Is a naturalistic theory of communication possible?

This article presents a theoretical discussion of the relationship between language and communication. I discuss Chomsky's position on this topic. Chomsky claims that if it is possible to construct a scientific theory of the language faculty, there is no possibility to construct a scientific theory of communication because in communication human intentionality is involved. This position is contrasted by philosophers of language considering that communication is to be studied as a form of rational action. I maintain that both these positions are not supported by the evidence coming from developmental research. Taking a cognitive point of view I contend that a communicative faculty can be defined that develops since infancy to adulthood, which has features independent of language and action. Different steps in the development of the communicative ability are linked to a parallel development of the theory of mind. I then argue in favor of a distinction between collective action and communication considering that while collective action is common to human and nonhuman primates, communication is typically human.

[1]  M. Harris.  Language Comprehension in Ape and Child , 1994 .

[2]  M. Tomasello,et al.  Understanding and sharing intentions: The origins of cultural cognition , 2005, Behavioral and Brain Sciences.

[3]  Hal Whitehead,et al.  Culture in whales and dolphins , 2001, Behavioral and Brain Sciences.

[4]  A. Meltzoff,et al.  Imitation of Facial and Manual Gestures by Human Neonates , 1977, Science.

[5]  Christophe Boesch,et al.  Joint cooperative hunting among wild chimpanzees: Taking natural observations seriously , 2005, Behavioral and Brain Sciences.

[6]  C. Heyes.  Causes and consequences of imitation , 2001, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[7]  C. Trevarthen,et al.  What infants' imitations communicate: With mothers, with fathers and with peers. , 1999 .

[8]  Michael Halliday,et al.  An Introduction to Functional Grammar , 1985 .

[9]  G. Airenti.  Le rôle des représentations dans le développement de la capacité communicative , 2001 .

[10]  Michael Tomasello,et al.  Chimpanzees versus humans: it's not that simple , 2003, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[11]  J. Stevenson.  The cultural origins of human cognition , 2001 .

[12]  Noam Chomsky,et al.  New horizons in the study of language , 1997 .

[13]  W. Fitch,et al.  Computational Constraints on Syntactic Processing in a Nonhuman Primate , 2004, Science.

[14]  M. Colombetti,et al.  Failures, exploitations and deceits in communication , 1993 .

[15]  A. Meltzoff.  Origins of theory of mind, cognition and communication. , 1999, Journal of communication disorders.

[16]  S. Baron-Cohen.  Precursors to a theory of mind: Understanding attention in others. , 1991 .

[17]  R. L. Schiefelbusch,et al.  The Acquisition Of Communicative Competence , 1984 .

[18]  Nick Chater,et al.  Perspectives on Imitation , 2004 .

[19]  Noam Chomsky.  Reflections on Language. , 1977 .

[20]  N. Fox,et al.  Social perception in infants , 1985 .

[21]  J. Bruner,et al.  The capacity for joint visual attention in the infant , 1975, Nature.

[22]  J. Peskin.  Ruse and Representations: On Children's Ability to Conceal Information. , 1992 .

[23]  Gerald Gazdar,et al.  Pragmatics: Implicature, Presupposition, and Logical Form , 1978 .

[24]  E. Schegloff,et al.  A simplest systematics for the organization of turn-taking for conversation , 1974 .

[25]  B. Sodian.  The development of deception in young children , 1991 .

[26]  B. Webber,et al.  Elements of Discourse Understanding , 1983 .

[27]  The development of communicative background: nonverbal interactions and speech acts , 2005 .

[28]  Jeni E. Yamada.  Laura : a case for the modularity of language , 1990 .

[29]  Paul J. Thibault,et al.  Brains, bodies, contextualising activity and language: do humans (and bonobos) have a language faculty, and can they do without one? , 2007 .

[30]  Jane A. Herman,et al.  Learning How to Say What One Means: A Longitudinal Study of Children's Speech Act Use* , 1996 .

[31]  Kevin R. Gregg,et al.  SLA volume 17 issue 1 Cover and Front matter , 1995, Studies in Second Language Acquisition.

[32]  Timothy Q. Gentner,et al.  Recursive syntactic pattern learning by songbirds , 2006, Nature.

[33]  W. Yule,et al.  A cognitive and behavioural phenotype in Williams syndrome. , 1991, Journal of clinical and experimental neuropsychology.

[34]  Sandra Weintraub,et al.  The acquisition of routines in child language , 1976, Language in Society.

[35]  Gerald Gazdar.  Implicature, presupposition and logical form , 1977 .

[36]  Penelope Brown,et al.  Politeness: Some Universals in Language Usage , 1989 .

[37]  Noam Chomsky.  Language and Nature , 1995 .

[38]  A. Lock.  Action, gesture, and symbol : the emergence of language , 1978 .

