Does Discovery-Based Instruction Enhance Learning?.

Discovery learning approaches to education have recently come under scrutiny (Tobias & Duffy, 2009), with many studies indicating limitations to discovery learning practices. Therefore, 2 meta-analyses were conducted using a sample of 164 studies: The 1st examined the effects of unassisted discovery learning versus explicit instruction, and the 2nd examined the effects of enhanced and/or assisted discovery versus other types of instruction (e.g., explicit, unassisted discovery). Random effects analyses of 580 comparisons revealed that outcomes were favorable for explicit instruction when compared with unassisted discovery under most conditions (d – 0.38, 95% CI [–.44, .31]). In contrast, analyses of 360 comparisons revealed that outcomes were favorable for enhanced discovery when compared with other forms of instruction (d 0.30, 95% CI [.23, .36]). The findings suggest that unassisted discovery does not benefit learners, whereas feedback, worked examples, scaffolding, and elicited explanations do.

[1]  L. A. Hausman.  How we Think , 1921 .

[2]  G. Hendrickson,et al.  Transfer of training in learning to hit a submerged target. , 1941 .

[3]  G. Hendrix.  A New Clue to Transfer of Training , 1947, The Elementary School Journal.

[4]  John R. Mayor,et al.  The Arithmetic Teacher , 1954 .

[5]  J. Wilder.  The Origins of Intelligence in Children , 1954 .

[6]  Jack E. Kittell.  An experimental study of the effect of external direction during learning on transfer and retention of principles. , 1957 .

[7]  Bert Y. Kersh.  The adequacy of "meaning" as an explanation for the superiority of learning by independent discovery. , 1958 .

[8]  J. Piaget,et al.  The Growth Of Logical Thinking From Childhood To Adolescence: An Essay On The Construction Of Formal Operational Structures , 1958 .

[9]  R. H. Walters.  The Growth of Logical Thinking from Childhood to Adolescence , 1960 .

[10]  Willis E. Ray.  Pupil Discovery vs. Direct Instruction , 1961 .

[11]  J. Bruner.  The act of discovery. , 1961 .

[12]  R. Gagne,et al.  Some factors in the programming of conceptual learning. , 1961 .

[13]  L. Vygotsky,et al.  Thought and Language , 1963 .

[14]  Bert Y. Kersh.  The motivating effect of learning by directed discovery. , 1962 .

[15]  Jean Piaget,et al.  Comments on Vygotsky's critical remarks concerning the Language and Thought of the Child, and Judgement and Reasoning in the Child , 1962 .

[16]  D. Ausubel.  The psychology of meaningful verbal learning. , 1963 .

[17]  M. C. Wittrock,et al.  Verbal stimuli in concept formation: Learning by discovery. , 1963 .

[18]  J. Scandura.  An Analysis of Exposition and Discovery Modes of Problem Solving Instruction , 1964 .

[19]  Discovery, Task Completion, and the Assignment as Factors in Motivation , 1965 .

[20]  Frank P. Belcastro,et al.  RELATIVE EFFECTIVENESS OF THE INDUCTIVE AND DEDUCTIVE METHODS OF PROGRAMMING ALGEBRA , 1966 .

[21]  J. Guthrie,et al.  Expository instruction versus a discovery method. , 1967, Journal of educational psychology.

[22]  B. Worthen.  A Study of Discovery and Expository Presentation: Implications for Teaching , 1968 .

[23]  Jacob Cohen.  Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences , 1969, The SAGE Encyclopedia of Research Design.

[24]  Attentional Differences in Children's Incidental Learning. , 1969 .

[25]  E. Keislar,et al.  Learning by discovery : a critical appraisal , 1969 .

[26]  J. Piaget.  Science of education and the psychology of the child , 1970 .

[27]  G. Borich,et al.  A Comparison of Guided Discovery, Discovery and Didactic Teaching of Math to Kindergarten Poverty Children1 , 1970 .

[28]  Donald L. Peters,et al.  Discovery Learning in Kindergarten Mathematics. , 1970 .

[29]  James Britton,et al.  Language and Learning , 1970 .

[30]  J. Piaget,et al.  The Origins of Intelligence in Children , 1971 .

