Empathic Care and Distress: Predictive Brain Markers and Dissociable Brain Systems

Encountering another's suffering can elicit both empathic distress and empathic care-the warm desire to affiliate. It remains unclear whether these two feelings can be accurately and differentially predicted from neural activity and to what extent their neural substrates can be distinguished. We developed fMRI markers predicting moment-by-moment intensity levels of care and distress intensity while participants (n = 66) listened to true biographies describing human suffering. Both markers' predictions correlated strongly with self-report in out-of-sample participants (r = 0.59 and r = 0.63, p < 0.00001), and both markers predicted later trial-by-trial charitable donation amounts (p < 0.05). Empathic care was preferentially associated with nucleus accumbens and medial orbitofrontal cortex activity, whereas distress was preferentially associated with premotor and somatosensory cortical activity. In tests of marker specificity with an independent behavioral sample (n = 200), the empathic care marker was associated with a mixed-valence feeling state, whereas the empathic distress marker was specific to negative emotion.

[1]  M. Numan.  Neural basis of maternal behavior in the rat , 1988, Psychoneuroendocrinology.

[2]  M. Lindquist,et al.  An fMRI-based neurologic signature of physical pain. , 2013, The New England journal of medicine.

[3]  A. Damasio,et al.  Neural correlates of admiration and compassion , 2009, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[4]  Carrie L. Masten,et al.  Empathy for the social suffering of friends and strangers recruits distinct patterns of brain activation. , 2013, Social cognitive and affective neuroscience.

[5]  Jason P. Mitchell,et al.  Equitable decision making is associated with neural markers of intrinsic value , 2011, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[6]  T. Sheehan,et al.  The Septal Region and Social Behavior , 2000 .

[7]  Kevin N. Ochsner,et al.  A Meta-analysis of Functional Neuroimaging Studies of Self- and Other Judgments Reveals a Spatial Gradient for Mentalizing in Medial Prefrontal Cortex , 2012, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience.

[8]  Polina Kukar,et al.  Against empathy: The case for rational compassion , 2018 .

[9]  A. Böckler,et al.  Are strong empathizers better mentalizers? Evidence for independence and interaction between the routes of social cognition. , 2016, Social cognitive and affective neuroscience.

[10]  Emile G. Bruneau,et al.  Distinct roles of the ‘Shared Pain’ and ‘Theory of Mind’ networks in processing others’ emotional suffering , 2012, Neuropsychologia.

[11]  Jin Fan,et al.  Somatic and vicarious pain are represented by dissociable multivariate brain patterns , 2016, eLife.

[12]  M. Houben,et al.  The relation between short-term emotion dynamics and psychological well-being: A meta-analysis. , 2015, Psychological bulletin.

[13]  F. D. Waal.  Putting the Altruism Back into Altruism: The Evolution of Empathy , 2008 .

[14]  Brian Knutson,et al.  Neural Underpinnings of the Identifiable Victim Effect: Affect Shifts Preferences for Giving , 2013, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[15]  Tania Singer,et al.  Empathic distress fatigue rather than compassion fatigue? Integrating findings from empathy research in psychology and social neuroscience , 2012 .

[16]  Paul Bloom,et al.  Against empathy: The case for rational compassion , 2018 .

[17]  J. Aharon-Peretz,et al.  Two systems for empathy: a double dissociation between emotional and cognitive empathy in inferior frontal gyrus versus ventromedial prefrontal lesions. , 2009, Brain : a journal of neurology.

[18]  Ethan Kross,et al.  Separate neural representations for physical pain and social rejection , 2014, Nature Communications.

[19]  D. Kahneman,et al.  When More Pain Is Preferred to Less: Adding a Better End , 1993 .

[20]  P. Shaver,et al.  Emotion knowledge: further exploration of a prototype approach. , 1987, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[21]  Jae-Young Son,et al.  Norms and the Flexibility of Moral Action , 2018, Personality Neuroscience.

[22]  Dino J. Levy,et al.  The root of all value: a neural common currency for choice , 2012, Current Opinion in Neurobiology.

[23]  J. Hirsch,et al.  Reduced Anterior Temporal and Hippocampal Functional Connectivity During Face Processing Discriminates Individuals with Social Anxiety Disorder from Healthy Controls and Panic Disorder, and Increases Following Treatment , 2014, Neuropsychopharmacology.

[24]  Luca Passamonti,et al.  A Key Role for Similarity in Vicarious Reward , 2009, Science.

[25]  Carrie L. Masten,et al.  An fMRI investigation of empathy for ‘social pain’ and subsequent prosocial behavior , 2011, NeuroImage.

[26]  A. Mouraux,et al.  The pain matrix reloaded A salience detection system for the body , 2011, Progress in Neurobiology.

[27]  Diane E. Stodola,et al.  Compassion Training Alters Altruism and Neural Responses to Suffering , 2013, Psychological science.

[28]  Thomas E. Nichols,et al.  Thresholding of Statistical Maps in Functional Neuroimaging Using the False Discovery Rate , 2002, NeuroImage.

[29]  Niall W. Duncan,et al.  Is there a core neural network in empathy? An fMRI based quantitative meta-analysis , 2011, Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews.