[39]  B. McCowan,et al.  Spontaneous vocal mimicry and production by bottlenose dolphins (Tursiops truncatus): evidence for vocal learning. , 1993, Journal of comparative psychology.

[40]  M. A. Cunningham,et al.  The Biology of Bird-Song Dialects , 1985, Behavioral and Brain Sciences.

[41]  R. Byrne,et al.  Machiavellian intelligence : social expertise and the evolution of intellect in monkeys, apes, and humans , 1990 .

[42]  D. Stern,et al.  VOCALIZING IN UNISON AND IN ALTERNATION: TWO MODES OF COMMUNICATION WITHIN THE MOTHER‐INFANT DYAD * , 1975, Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences.

[43]  G. Airenti,et al.  Dialogue in a Developmental Perspective , 1998 .

[44]  M. Tomasello,et al.  Chimpanzees know what conspecifics do and do not see , 2000, Animal Behaviour.

[45]  A. Meltzoff,et al.  Infant vocalizations in response to speech: vocal imitation and developmental change. , 1996, The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America.

[46]  J. Searle.  Consciousness and Language: Collective Intentions and Actions , 2002 .

[47]  H. Grice.  Reasoning: Further Notes on Logic and Conversation , 2008 .

[48]  J. Wisdom.  Other Minds , 1941, Royal Institute of Philosophy Lectures.

[49]  J. Bruner.  The ontogenesis of speech acts , 1975, Journal of Child Language.

[50]  Meaning, belief, and language acquisition , 1996 .

[51]  P. Strawson.  Intention and Convention in Speech Acts , 1964 .

[52]  T. Zentall,et al.  Social learning : psychological and biological perspectives , 1988 .

[53]  M. Tomasello,et al.  Do chimpanzees know what conspecifics know? , 2001, Animal Behaviour.

[54]  G. Bateson,et al.  Mind and Nature: A Necessary Unity , 1979 .

[55]  Ursula Bellugi,et al.  Dissociation between language and cognitive functions in Williams syndrome , 1988 .

[56]  Noam Chomsky,et al.  Language and problems of knowledge : the Managua lectures , 1990 .

[57]  J. Lucariello,et al.  The development of complex metarepresentational reasoning: The case of situational irony , 1995 .

[58]  Michael Tomasello,et al.  'Unwilling' versus 'unable': chimpanzees' understanding of human intentional action. , 2004, Developmental science.

[59]  Noam Chomsky.  Language and Problems of Knowledge , 1987 .

[60]  A. Meltzoff,et al.  Imitation, Memory, and the Representation of Persons. , 1994, Infant behavior & development.

[61]  Neil Smith,et al.  Learning the impossible: The acquisition of possible and impossible languages by a polyglot savant , 1993 .

[62]  S. Baron-Cohen,et al.  Understanding other minds : perspectives from autism , 1994 .

[63]  H. Grice.  Utterer's meaning and intentions , 1969 .

[64]  Vann McGee,et al.  Learning the impossible , 1994 .

[65]  A. Kasher,et al.  Language in Focus: Foundations, Methods and Systems , 1976 .

[66]  Philip R. Cohen,et al.  Collective Intentions and Actions , 2003 .

[67]  J. N. Hattiangadi.  How Is Language Possible? Philosophical Reflections on the Evolution of Language and Knowledge , 1988 .

[68]  Michael Tomasello,et al.  Joint Attention and Imitative Learning in Children, Chimpanzees, and Enculturated Chimpanzees* , 1995 .

[69]  M. Tomasello,et al.  Chimpanzees Recruit the Best Collaborators , 2006, Science.

[70]  T. Stone,et al.  Chomsky Amongst the Philosophers , 2002 .

[71]  A. Esposito,et al.  Language without communication: a case study , 1979, Journal of Child Language.

[72]  Asa Kasher,et al.  The Chomskyan Turn , 1993 .

[73]  Jacqueline Nadel,et al.  New Perspectives in Early Communicative Development , 1993 .

[74]  Susan S. Jones.  PSYCHOLOGICAL SCIENCE Research Article Imitation in Infancy The Development of Mimicry , 2022 .

[75]  木村 和夫.  Pragmatics , 1997, Language Teaching.

[76]  A. Decasper,et al.  Prenatal maternal speech influences newborns' perception of speech sounds , 1986 .

[77]  Jean Berko Gleason,et al.  Hi, thanks, and goodbye: More routine information , 1980, Language in Society.

[78]  R. Byrne,et al.  Why creative intelligence is hard to find , 1988, Behavioral and Brain Sciences.

[79]  Michael E. Bratman,et al.  Shared Cooperative Activity , 1991 .

[80]  D. Bishop,et al.  Language development in exceptional circumstances , 1988 .