[31]  A. Warren.  Carmichael's Manual of child psychology. , 1972 .

[32]  Marcia K. Johnson,et al.  Contextual prerequisites for understanding: Some investigations of comprehension and recall , 1972 .

[33]  H. T. Olander,et al.  The effectiveness of discovery and expository methods in the teaching of fourth-grade mathematics. , 1973 .

[34]  Robert N. Singer,et al.  Effects of Prompted and Problem-solving Approaches on Learning and Transfer of Motor Skills , 1975 .

[35]  Brief Note: Effects of Prompted and Problem-solving Approaches on Learning and Transfer of Motor Skills , 1975 .

[36]  Anton E. Lawson,et al.  Encouraging the transition from concrete to formal cognitive functioning-an experiment , 1976 .

[37]  Jean Piaget.  Piaget’s Theory , 1976 .

[38]  Joseph R. Jenkins,et al.  Learning Word Meanings: A Comparison of Instructional Procedures , 1977 .

[39]  F. Danner,et al.  Eliciting Formal Operations. , 1977 .

[40]  Bernard J. Shapiro,et al.  NUMBER PATTERNS: DISCOVERY VERSUS RECEPTION LEARNING , 1977 .

[41]  C. Hirsch.  The Effects of Guided Discovery and Individualized Instructional Packages on Initial Learning, Transfer, and Retention in Second-Year Algebra. , 1977 .

[42]  Improvement in Arithmetic and Reading and Discovery Learning in Mathematics (SEED). , 1978 .

[43]  J. Piaget.  Success and Understanding , 1978 .

[44]  R N Singer,et al.  Effect of guided vs. discovery learning strategies on initial motor task learning, transfer, and retention. , 1978, Research quarterly.

[45]  N. J. Slamecka,et al.  The Generation Effect: Delineation of a Phenomenon , 1978 .

[46]  M. Linn,et al.  Effectiveness of the science curriculum improvement study in teaching scientific literacy , 1978 .

[47]  J. Piaget,et al.  The essential Piaget , 1979 .

[48]  William J. Bluhm.  The effects of science process skill instruction on preservice elementary teachers' knowledge of, ability to use, and ability to sequence science process skills , 1979 .

[49]  B. Fischhoff,et al.  Journal of Experimental Psychology: Human Learning and Memory , 1980 .

[50]  J. Wertsch.  The Concept of Activity in Soviet Psychology , 1981 .

[51]  Linda L. Dunlap,et al.  Effects of Reception and Discovery Instruction on Kindergarteners’ Performance on Probability Tasks , 1982 .

[52]  R. Rosenthal.  Meta-analytic procedures for social research , 1984 .

[53]  M. McDaniel,et al.  Putting the Keyword Method in Context , 1984 .

[54]  John D. W. Andrews,et al.  Discovery and Expository Learning Compared: Their Effects on Independent and Dependent Students , 1984 .

[55]  The Relationships Bewtwen Cognitive Styles, Methods of Instruction, Knowledge, and Process Skills of College Chemistry Students , 1986 .

[56]  Erik De Corte,et al.  Learning and Instruction: European Research in an International Context: Volume 1 , 1987 .

[57]  Valerie J. Shute,et al.  Inference and discovery in an exploratory laboratory. , 1988 .

[58]  R. A. Tarmizi,et al.  Guidance during Mathematical Problem Solving. , 1988 .

[59]  John Sweller,et al.  Cognitive Load During Problem Solving: Effects on Learning , 1988, Cogn. Sci..

[60]  Blair T. Johnson.  DSTAT : software for the meta-analytic review of research literatures , 1992 .

[61]  R. Sternberg,et al.  Learning and individual differences: Advances in theory and research. , 1989 .

[62]  P. Lachenbruch.  Statistical Power Analysis for the Behavioral Sciences (2nd ed.) , 1989 .

[63]  Ann L. Brown,et al.  Analogical transfer in young children: Analogies as tools for communication and exposition , 1989 .

[64]  David Reinking,et al.  The Effects of Computer-Mediated Texts on the Vocabulary Learning and Comprehension of Intermediate-Grade Readers , 1990 .

[65]  Heinz Mandl,et al.  Analysis of complex skills and complex knowledge domains , 1990 .

