Understanding other minds: linking developmental psychology and functional neuroimaging.

Evidence from developmental psychology suggests that understanding other minds constitutes a special domain of cognition with at least two components: an early-developing system for reasoning about goals, perceptions, and emotions, and a later-developing system for representing the contents of beliefs. Neuroimaging reinforces and elaborates upon this view by providing evidence that (a) domain-specific brain regions exist for representing belief contents, (b) these regions are apparently distinct from other regions engaged in reasoning about goals and actions (suggesting that the two developmental stages reflect the emergence of two distinct systems, rather than the elaboration of a single system), and (c) these regions are distinct from brain regions engaged in inhibitory control and in syntactic processing. The clear neural distinction between these processes is evidence that belief attribution is not dependent on either inhibitory control or syntax, but is subserved by a specialized neural system for theory of mind.

[1]  J. Stroop,et al.  Factors affecting speed in serial verbal reactions. , 1938 .

[2]  C. Eriksen,et al.  Effects of noise letters upon the identification of a target letter in a nonsearch task , 1974 .

[3]  Daniel C. Dennett,et al.  Beliefs about beliefs [P&W, SR&B] , 1978, Behavioral and Brain Sciences.

[4]  D. Premack,et al.  Does the chimpanzee have a theory of mind? , 1978, Behavioral and Brain Sciences.

[5]  T. Field,et al.  Production and perception of facial expressions in infancy and early childhood. , 1982, Advances in child development and behavior.

[6]  M. Beeghly,et al.  Talking About Internal States: The Acquisition of an Explicit Theory of Mind , 1982 .

[7]  J. Searle Intentionality: Name index , 1983 .

[8]  H. Wimmer,et al.  Beliefs about beliefs: Representation and constraining function of wrong beliefs in young children's understanding of deception , 1983, Cognition.

[9]  J. Searle Intentionality: An Essay in the Philosophy of Mind , 1983 .

[10]  S. Baron-Cohen,et al.  Does the autistic child have a “theory of mind” ? , 1985, Cognition.

[11]  Inge Bretherton,et al.  Learning to Talk about Emotions: A Functionalist Perspective. , 1986 .

[12]  C. Nelson The recognition of facial expressions in the first two years of life: mechanisms of development. , 1987, Child development.

[13]  John H. Flavell,et al.  The development of children's knowledge about the mind: From cognitive connections to mental representations. , 1988 .

[14]  Alison Gopnik,et al.  Children's understanding of representational change and its relation to the understanding of false belief and the appearance-reality distinction. , 1988 .

[15]  A. J. Caron,et al.  Infant discrimination of naturalistic emotional expressions: the role of face and voice. , 1988, Child development.

[16]  A. Gopnik,et al.  Children's understanding of representational change and its relation to the understanding of false belief and the appearance-reality distinction. , 1988, Child development.

[17]  H. Wellman,et al.  From simple desires to ordinary beliefs: The early development of everyday psychology , 1990, Cognition.

[18]  D. Zaitchik,et al.  When representations conflict with reality: The preschooler's problem with false beliefs and “false” photographs , 1990, Cognition.

[19]  P. Harris Children and Emotion: The Development of Psychological Understanding , 1991 .

[20]  D. Zaitchik Is only seeing really believing?: Sources of the true belief in the false belief task , 1991 .

[21]  S. Feinman Social Referencing and the Social Construction of Reality in Infancy , 1992 .

[22]  Alan M. Leslie,et al.  Domain specificity in conceptual development: Neuropsychological evidence from autism , 1992, Cognition.

[23]  F. Happé Communicative competence and theory of mind in autism: A test of relevance theory , 1993, Cognition.

[24]  Dare A. Baldwin,et al.  Infants' ability to consult the speaker for clues to word reference , 1993, Journal of Child Language.

[25]  J. Perner Understanding the Representational Mind , 1993 .

[26]  A. Leslie Mapping the mind: ToMM, ToBY, and Agency: Core architecture and domain specificity , 1994 .

[27]  S. Baron-Cohen How to build a baby that can read minds: Cognitive mechanisms in mindreading. , 1994 .

[28]  Richard S. J. Frackowiak,et al.  Other minds in the brain: a functional imaging study of “theory of mind” in story comprehension , 1995, Cognition.

[29]  Remo Guidieri Res , 1995, RES: Anthropology and Aesthetics.

[30]  M. Siegal,et al.  Deafness, conversation and theory of mind. , 1995, Journal of child psychology and psychiatry, and allied disciplines.

