Levin,et al.  Acceptance and commitment therapy and contextual behavioral science: examining the progress of a distinctive model of behavioral and cognitive therapy. , 2013, Behavior therapy.

[36]  Alex Martin,et al.  Aversive learning modulates cortical representations of object categories. , 2014, Cerebral cortex.

[37]  W. K. Honig,et al.  The legacy of Guttman and Kalish (1956): Twenty-five years of research on stimulus generalization. , 1981, Journal of the experimental analysis of behavior.

[38]  Pre-Extinction of Sensory Preconditioned Electrodermal Activity , 2000, The Quarterly journal of experimental psychology. B, Comparative and physiological psychology.

[39]  A. Branca Semantic generalization at the level of the conditioning experiment. , 1957, The American journal of psychology.

[40]  Derek A Hamilton,et al.  Transformation of the discriminative and eliciting functions of generalized relational stimuli. , 2007, Journal of the experimental analysis of behavior.

[41]  S. Mineka,et al.  A modern learning theory perspective on the etiology of panic disorder. , 2001, Psychological review.

[42]  M. Bouton Context, ambiguity, and unlearning: sources of relapse after behavioral extinction , 2002, Biological Psychiatry.

[43]  R. Hen,et al.  Neurogenesis and generalization: a new approach to stratify and treat anxiety disorders , 2012, Nature Neuroscience.

[44]  B. Roche,et al.  Derived Avoidance Learning: Transformation of Avoidance Response Functions in Accordance with Same and Opposite Relational Frames , 2007, Journal of the experimental analysis of behavior.

[45]  G. Murphy,et al.  The Big Book of Concepts , 2002 .

[46]  Bram Vervliet,et al.  Return of fear in a human differential conditioning paradigm caused by a stimulus change after extinction. , 2005, Behaviour research and therapy.

[47]  S. Lissek,et al.  Maladaptive behavioral consequences of conditioned fear-generalization: a pronounced, yet sparsely studied, feature of anxiety pathology. , 2014, Behaviour research and therapy.

[48]  M. Fullana,et al.  Testing the temporal stability of individual differences in the acquisition and generalization of fear. , 2014, Psychophysiology.

[49]  Murray Sidman,et al.  Equivalence Relations and Behavior: A Research Story , 1994 .

[50]  Joseph E LeDoux Coming to terms with fear , 2014, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[51]  Edward E. Smith,et al.  Category-Based Induction , 1990 .

[52]  C. Grillon,et al.  Overgeneralization of conditioned fear as a pathogenic marker of panic disorder. , 2010, The American journal of psychiatry.

[53]  D. Barlow,et al.  Relative Effectiveness of Emotion Induction Procedures and the Role of Personal Relevance in a Clinical Sample: A Comparison of Film, Images, and Music , 2011, Journal of Psychopathology and Behavioral Assessment.

[54]  G. Glover,et al.  A Genetic Variant BDNF Polymorphism Alters Extinction Learning in Both Mouse and Human , 2010, Science.

[55]  M. Kindt,et al.  Fear generalization in humans: Impact of prior non-fearful experiences. , 2010, Behaviour research and therapy.

[56]  G. Razran,et al.  A QUANTITATIVE STUDY OF MEANING BY A CONDITIONED SALIVARY TECHNIQUE (SEMANTIC CONDITIONING). , 1939, Science.

[57]  C. Grillon Models and mechanisms of anxiety: evidence from startle studies , 2008, Psychopharmacology.

[58]  Dermot Barnes-Holmes,et al.  Transfer of aversive respondent elicitation in accordance with equivalence relations. , 2009, Journal of the experimental analysis of behavior.

[59]  Bram Vervliet,et al.  Fear generalization in humans: impact of verbal instructions. , 2010, Behaviour research and therapy.

[60]  D. Pine,et al.  The development of fear learning and generalization in 8-13 year-olds. , 2012, Developmental psychobiology.

[61]  R. Poulton,et al.  Non-associative fear acquisition: a review of the evidence from retrospective and longitudinal research. , 2002, Behaviour research and therapy.

[62]  No effect of trait anxiety on differential fear conditioning or fear generalization , 2013, Biological Psychology.

[63]  A. Etkin,et al.  Functional neuroimaging of anxiety: a meta-analysis of emotional processing in PTSD, social anxiety disorder, and specific phobia. , 2007, The American journal of psychiatry.

[64]  Eldar Shafir,et al.  Similarity, plausibility, and judgments of probability , 1993, Cognition.

[65]  M. Craske,et al.  Optimizing inhibitory learning during exposure therapy. , 2008, Behaviour research and therapy.

[66]  S. Lissek TOWARD AN ACCOUNT OF CLINICAL ANXIETY PREDICATED ON BASIC, NEURALLY MAPPED MECHANISMS OF PAVLOVIAN FEAR‐LEARNING: THE CASE FOR CONDITIONED OVERGENERALIZATION , 2012, Depression and anxiety.

