An evaluation of super-optimality as a control tool: a relative stability perspective

Super-optimality has been shown to maximize robust stability margins for a special class of systems but not for the general case. Notwithstanding the mathematical elegance of the approach therefore, it is not clear whether super-optimality generally affords practical advantages to the control engineer. The present paper investigates this issue from a relative stability perspective and shows by numerical example that one can achieve better results by selecting non-super-optimal controllers. The example quoted is in no way special and a procedure for generating others is given.