[31]  H. Wellman,et al.  Children Talk About the Mind , 1995 .

[32]  A. Meltzoff Understanding the Intentions of Others: Re-Enactment of Intended Acts by 18-Month-Old Children. , 1995, Developmental psychology.

[33]  H. Wellman,et al.  Early understanding of emotion: Evidence from natural language , 1995 .

[34]  J. Astington,et al.  Theory of mind development and social understanding. , 1995 .

[35]  M. Hallett,et al.  Modeling other minds , 1995, Neuroreport.

[36]  R. Andersen,et al.  Functional analysis of human MT and related visual cortical areas using magnetic resonance imaging , 1995, The Journal of neuroscience : the official journal of the Society for Neuroscience.

[37]  S. Stich,et al.  The Varieties of Off-Line Simulation , 1996 .

[38]  M. Just,et al.  Brain Activation Modulated by Sentence Comprehension , 1996, Science.

[39]  D. Dennett Kinds of Minds: Towards an Understanding of Consciousness , 1996 .

[40]  Katherine Nelson,et al.  Language In Cognitive Development , 1996 .

[41]  S. Carey,et al.  Whose gaze will infants follow? Features that elicit gaze-following in twelve-month-olds , 1996 .

[42]  M. Tomasello,et al.  Eighteen-month-old children learn words in non-ostensive contexts , 1996, Journal of Child Language.

[43]  T. Allison,et al.  Face-Specific Processing in the Human Fusiform Gyrus , 1997, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience.

[44]  György Gergely,et al.  Teleological reasoning in infancy: The infant's naive theory of rational action A reply to Premack and Premack , 1997, Cognition.

[45]  A. Gopnik,et al.  Early reasoning about desires: evidence from 14- and 18-month-olds. , 1997, Developmental psychology.

[46]  N. Kanwisher,et al.  The Fusiform Face Area: A Module in Human Extrastriate Cortex Specialized for Face Perception , 1997, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[47]  S. Baron-Cohen Mindblindness: An Essay on Autism and Theory of Mind , 1997 .

[48]  S. Wortham Language in Cognitive Development: Emergence of the Mediated Mind , 1998 .

[49]  J. Decety,et al.  Brain Regions Involved in the Perception of Gaze: A PET Study , 1998, NeuroImage.

[50]  M. Tomasello,et al.  Fourteen-through 18-month-old infants di eren-tially imitate intentional and accidental actions , 1998 .

[51]  A. Leslie,et al.  Inhibitory processing in the false belief task: Two conjectures , 1998 .

[52]  T. Allison,et al.  Temporal Cortex Activation in Humans Viewing Eye and Mouth Movements , 1998, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[53]  P. Whalen Fear, Vigilance, and Ambiguity , 1998 .

[54]  Jon Driver,et al.  Adult's Eyes Trigger Shifts of Visual Attention in Human Infants , 1998 .

[55]  A. Goldman,et al.  Mirror neurons and the simulation theory of mind-reading , 1998, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[56]  Egill Rostrup,et al.  Visual Activation in Infants and Young Children Studied by Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging , 1998, Pediatric Research.

[57]  M. Tomasello,et al.  Social cognition, joint attention, and communicative competence from 9 to 15 months of age. , 1998, Monographs of the Society for Research in Child Development.

[58]  S. Carey,et al.  Whose gaze will infants follow? The elicitation of gaze-following in 12-month-olds , 1998 .

[59]  Stephen Stich,et al.  Theory theory to the Max , 1998 .

[60]  A. Woodward Infants selectively encode the goal object of an actor's reach , 1998, Cognition.

[61]  Josef Perner,et al.  Executive functions and theory of mind: Cognitive complexity or functional dependence? , 1999 .

[62]  J. Dunn,et al.  Theory of mind, emotion understanding, language, and family background: individual differences and interrelations. , 1999, Child development.

[63]  M. Doherty,et al.  A New Look at Gaze: Preschool Children's Understanding of Eye-Direction , 1999 .

[64]  J. Decety,et al.  Neural mechanisms subserving the perception of human actions , 1999, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[65]  Jonathan D. Cohen,et al.  Conflict monitoring versus selection-for-action in anterior cingulate cortex , 1999, Nature.

[66]  J. Flavell,et al.  Cognitive development: children's knowledge about the mind. , 1999, Annual review of psychology.