[66]  Francis T. Durso,et al.  Partial Knowledge in Vocabulary Acquisition: General Constraints and Specific Detail , 1990 .

[67]  Davida Charney,et al.  Goal Setting and Procedure Selection in Acquiring Computer Skills: A Comparison of Tutorials, Problem Solving, and Learner Exploration , 1990 .

[68]  Selecting and cueing key phrases in instructional texts , 1990 .

[69]  P. Chandler,et al.  Cognitive load as a factor in the structuring of technical material. , 1990 .

[70]  Mark A. McDaniel,et al.  Discovery Learning and Transfer of Problem-Solving Skills , 1990 .

[71]  B. Rogoff.  Apprenticeship in Thinking: Cognitive Development in Social Context , 1990 .

[72]  W. Shadish,et al.  Reflections on a conference. , 1990 .

[73]  J. Sweller,et al.  Structuring Effective Worked Examples , 1990 .

[74]  Children's Guided Participation in Planning Imaginary Errands with Skilled Adult or Peer Partners. , 1991 .

[75]  George Brant,et al.  Which Comes First the Simulation or the Lecture? , 1991 .

[76]  A. King.  Effects of training in strategic questioning on children's problem-solving performance , 1991 .

[77]  Amelia Lee,et al.  Comparison of Guided and Discovery Learning Strategies , 1991 .

[78]  M. Elias,et al.  A comparison of instructional methods for delivering a preventive social competence/social decision making program to at risk, average, and competent students. , 1991 .

[79]  P. Chandler,et al.  Cognitive Load Theory and the Format of Instruction , 1991 .

[80]  Ann Thompson,et al.  Effects of Guided Programming Instruction on the Transfer of Analogical Reasoning , 1991 .

[81]  Anita Jackson,et al.  When talking doesn't help: An investigation of microcomputer-based group problem solving , 1992 .

[82]  F. Paas.  Training strategies for attaining transfer of problem-solving skill in statistics: A cognitive-load approach. , 1992 .

[83]  J. Elshout,et al.  Relation between Intellectual Ability and Working Method as Predictors of Learning. , 1992 .

[84]  Hans van der Meij,et al.  Assessment of the Minimalist Approach to Computer User Documentation , 1993, Interact. Comput..

[85]  D. Messer,et al.  Influences on the effectiveness of peer interaction: Children's level of cognitive development and the relative ability of partners. , 1993 .

[86]  J. Hiebert,et al.  Instructional Tasks, Classroom Discourse, and Students’ Learning in Second-Grade Arithmetic , 1993 .

[87]  D. Leutner.  Guided discovery learning with computer-based simulation games: Effects of adaptive and non-adaptive instructional support , 1993 .

[88]  Ard W. Lazonder,et al.  The Minimal Manual: Is Less Really More? , 1993, Int. J. Man Mach. Stud..

[89]  J. Bruer.  Schools for Thought: A Science of Learning in the Classroom , 1993 .

[90]  J. Sweller.  COGNITIVE LOAD THEORY, LEARNING DIFFICULTY, AND INSTRUCTIONAL DESIGN , 1994 .

[91]  F. Paas,et al.  Variability of Worked Examples and Transfer of Geometrical Problem-Solving Skills: A Cognitive-Load Approach , 1994 .

[92]  Hitendra K. Pillay,et al.  Cognitive load and mental rotation: structuring orthographic projection for learning and problem solving , 1994 .

[93]  J. Elshout,et al.  Metacognitive mediation in learning with computer-based simulations , 1994 .

[94]  Hans van der Meij,et al.  Effect of Error Information in Tutorial Documentation , 1994, Interact. Comput..

[95]  Kurt W. Fischer,et al.  Constructive criticism and social lies: A developmental sequence for understanding honesty and kindness in social interactions. , 1994 .

[96]  William M. Carroll.  Using worked examples as an instructional support in the algebra classroom. , 1994 .

[97]  John Sweller,et al.  Demands Imposed on Primary-School Students by Geometric Models , 1994 .

[98]  Michelene T. H. Chi,et al.  Eliciting Self-Explanations Improves Understanding , 1994, Cogn. Sci..