[30]  Tania Singer,et al.  Differential pattern of functional brain plasticity after compassion and empathy training. , 2014, Social cognitive and affective neuroscience.

[31]  Tania Singer,et al.  Empathy and compassion , 2014, Current Biology.

[32]  M. Peelen,et al.  Supramodal Representations of Perceived Emotions in the Human Brain , 2010, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[33]  Talma Hendler,et al.  Cry for her or cry with her: context-dependent dissociation of two modes of cinematic empathy reflected in network cohesion dynamics. , 2014, Social cognitive and affective neuroscience.

[34]  R. Hari,et al.  Discrete Neural Signatures of Basic Emotions. , 2016, Cerebral cortex.

[35]  C. Daniel Batson,et al.  Altruism in Humans , 2011 .

[36]  G. Tononi,et al.  Human cortical excitability increases with time awake. , 2013, Cerebral cortex.

[37]  Edward E. Smith,et al.  Placebo-Induced Changes in fMRI in the Anticipation and Experience of Pain , 2004, Science.

[38]  Luke J. Chang,et al.  A Sensitive and Specific Neural Signature for Picture-Induced Negative Affect , 2015, PLoS biology.

[39]  Rebecca Saxe,et al.  How We Know It Hurts: Item Analysis of Written Narratives Reveals Distinct Neural Responses to Others' Physical Pain and Emotional Suffering , 2013, PloS one.

[40]  M. Iacoboni,et al.  The mirror neuron system and the consequences of its dysfunction , 2006, Nature Reviews Neuroscience.

[41]  Lisa Feldman Barrett,et al.  Conceptualizing and experiencing compassion. , 2013, Emotion.

[42]  Philip A. Kragel,et al.  Decoding the Nature of Emotion in the Brain , 2016, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[43]  Rebecca Saxe,et al.  Social cognition in members of conflict groups: behavioural and neural responses in Arabs, Israelis and South Americans to each other's misfortunes , 2012, Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences.

[44]  Thomas R Insel,et al.  The Challenge of Translation in Social Neuroscience: A Review of Oxytocin, Vasopressin, and Affiliative Behavior , 2010, Neuron.

[45]  Kristen A. Lindquist,et al.  The brain basis of emotion: A meta-analytic review , 2012, Behavioral and Brain Sciences.

[46]  Russell A. Poldrack,et al.  Large-scale automated synthesis of human functional neuroimaging data , 2011, Nature Methods.

[47]  Luke J. Chang,et al.  Brain Mechanisms of the Placebo Effect: An Affective Appraisal Account. , 2017, Annual review of clinical psychology.

[48]  Rodrigo Basilio,et al.  Voluntary Enhancement of Neural Signatures of Affiliative Emotion Using fMRI Neurofeedback , 2014, PloS one.

[49]  Katrin Amunts,et al.  Stereotaxic probabilistic maps of the magnocellular cell groups in human basal forebrain , 2008, NeuroImage.

[50]  L. Uddin.  Salience processing and insular cortical function and dysfunction , 2014, Nature Reviews Neuroscience.

[51]  Tristen K. Inagaki,et al.  Neural Correlates of Giving Support to a Loved One , 2012, Psychosomatic medicine.

[52]  G. Loewenstein,et al.  Neural Predictors of Purchases , 2007, Neuron.

[53]  S. Fiske,et al.  Social groups that elicit disgust are differentially processed in mPFC. , 2007, Social cognitive and affective neuroscience.

[54]  D. Pizzagalli,et al.  Corticostriatal pathways contribute to the natural time course of positive mood , 2015, Nature Communications.

[55]  Claus Lamm,et al.  Meta-analytic evidence for common and distinct neural networks associated with directly experienced pain and empathy for pain , 2011, NeuroImage.

[56]  C. Lamm,et al.  The role of shared neural activations, mirror neurons, and morality in empathy – A critical comment , 2015, Neuroscience Research.

[57]  Daniel T. Knoepfle,et al.  Value Computations in Ventral Medial Prefrontal Cortex during Charitable Decision Making Incorporate Input from Regions Involved in Social Cognition , 2010, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[58]  R. Bredewold,et al.  Dynamic changes in extracellular release of GABA and glutamate in the lateral septum during social play behavior in juvenile rats: Implications for sex-specific regulation of social play behavior , 2015, Neuroscience.

[59]  Jamil Zaki,et al.  Common and distinct neural correlates of personal and vicarious reward: A quantitative meta-analysis , 2015, NeuroImage.

[60]  Claus Lamm,et al.  The Neural Substrate of Human Empathy: Effects of Perspective-taking and Cognitive Appraisal , 2007, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience.

[61]  Brian Knutson,et al.  When Giving Is Good: Ventromedial Prefrontal Cortex Activation for Others' Intentions , 2010, Neuron.

[62]  Thomas L. Griffiths,et al.  Supplementary Information for Natural Speech Reveals the Semantic Maps That Tile Human Cerebral Cortex , 2022 .