[67]  T. Zentall,et al.  Categorization, concept learning, and behavior analysis: an introduction. , 2002, Journal of the experimental analysis of behavior.

[68]  I. Maltzman,et al.  Orienting in classical conditioning and generalization of the galvanic skin response to words: an overview. , 1977, Journal of experimental psychology. General.

[69]  Gregory L Murphy,et al.  Stimulus Typicality Determines How Broadly Fear Is Generalized , 2014, Psychological science.

[70]  R. Fazio,et al.  It was as big as my head, I swear! Biased spider size estimation in spider phobia. , 2012, Journal of anxiety disorders.

[71]  K. Reeve,et al.  Perceptual classes established with forced-choice primary generalization tests and transfer of function. , 2001, Journal of the experimental analysis of behavior.

[72]  M. Twohig,et al.  Cognitive defusion and self-relevant negative thoughts: examining the impact of a ninety year old technique. , 2004, Behaviour research and therapy.

[73]  Joshua M. Carlson,et al.  Hyper-Reactive Human Ventral Tegmental Area and Aberrant Mesocorticolimbic Connectivity in Overgeneralization of Fear in Generalized Anxiety Disorder , 2014, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[74]  N. H. Eisen The influence of set on semantic generalization. , 1954, Journal of abnormal psychology.

[75]  B. Roche,et al.  Relational frame theory and experimental psychopathology , 2013 .

[76]  B. W. Feather SEMANTIC GENERALIZATION OF CLASSICALLY CONDITIONED RESPONSES: A REVIEW. , 1965, Psychological bulletin.

[77]  I. Maltzman,et al.  Galvanic skin response--orienting reflex and semantic conditioning and generalization with different unconditioned stimuli. , 1977, Journal of experimental psychology. General.

[78]  A. Kaczkurkin,et al.  Generalization of Conditioned Fear and Obsessive-Compulsive Traits , 2013, Journal of psychology & psychotherapy.

[79]  W. Mink Semantic Generalization as Related to Word Association , 1963 .

[80]  C. Spielberger,et al.  Manual for the State-Trait Anxiety Inventory , 1970 .

[81]  J. Houwer Why the Cognitive Approach in Psychology Would Profit From a Functional Approach and Vice Versa , 2011, Perspectives on psychological science : a journal of the Association for Psychological Science.

[82]  E. Augustson,et al.  The transfer of avoidance evoking functions through stimulus equivalence classes. , 1997, Journal of behavior therapy and experimental psychiatry.

[83]  S. Mineka The role of fear in theories of avoidance learning, flooding, and extinction. , 1979 .

[84]  Conor Linehan,et al.  A Derived Relations Analysis of Approach-Avoidance Conflict: Implications for the Behavioral Analysis of Human Anxiety , 2011 .

[85]  Simon Dymond,et al.  Safe From Harm : Learned , Instructed , and Symbolic Generalization Pathways of Human Threat-Avoidance , 2012 .

[86]  Jeanine K. Stefanucci,et al.  A new mode of fear expression: perceptual bias in height fear. , 2008, Emotion.

[87]  E. Rolls,et al.  Computational analysis of the role of the hippocampus in memory , 1994, Hippocampus.

[88]  B. Vervliet,et al.  Criteria of validity in experimental psychopathology: application to models of anxiety and depression , 2012, Psychological Medicine.

[89]  Kevin S. LaBar,et al.  Role of conceptual knowledge in learning and retention of conditioned fear , 2012, Biological Psychology.

[90]  I. Maltzman,et al.  Semantic generalization without prior conditioning. , 1970, Journal of experimental psychology.

[91]  C. Montag,et al.  The BDNF Val66Met polymorphism and anxiety: Support for animal knock-in studies from a genetic association study in humans , 2010, Psychiatry Research.

[92]  Vishnu P. Murty,et al.  Neurobehavioral mechanisms of human fear generalization , 2011, NeuroImage.

[93]  S. Hayes,et al.  Verbal relations and the evolution of behavior analysis. , 1992 .

[94]  David H. Barlow,et al.  Anxiety and its disorders : the nature and treatment of anxiety and panic , 1988 .

[95]  David E. Greenway,et al.  The transfer of respondent eliciting and extinction functions through stimulus equivalence classes. , 1994, Journal of the experimental analysis of behavior.

[96]  A. Hamm,et al.  Amygdala-dependent fear conditioning in humans is modulated by the BDNFval66met polymorphism. , 2010, Behavioral neuroscience.

[97]  Neurocognitive Mechanisms of Fear Conditioning and Vulnerability to Anxiety , 2011, Front. Hum. Neurosci..