[99]  Sharon Tkacz,et al.  Student study techniques and the generation effect. , 1994 .

[100]  Lloyd P. Rieber,et al.  To Teach or Not to Teach? Comparing the Use of Computer-Based Simulations in Deductive versus Inductive Approaches to Learning with Adults in Science , 1995 .

[101]  Ard W. Lazonder,et al.  Error-information in tutorial documentation: Supporting users' errors to facilitate initial skill learning , 1995, Int. J. Hum. Comput. Stud..

[102]  Ann L. Brown,et al.  Training in Self-Explanation and Self-Regulation Strategies: Investigating the Effects of Knowledge Acquisition Activities on Problem Solving , 1995 .

[103]  D. Messer,et al.  Using Computers to Help Pupils Tell the Time, is Feedback Necessary? , 1996 .

[104]  Axel Cleeremans,et al.  Comparing direct and indirect measures of sequence learning , 1996 .

[105]  Development Without Learning , 1996 .

[106]  Jill L. Quilici,et al.  Role of examples in how students learn to categorize statistics word problems. , 1996 .

[107]  M. Cole,et al.  Beyond the Individual-Social Antinomy in Discussions of Piaget and Vygotsky , 1996 .

[108]  Ann L. Brown,et al.  The Effect of Instructional Explanations on Learning From Scientific Texts , 1997 .

[109]  Ann Thompson,et al.  Guided Instruction in Logo Programming and the Development of Cognitive Monitoring Strategies among College Students , 1997 .

[110]  Constance Kamii,et al.  To teach or not to teach algorithms , 1997 .

[111]  W. V. van Meurs,et al.  A Comparison of Traditional Textbook and Interactive Computer Learning of Neuromuscular Block , 1997, Anesthesia and analgesia.

[112]  Alexander Renkl,et al.  Instructional effects in complex learning: Do objective and subjective learning outcomes converge? , 1998 .

[113]  Daniel L. Schwartz,et al.  A time for telling , 1998 .

[114]  T. Jong,et al.  Supporting simulation-based learning; the effects of model progression and assignments on definitional and intuitive knowledge , 1998 .

[115]  H. Carl Haywood,et al.  Two ways to elaborate Vygotsky's concept of mediation. , 1998 .

[116]  Robbie Case,et al.  The development of conceptual structures. , 1998 .

[117]  J. Sweller,et al.  Learning to Solve Compare Word Problems: The Effect of Example Format and Generating Self-Explanations , 1998 .

[118]  Y. Engeström,et al.  Activity theory and individual and social transformation. , 1999 .

[119]  D. Klahr,et al.  All other things being equal: acquisition and transfer of the control of variables strategy. , 1999, Child development.

[120]  M. Alibali.  How children change their minds: strategy change can be gradual or abrupt. , 1999, Developmental psychology.

[121]  K. Crowley,et al.  Explanation and generalization in young children's strategy learning. , 1999, Child development.

[122]  J. Tuovinen,et al.  A comparison of cognitive load associated with discovery learning and worked examples , 1999 .

[123]  The role of augmented information prior to learning a bimanual visual‐motor coordination task: Do instructions of the movement pattern facilitate learning relative to discovery learning? , 1999 .

[124]  The teachability of children with naive theories: An exploration of the effects of two teaching methods , 1999 .

[125]  Maria Bannert,et al.  The effects of training wheels and self-learning materials in software training , 2008, J. Comput. Assist. Learn..

[126]  John B. Black,et al.  The Development of Cognitive Skills To Support Inquiry Learning , 2000 .

[127]  J. Norris,et al.  Effectiveness of L2 Instruction: A Research Synthesis and Quantitative Meta‐analysis , 2000 .

[128]  J. Flavell.  Development of children’s knowledge about the mental world , 2000 .

[129]  A. Stetsenko,et al.  The Quality of Cultural Tools and Cognitive Development: Gal’perin’s Perspective and Its Implications1 , 2000, Human Development.

[130]  D. Messer,et al.  Differential Benefits from Scaffolding and Children Working Alone , 2000 .

[131]  K. Pine,et al.  The Effect of Explaining Another's Actions on Children's Implicit Theories of Balance , 2000 .