[63]  N. Kriegeskorte,et al.  Neural correlates of trust , 2007, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[64]  Fenna M. Krienen,et al.  Clan Mentality: Evidence That the Medial Prefrontal Cortex Responds to Close Others , 2010, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[65]  Brian Knutson,et al.  Neural Affective Mechanisms Predict Market-Level Microlending , 2015, Psychological science.

[66]  Ivanei E. Bramati,et al.  A Neural Signature of Affiliative Emotion in the Human Septohypothalamic Area , 2012, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[67]  T. Johnstone,et al.  Regulation of the Neural Circuitry of Emotion by Compassion Meditation: Effects of Meditative Expertise , 2008, PloS one.

[68]  M. Just,et al.  Identifying Emotions on the Basis of Neural Activation , 2013, PloS one.

[69]  Marie Schaer,et al.  Degrees of separation: A quantitative neuroimaging meta-analysis investigating self-specificity and shared neural activation between self- and other-reflection , 2012, Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews.

[70]  Christian Keysers,et al.  Somatosensation in social perception , 2010, Nature Reviews Neuroscience.

[71]  Yoni K. Ashar,et al.  Toward a Neuroscience of Compassion , 2016 .

[72]  Franck Zenasni,et al.  Burnout and empathy in primary care: three hypotheses. , 2012, The British journal of general practice : the journal of the Royal College of General Practitioners.

[73]  A. Meltzoff,et al.  Empathy examined through the neural mechanisms involved in imagining how I feel versus how you feel pain , 2006, Neuropsychologia.

[74]  Peng Ren,et al.  Voluntary control of anterior insula and its functional connections is feedback-independent and increases pain empathy , 2016, NeuroImage.

[75]  N. Kalin,et al.  Relationships between changes in sustained fronto-striatal connectivity and positive affect in major depression resulting from antidepressant treatment. , 2013, The American journal of psychiatry.

[76]  T. Singer,et al.  Functional neural plasticity and associated changes in positive affect after compassion training. , 2013, Cerebral cortex.

[77]  R. R. Reno,et al.  Relation of sympathy and personal distress to prosocial behavior: a multimethod study. , 1989, Journal of personality and social psychology.

[78]  J. Mattingley,et al.  Brain regions with mirror properties: A meta-analysis of 125 human fMRI studies , 2012, Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews.

[79]  Haakon G. Engen,et al.  Compassion-based emotion regulation up-regulates experienced positive affect and associated neural networks. , 2015, Social cognitive and affective neuroscience.

[80]  Philip A. Kragel,et al.  Multivariate neural biomarkers of emotional states are categorically distinct. , 2015, Social cognitive and affective neuroscience.

[81]  J. Grafman,et al.  Human fronto–mesolimbic networks guide decisions about charitable donation , 2006, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

[82]  G. Rizzolatti,et al.  A unifying view of the basis of social cognition , 2004, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[83]  Luke J. Chang,et al.  Building better biomarkers: brain models in translational neuroimaging , 2017, Nature Neuroscience.

[84]  A. Meade,et al.  Identifying careless responses in survey data. , 2012, Psychological methods.

[85]  H. Möller,et al.  Individualized differential diagnosis of schizophrenia and mood disorders using neuroanatomical biomarkers. , 2015, Brain : a journal of neurology.

[86]  Thomas E. Nichols,et al.  A Bayesian Model of Category-Specific Emotional Brain Responses , 2015, PLoS Comput. Biol..

[87]  Yoni K. Ashar,et al.  Effects of compassion meditation on a psychological model of charitable donation. , 2016, Emotion.

[88]  Ulrich Mayr,et al.  Neural Responses to Taxation and Voluntary Giving Reveal Motives for Charitable Donations , 2007, Science.

[89]  Matthew D. Lieberman,et al.  The neural components of empathy: predicting daily prosocial behavior. , 2014, Social cognitive and affective neuroscience.

[90]  Tim D Caroe.  Burnout and empathy in primary care. , 2012, The British journal of general practice : the journal of the Royal College of General Practitioners.

[91]  Ajay B. Satpute,et al.  The Brain Basis of Positive and Negative Affect: Evidence from a Meta-Analysis of the Human Neuroimaging Literature. , 2016, Cerebral cortex.

[92]  Arne D. Ekstrom,et al.  Single-Neuron Responses in Humans during Execution and Observation of Actions , 2010, Current Biology.

[93]  Martin A. Lindquist,et al.  Group-regularized individual prediction: theory and application to pain , 2017, NeuroImage.

[94]  Brian Knutson,et al.  Neural valuation of environmental resources , 2015, NeuroImage.

[95]  Patrik Vuilleumier,et al.  Cross-modal representations of first-hand and vicarious pain, disgust and fairness in insular and cingulate cortex , 2016, Nature Communications.

[96]  J. Decety,et al.  Empathy versus personal distress: Recent evidence from social neuroscience. , 2009 .

[97]  K. Ochsner,et al.  The neuroscience of empathy: progress, pitfalls and promise , 2012, Nature Neuroscience.

[98]  C. Batson,et al.  Distress and empathy: two qualitatively distinct vicarious emotions with different motivational consequences. , 1987, Journal of personality.