[81]  Ori Friedman,et al.  Core mechanisms in ‘theory of mind’ , 2004, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[82]  Ear ly Communication : Beyond Speech-Act Theory , 2000 .

[83]  E. Schegloff,et al.  The preference for self-correction in the organization of repair in conversation , 1977 .

[84]  Alan M. Leslie,et al.  Autism and ostensive communication: The relevance of metarepresentation , 1989, Development and Psychopathology.

[85]  J. Bruner,et al.  Cultural learning. Author's reply , 1993 .

[86]  Csr Young,et al.  How to Do Things With Words , 2009 .

[87]  D. Olson,et al.  Developing theories of mind , 1988 .

[88]  B. Bower.  A Child's Theory of Mind , 1993 .

[89]  C. Trevarthen.  Communication and cooperation in early infancy: a description of primary intersubjectivity , 1979 .

[90]  Philip Smith,et al.  Pretend Play: Is It Metarepresentational? , 1994 .

[91]  Stein Bråten.  Intersubjective communication and emotion in early ontogeny , 1998 .

[92]  J. Fodor.  The Modularity of mind. An essay on faculty psychology , 1986 .

[93]  S. Curtiss.  Genie: A Psycholinguistic Study of a Modern-Day "Wild Child" , 1977 .

[94]  A. Leslie.  Pretense and representation: The origins of "theory of mind." , 1987 .

[95]  Noam Chomsky,et al.  The faculty of language: what is it, who has it, and how did it evolve? , 2002, Science.

[96]  Elizabeth Bates,et al.  The Acquisition of Performatives Prior to Speech. , 1975 .

[97]  Simon Baron-Cohen,et al.  Understanding other minds: Perspectives from developmental cognitive neuroscience, 2nd ed. , 2000 .

[98]  Patricia M. Clancy,et al.  The acquisition of Japanese , 1986 .

[99]  Brian J. Scholl,et al.  Modularity, Development and ‘Theory of Mind’ , 1999 .

[100]  E. W. Menzel,et al.  Chapter 3 - A Group of Young Chimpanzees in a One-Acre Field1 , 1974 .

[101]  Sandra A. Thompson,et al.  The language of turn and sequence , 2002 .

[102]  Siobhan Chapman.  Logic and Conversation , 2005 .

[103]  R L FANTZ,et al.  The origin of form perception. , 1961, Scientific American.

[104]  R. Martorell,et al.  Early supplementary feeding and cognition: effects over two decades. , 1969, Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development.

[105]  M. Anisfeld,et al.  Only Tongue Protrusion Modeling Is Matched by Neonates , 1996 .

[106]  H. Putnam.  Representation and Reality , 1993 .

[107]  K. Bard,et al.  Evolutionary foundations of imitation:social, cognitive, and developmental aspects of imitative processes in non-human primates , 1999 .

[108]  Thomas R. Zentall,et al.  Imitation by Animals , 2003 .

[109]  D. Bickerton.  Language and Human Behavior , 1996 .

[110]  J. Astington.  Promises: words or deeds? , 1988 .

[111]  R. Tuomela.  What is cooperation? , 1993 .

[112]  G. Gazdar,et al.  Syntax and semantics 9: Pragmatics: Peter Cole, ed., New York: Academic Press. 1978. pp. xii + 340. , 1980 .

[113]  Tim Ingold,et al.  Companion Encyclopedia of Anthropology , 1993 .

[114]  J. Bruner.  Child's Talk: Learning to Use Language , 1985 .

[115]  A. Decasper,et al.  Of Human Bonding: Newborns Prefer Their Mothers' Voices , 1980 .

[116]  Asa Kasher,et al.  Conversational Maxims and Rationality , 1976 .

[117]  B. Kent Houston,et al.  Children's Understanding of Social Interaction. , 1969 .

[118]  H. Wimmer,et al.  Beliefs about beliefs: Representation and constraining function of wrong beliefs in young children's understanding of deception , 1983, Cognition.

[119]  M. Colombetti,et al.  Conversation and behavior games in the pragmatics of dialogue , 1993 .

[120]  G. Kugiumutzakis,et al.  Genesis and development of early infant mimesis to facial and vocal models. , 1999 .

[121]  C. Trevarthen,et al.  MEASURING THE HUMAN VOICE : ANALYSING PITCH , TIMING , LOUDNESS , 1998 .

[122]  S. Danby.  The Communicative Competence of Young Children , 2002 .

[123]  Ivana Marková,et al.  The Social context of language , 1978 .

[124]  G. Butterworth.  The ontogeny and phylogeny of joint visual attention. , 1991 .

[125]  Philip R. Cohen,et al.  Intentions in Communication. , 1992 .

[126]  A. Meltzoff.  1 Imitation and Other Minds: The "Like Me" Hypothesis , 2005 .

[127]  J. Perner.  Understanding the Representational Mind , 1993 .