[132]  R E Wood,et al.  Impact of guided exploration and enactive exploration on self-regulatory mechanisms and information acquisition through electronic search. , 2001, The Journal of applied psychology.

[133]  S. Petcharatana,et al.  Does computer‐assisted instruction really help to improve the learning process? , 2001, Medical education.

[134]  H. Wellman,et al.  The emergence of children's causal explanations and theories: evidence from everyday conversation. , 2001, Developmental psychology.

[135]  Slava Kalyuga,et al.  Learner Experience and Efficiency of Instructional Guidance , 2001 .

[136]  Slava Kalyuga,et al.  When problem solving is superior to studying worked examples. , 2001 .

[137]  Z. Zacharia,et al.  The effects of an interactive computer-based simulation prior to performing a laboratory inquiry-based experiment on science teachers' conceptual understanding of physics , 2002 .

[138]  H. Mandl,et al.  Conditions and effects of example elaboration , 2002 .

[139]  Erika Tunteler,et al.  Spontaneous analogical transfer in 4-year-olds: a microgenetic study. , 2002, Journal of experimental child psychology.

[140]  B. H. Pillow,et al.  Facilitating Children's Understanding of Misinterpretation: Explanatory Efforts and Improvements in Perspective Taking , 2002, The Journal of genetic psychology.

[141]  R. Sutherland,et al.  Knowing in advance: the impact of prior event information on memory and event knowledge. , 2003, Journal of experimental child psychology.

[142]  D. Kelemen.  British and American children's preferences for teleo-functional explanations of the natural world , 2003, Cognition.

[143]  P. Chandler,et al.  When imagining information is effective , 2003 .

[144]  Jianwei Zhang,et al.  Supporting scientific discovery learning in a simulation environment , 2003, J. Comput. Assist. Learn..

[145]  F. Paas,et al.  Cognitive Load Theory and Instructional Design: Recent Developments , 2003 .

[146]  Philip David Zelazo,et al.  Sources of inflexibility in 6-year-olds' understanding of emotion in speech. , 2003, Child development.

[147]  D. Kuhn,et al.  Connecting Scientific Reasoning and Causal Inference , 2004 .

[148]  R. Pea,et al.  The Social and Technological Dimensions of Scaffolding and Related Theoretical Concepts for Learning, Education, and Human Activity , 2004, The Journal of the Learning Sciences.

[149]  R. Mayer.  Should there be a three-strikes rule against pure discovery learning? The case for guided methods of instruction. , 2004, The American psychologist.

[150]  Jianwei Zhang,et al.  Triple scheme of learning support design for scientific discovery learning based on computer simulation: experimental research , 2004, J. Comput. Assist. Learn..

[151]  Milena K. Nigam,et al.  The Equivalence of Learning Paths in Early Science Instruction: Effects of Direct Instruction and Discovery Learning , 2022 .

[152]  Ton de Jong,et al.  The effects of discovery learning and expository instruction on the acquisition of definitional and intuitive knowledge , 2004, J. Comput. Assist. Learn..

[153]  Agency mediation and an understanding of the mind , 2004, Behavioral and Brain Sciences.

[154]  Arnaud Destrebecqz,et al.  The effect of explicit knowledge on sequence learning: A graded account , 2004 .

[155]  D. Kuhn,et al.  Is Developing Scientific Thinking All About Learning to Control Variables? , 2005, Psychological science.

[156]  P. Kirschner,et al.  Optimizing the number of steps in learning tasks for complex skills. , 2005, The British journal of educational psychology.

[157]  Christine Howe,et al.  Chance favours only the prepared mind: Incubation and the delayed effects of peer collaboration. , 2005, British journal of psychology.

[158]  Catherine E. Snow,et al.  Sustained vocabulary-learning strategy instruction for english-language learners , 2005 .

[159]  H. Wellman,et al.  Theories of Mind in Transition: A Microgenetic Study of the Development of False Belief Understanding , 2006 .

[160]  Andrew T. Stull,et al.  Three Experimental Comparisons of Learner-generated versus Author-provided Graphic Organizers , 2007 .

[161]  Mona Hicks,et al.  Our Underachieving Colleges: A Candid Look at How Much Students Learn and Why They Should Be Learning More , 2006 .