[67]  Y. Miyashita,et al.  Common inhibitory mechanism in human inferior prefrontal cortex revealed by event-related functional MRI. , 1999, Brain : a journal of neurology.

[68]  J. Astington,et al.  A longitudinal study of the relation between language and theory-of-mind development. , 1999, Developmental psychology.

[69]  Jill de Villiers,et al.  Language and theory of mind: What are the developmental relationships? , 2000 .

[70]  A. Berti,et al.  The understanding of sadness, guilt, and shame in 5-, 7-, and 9-year-old children. , 2000, Genetic, social, and general psychology monographs.

[71]  P. Bloom How children learn the meanings of words , 2000 .

[72]  D. Perrett,et al.  Neural Representation for the Perception of the Intentionality of Actions , 2000, Brain and Cognition.

[73]  E. Halgren,et al.  Cognitive response profile of the human fusiform face area as determined by MEG. , 2000, Cerebral cortex.

[74]  J. Villiers,et al.  Linguistic determinism and the understanding of false beliefs. , 2000 .

[75]  C. Frith,et al.  Movement and Mind: A Functional Imaging Study of Perception and Interpretation of Complex Intentional Movement Patterns , 2000, NeuroImage.

[76]  K. Sullivan,et al.  A componential view of theory of mind: evidence from Williams syndrome , 2000, Cognition.

[77]  Michael Siegal,et al.  Evidence for cognition without grammar from causal reasoning and ‘theory of mind’ in an agrammatic aphasic patient , 2000, Current Biology.

[78]  P. Bloom,et al.  Two reasons to abandon the false belief task as a test of theory of mind , 2000, Cognition.

[79]  Joseph E LeDoux Emotion circuits in the brain. , 2009, Annual review of neuroscience.

[80]  Henry M. Wellman,et al.  Developing understandings of mind , 2000 .

[81]  A K Anderson,et al.  Contribution of the anteromedial temporal lobes to the evaluation of facial emotion. , 2000, Neuropsychology.

[82]  Kevin J. Riggs,et al.  Children's Reasoning and the Mind , 2000 .

[83]  U. Frith,et al.  The physiological basis of theory of mind: Functional neuroimaging studies. , 2000 .

[84]  Patrice D. Tremoulet,et al.  Perception of Animacy from the Motion of a Single Object , 2000, Perception.

[85]  J. Decety,et al.  A PET Investigation of the Attribution of Intentions with a Nonverbal Task , 2000, NeuroImage.

[86]  J. Haxby,et al.  The distributed human neural system for face perception , 2000, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[87]  J. Haxby,et al.  Distinct representations of eye gaze and identity in the distributed human neural system for face perception , 2000, Nature Neuroscience.

[88]  T. Allison,et al.  Social perception from visual cues: role of the STS region , 2000, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[89]  C. Frith,et al.  Reading the mind in cartoons and stories: an fMRI study of ‘theory of mind’ in verbal and nonverbal tasks , 2000, Neuropsychologia.

[90]  Susan C. Johnson The recognition of mentalistic agents in infancy , 2000, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[91]  S. Baron-Cohen,et al.  Is there an innate gaze module? Evidence from human neonates , 2000 .

[92]  J. Perner,et al.  Theory of mind and executive function: Is there a developmental relationship? , 2000 .

[93]  N. Cohen,et al.  The relative involvement of anterior cingulate and prefrontal cortex in attentional control depends on nature of conflict. , 2001, Brain research. Cognitive brain research.

[94]  J. Decety,et al.  Functional anatomy of execution, mental simulation, observation, and verb generation of actions: A meta‐analysis , 2001, Human brain mapping.

[95]  B. Scholl,et al.  Minds, modules, and meta-analysis. , 2001, Child development.

[96]  J. Decety,et al.  Effect of subjective perspective taking during simulation of action: a PET investigation of agency , 2001, Nature Neuroscience.

[97]  N. Sadato,et al.  Attention to emotion modulates fMRI activity in human right superior temporal sulcus. , 2001, Brain research. Cognitive brain research.

[98]  Bertram F. Malle,et al.  Folk explanations of intentional action. , 2001 .

[99]  Jodie A. Baird,et al.  Discerning intentions in dynamic human action , 2001, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[100]  M. Terwogt,et al.  Preschoolers' appreciation of uncommon desires and subsequent emotions , 2001 .

[101]  Jeffrey M. Zacks,et al.  Human brain activity time-locked to perceptual event boundaries , 2001, Nature Neuroscience.