[98]  G. Davey,et al.  Sensory preconditioning and UCS inflation in human 'fear' conditioning. , 1989, Behaviour research and therapy.

[99]  J. Vlaeyen,et al.  Generalization Gradients in Cued and Contextual Pain-Related Fear: An Experimental Study in Healthy Participants , 2013, Front. Hum. Neurosci..

[100]  Marcel A. van den Hout,et al.  Neuroticism and avoidance of ambiguous stimuli: Better safe than sorry? , 2010 .

[101]  Joshua M. Carlson,et al.  Neural reactivity tracks fear generalization gradients , 2013, Biological Psychology.

[102]  M. Wilson,et al.  Dentate Gyrus NMDA Receptors Mediate Rapid Pattern Separation in the Hippocampal Network , 2007, Science.

[103]  I. Marks,et al.  Fears, phobias, and rituals : panic, anxiety, and their disorders , 1987 .

[104]  B. Vervliet,et al.  Generalization of Human Fear Acquisition and Extinction within a Novel Arbitrary Stimulus Category , 2014, PloS one.

[105]  M. Kindt,et al.  What's wrong with fear conditioning? , 2013, Biological Psychology.

[106]  N. Mackintosh,et al.  Associative learning and elemental representation: II. Generalization and discrimination , 2002, Animal learning & behavior.

[107]  S. Rachman The conditioning theory of fearacquisition: A critical examination , 1977 .

[108]  R. Paz,et al.  Negative Valence Widens Generalization of Learning , 2010, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[109]  C. Grillon,et al.  Learning Models of PTSD , 2012 .

[110]  Christian Grillon,et al.  Neural substrates of classically conditioned fear-generalization in humans: a parametric fMRI study. , 2014, Social cognitive and affective neuroscience.

[111]  E. Costello,et al.  The Developmental Epidemiology of Anxiety Disorders: Phenomenology, Prevalence, and Comorbidity , 2005 .

[112]  S. Rauch,et al.  What is an anxiety disorder? , 2009, Depression and anxiety.

[113]  K. LaBar,et al.  Effects of discrimination training on fear generalization gradients and perceptual classification in humans. , 2013, Behavioral neuroscience.

[114]  C. Grillon,et al.  Classical fear conditioning in the anxiety disorders: a meta-analysis. , 2005, Behaviour research and therapy.

[115]  Carel ten Cate,et al.  Biases in signal evolution: learning makes a difference. , 2007, Trends in ecology & evolution.

[116]  Joseph E LeDoux,et al.  Extinction-Reconsolidation Boundaries: Key to Persistent Attenuation of Fear Memories , 2009, Science.

[117]  E. Heit Properties of inductive reasoning , 2000, Psychonomic bulletin & review.

[118]  M. Davis,et al.  Using pavlovian higher-order conditioning paradigms to investigate the neural substrates of emotional learning and memory. , 2000, Learning & memory.

[119]  N. Guttman,et al.  Discriminability and stimulus generalization. , 1956, Journal of experimental psychology.

[120]  M. Kozak,et al.  Emotional processing of fear: exposure to corrective information. , 1986, Psychological bulletin.

[121]  Janet B W Williams,et al.  Diagnostic and Statistical Manual of Mental Disorders , 2013 .

[122]  M. Egan,et al.  Brain-Derived Neurotrophic Factor val66met Polymorphism Affects Human Memory-Related Hippocampal Activity and Predicts Memory Performance , 2003, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[123]  L. Fañanás,et al.  Acquisition and generalization of fear conditioning are not modulated by the BDNF-val66met polymorphism in humans. , 2012, Psychophysiology.

[124]  M. Gluck,et al.  Hippocampal mediation of stimulus representation: A computational theory , 1993, Hippocampus.

[125]  R. Noyes,et al.  Generalized anxiety disorder. , 1987, Primary care.

[126]  E. Hatchwell,et al.  Genetic variation in brain‐derived neurotrophic factor and human fear conditioning , 2009, Genes, brain, and behavior.

[127]  Jennifer Y F Lau,et al.  Measuring the role of conditioning and stimulus generalisation in common fears and worries , 2013, Cognition & emotion.

[128]  S. Mednick,et al.  Reciprocal augmentation of generalization and anxiety. , 1962, Journal of experimental psychology.

[129]  Bram Vervliet,et al.  Fear generalization in humans: Impact of feature learning on conditioning and extinction , 2014, Neurobiology of Learning and Memory.

[130]  S. Ghirlanda,et al.  A century of generalization , 2003, Animal Behaviour.

[131]  B. Roche,et al.  Inferred threat and safety: symbolic generalization of human avoidance learning. , 2011, Behaviour research and therapy.

[132]  A. Treves The dentate gyrus , 2016 .

[133]  L. Rips Inductive judgments about natural categories. , 1975 .