[162]  T. Lombrozo.  The structure and function of explanations , 2006, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[163]  A. Stetsenko,et al.  Embracing History through Transforming It , 2006 .

[164]  B. Rittle-Johnson,et al.  Promoting transfer: effects of self-explanation and direct instruction. , 2006, Child development.

[165]  Richard E. Clark,et al.  Why Minimal Guidance During Instruction Does Not Work: An Analysis of the Failure of Constructivist, Discovery, Problem-Based, Experiential, and Inquiry-Based Teaching , 2006 .

[166]  F. Keil,et al.  Explanation and understanding , 2015 .

[167]  Kim A. Kastens,et al.  Eliciting Self-Explanations Improves Children's Performance on a Field-Based Map Skills Task , 2007 .

[168]  Gabrielle Rappolt-Schlichtmann,et al.  Transient and Robust Knowledge: Contextual Support and the Dynamics of Children’s Reasoning About Density , 2007 .

[169]  Michael A. McDaniel,et al.  The generation effect: A meta-analytic review , 2007, Memory & cognition.

[170]  M. Pipe,et al.  Does providing props during preparation help children to remember a novel event? , 2007, Journal of experimental child psychology.

[171]  C. Hmelo‐Silver,et al.  Scaffolding and Achievement in Problem-Based and Inquiry Learning: A Response to Kirschner, Sweller, and Clark (2006) , 2007 .

[172]  J. Sweller,et al.  Why Minimally Guided Teaching Techniques Do Not Work: A Reply to Commentaries , 2007 .

[173]  Kevin Crowley,et al.  How Parent Explanation Changes What Children Learn from Everyday Scientific Thinking. , 2007 .

[174]  Sofie M. M. Loyens,et al.  Problem-Based Learning is Compatible with Human Cognitive Architecture: Commentary on Kirschner, Sweller, and Clark (2006) , 2007 .

[175]  Richard E. Mayer,et al.  Learning and Instruction , 2007 .

[176]  Deanna Kuhn,et al.  Is Direct Instruction an Answer to the Right Question? , 2007 .

[177]  David C. Geary,et al.  Whither Evolutionary Educational Psychology? , 2008 .

[178]  D. Klahr,et al.  Developing elementary science skills: Instructional effectiveness and path independence , 2008 .

[179]  P. J. Brooks,et al.  The effects of explanatory conversations on children's emotion understanding , 2008 .

[180]  B. Rittle-Johnson,et al.  Learning from explaining: does it matter if mom is listening? , 2008, Journal of experimental child psychology.

[181]  A. Stetsenko,et al.  Teaching, Learning, and Development: A Post‐Vygotskian Perspective , 2008 .

[182]  Taking Guided Learning Theory to School: Reconciling the Cognitive, Motivational, and Social Contexts of Instruction , 2009 .

[183]  Richard E. Mayer,et al.  Constructivism as a theory of learning versus constructivism as a prescription for instruction. , 2009 .

[184]  Rand J. Spiro,et al.  Constructivism: When it's the wrong idea and when it's the only idea. , 2009 .

[185]  D. Klahr.  “ To Every Thing There is a Season, and a Time to Every Purpose Under the Heavens” What about Direct Instruction? , 2009 .

[186]  Michelene T. H. Chi,et al.  Active-Constructive-Interactive: A Conceptual Framework for Differentiating Learning Activities , 2009, Top. Cogn. Sci..

[187]  B. Rosenshine.  The Empirical Support for Direct Instruction , 2009 .

[188]  From behaviorism to constructivism: A philosophical journey from drill and practice to situated learning. , 2009 .

[189]  W. Kintsch.  Learning and constructivism. , 2009 .

[190]  Daniel L. Schwartz,et al.  Constructivism in an age of non-constructivist assessments , 2009 .

[191]  Alyssa Friend Wise,et al.  Beyond More Versus Less: A Reframing of the Debate on Instructional Guidance , 2009 .

[192]  John Sweller,et al.  What Human Cognitive Architecture Tells Us About Constructivism , 2009 .

[193]  Reflections on the Conference , 2011 .

[194]  John Sweller,et al.  Cognitive Load Theory , 2020, Encyclopedia of Education and Information Technologies.