[102]  Dare A. Baldwin,et al.  Intentions and Intentionality: Foundations of Social Cognition , 2001 .

[103]  J. Decety,et al.  From the perception of action to the understanding of intention , 2001, Nature reviews. Neuroscience.

[104]  H. Wellman,et al.  Thinking about the past: early knowledge about links between prior experience, thinking, and emotion. , 2001, Child development.

[105]  H. Wellman,et al.  Meta-analysis of theory-of-mind development: the truth about false belief. , 2001, Child development.

[106]  Daniel Houser,et al.  A functional imaging study of cooperation in two-person reciprocal exchange , 2001, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America.

[107]  G. Rizzolatti,et al.  Action observation activates premotor and parietal areas in a somatotopic manner: an fMRI study , 2001, The European journal of neuroscience.

[108]  K. Zilles,et al.  Mind Reading: Neural Mechanisms of Theory of Mind and Self-Perspective , 2001, NeuroImage.

[109]  Susan C. Johnson,et al.  Inferring the goals of a nonhuman agent , 2001 .

[110]  Stephen C. Want,et al.  Severe Impairment in Grammar Does Not Preclude Theory of Mind , 2001, Neurocase.

[111]  L J Moses,et al.  Executive accounts of theory-of-mind development. , 2001, Child development.

[112]  A D Friederici,et al.  Syntactic, Prosodic, and Semantic Processes in the Brain: Evidence from Event-Related Neuroimaging , 2001, Journal of psycholinguistic research.

[113]  Dare A. Baldwin,et al.  Evidence for referential understanding in the emotions domain at twelve and eighteen months. , 2001, Child development.

[114]  M. Bornstein,et al.  Longitudinal Relations Between 2-Year-Olds' Language and 4-Year-Olds' Theory of Mind , 2001 .

[115]  H. Wellman,et al.  Theory of mind and conceptual change. , 2001, Child development.

[116]  G. Rizzolatti,et al.  Neurophysiological mechanisms underlying the understanding and imitation of action , 2001, Nature Reviews Neuroscience.

[117]  Bertram F. Malle,et al.  The distinction between desire and intention: A folk-conceptual analysis , 2001 .

[118]  R. Adolphs The neurobiology of social cognition , 2001, Current Opinion in Neurobiology.

[119]  U. Frith Mind Blindness and the Brain in Autism , 2001, Neuron.

[120]  Emotion, Pragmatics and Social Understanding in the Preschool Years , 2001 .

[121]  J. Astington,et al.  The future of theory-of-mind research: understanding motivational states, the role of language, and real-world consequences. , 2001, Child development.

[122]  L. Moses,et al.  Individual differences in inhibitory control and children's theory of mind. , 2001, Child development.

[123]  Bruce D. McCandliss,et al.  Applications of magnetic resonance imaging to the study of development , 2001 .

[124]  T. Braver,et al.  Anterior cingulate cortex and response conflict: effects of frequency, inhibition and errors. , 2001, Cerebral cortex.

[125]  A. Young,et al.  Reading the mind from eye gaze , 2002, Neuropsychologia.

[126]  M. Corbetta,et al.  Two attentional processes in the parietal lobe. , 2002, Cerebral cortex.

[127]  A. Meltzoff,et al.  The importance of eyes: how infants interpret adult looking behavior. , 2002, Developmental psychology.

[128]  Jennie E. Pyers,et al.  Complements to cognition: a longitudinal study of the relationship between complex syntax and false-belief-understanding , 2002 .

[129]  A. Meltzoff,et al.  A PET Exploration of the Neural Mechanisms Involved in Reciprocal Imitation , 2002, NeuroImage.

[130]  J. Kagan,et al.  Temperament, tympanum, and temperature: four provisional studies of the biobehavioral correlates of tympanic membrane temperature asymmetries. , 2002, Child development.

[131]  Michael Siegal,et al.  Signposts to development: theory of mind in deaf children. , 2002, Child development.

[132]  A. Meltzoff,et al.  Does the End Justify the Means? A PET Exploration of the Mechanisms Involved in Human Imitation , 2002, NeuroImage.

[133]  John S Morrisj How do you feel? , 2002, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[134]  C. Frith,et al.  Autism, Asperger syndrome and brain mechanisms for the attribution of mental states to animated shapes. , 2002, Brain : a journal of neurology.

[135]  Abraham Z. Snyder,et al.  The Feasibility of a Common Stereotactic Space for Children and Adults in fMRI Studies of Development , 2002, NeuroImage.

