The Tale of Two Localization Technologies: Enabling Accurate Low-Overhead WiFi-based Localization for Low-end Phones

WiFi fingerprinting is one of the mainstream technologies for indoor localization. However, it requires an initial calibration phase during which the fingerprint database is built manually by site surveyors. This process is labour intensive, tedious, and needs to be repeated with any change in the environment. While a number of recent systems have been introduced to reduce the calibration effort through RF propagation models and/or crowdsourcing, these still have some limitations. Other approaches use the recently developed iBeacon technology as an alternative to WiFi for indoor localization. However, these beacon-based solutions are limited to a small subset of high-end phones. In this paper, we present HybridLoc: an accurate low-overhead indoor localization system. The basic idea HybridLoc builds on is to leverage the sensors of high-end phones to enable localization of lower-end phones. Specifically, the WiFi fingerprint is crowdsourced by opportunistically collecting WiFi-scans labeled with location data obtained from BLE-enabled high-end smart phones. These scans are used to automatically construct the WiFi-fingerprint, that is used later to localize any lower-end cell phone with the ubiquitous WiFi technology. HybridLoc also has provisions for handling the inherent error in the estimated BLE locations used in constructing the fingerprint as well as to handle practical deployment issues including the noisy wireless environment, heterogeneous devices, among others. Evaluation of HybridLoc using Android phones shows that it can provide accurate localization in the same range as manual fingerprinting techniques under the same deployment conditions. Moreover, the localization accuracy on low-end phones supporting only WiFi is comparable to that achieved with high-end phones supporting BLE. This accuracy is achieved with no training overhead, is robust to the different user devices, and is consistent under environment changes.