[136]  Ivanei E. Bramati,et al.  The Neural Correlates of Moral Sensitivity: A Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging Investigation of Basic and Moral Emotions , 2002, The Journal of Neuroscience.

[137]  E. Robinson,et al.  Five-year-olds' handling of reference and description in the domains of language and mental representation. , 2002, Journal of experimental child psychology.

[138]  M. Chandler,et al.  Children's understanding of interpretation , 2002 .

[139]  P Vuilleumier,et al.  Neural response to emotional faces with and without awareness: event-related fMRI in a parietal patient with visual extinction and spatial neglect , 2002, Neuropsychologia.

[140]  S. Dehaene,et al.  Functional Neuroimaging of Speech Perception in Infants , 2002, Science.

[141]  F. Rösler,et al.  Brain Activation Modulated by the Comprehension of Normal and Pseudo-word Sentences of Different Processing Demands: A Functional Magnetic Resonance Imaging Study , 2002, NeuroImage.

[142]  B. Malle The relation between language and theory of mind in development and evolution , 2002 .

[143]  Evelyn C. Ferstl,et al.  What Does the Frontomedian Cortex Contribute to Language Processing: Coherence or Theory of Mind? , 2002, NeuroImage.

[144]  S. Preston,et al.  Empathy: Its ultimate and proximate bases. , 2001, The Behavioral and brain sciences.

[145]  Joshua D. Greene,et al.  How (and where) does moral judgment work? , 2002, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[146]  B. Everitt,et al.  Emotion and motivation: the role of the amygdala, ventral striatum, and prefrontal cortex , 2002, Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews.

[147]  M. Siegal,et al.  Neural systems involved in 'theory of mind' , 2002, Nature Reviews Neuroscience.

[148]  J. Downar,et al.  A cortical network sensitive to stimulus salience in a neutral behavioral context across multiple sensory modalities. , 2002, Journal of neurophysiology.

[149]  J. Haxby,et al.  Human neural systems for face recognition and social communication , 2002, Biological Psychiatry.

[150]  Rechele Brooks,et al.  Gaze following at 12 and 14 months: Do the eyes matter? , 2002 .

[151]  K. Bartsch The role of experience in children's developing folk epistemology: review and analysis from the theory–theory perspective , 2002 .

[152]  A. Nobre,et al.  The Response of Left Temporal Cortex to Sentences , 2002, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience.

[153]  R. Adolphs Neural systems for recognizing emotion , 2002, Current Opinion in Neurobiology.

[154]  M. Corbetta,et al.  Neural Systems for Visual Orienting and Their Relationships to Spatial Working Memory , 2002, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience.

[155]  Christopher D. Frith,et al.  Imaging the Intentional Stance in a Competitive Game , 2002, NeuroImage.

[156]  J. O'Doherty,et al.  Automatic and intentional brain responses during evaluation of trustworthiness of faces , 2002, Nature Neuroscience.

[157]  H. Garavan,et al.  Dissociable Executive Functions in the Dynamic Control of Behavior: Inhibition, Error Detection, and Correction , 2002, NeuroImage.

[158]  C. Frith,et al.  Experiencing Oneself vs Another Person as Being the Cause of an Action: The Neural Correlates of the Experience of Agency , 2002, NeuroImage.

[159]  T. Canli,et al.  Neuroimaging of emotion and personality: Scientific evidence and ethical considerations , 2002, Brain and Cognition.

[160]  H. Wellman,et al.  Infants' ability to connect gaze and emotional expression to intentional action , 2002, Cognition.

[161]  J. Mazziotta,et al.  Modulation of motor and premotor activity during imitation of target-directed actions. , 2002, Cerebral cortex.

[162]  K. Doya,et al.  A unifying computational framework for motor control and social interaction. , 2003, Philosophical transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological sciences.

[163]  Marc Jeannerod,et al.  Modulating the experience of agency: a positron emission tomography study , 2003, NeuroImage.

[164]  D. Perrett,et al.  Being the target of another’s emotion: a PET study , 2003, Neuropsychologia.

[165]  Aina Puce,et al.  Electrophysiology and brain imaging of biological motion. , 2003, Philosophical transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological sciences.

[166]  T. Allison,et al.  Brain activation evoked by perception of gaze shifts: the influence of context , 2003, Neuropsychologia.

[167]  R. Blair,et al.  Facial expressions, their communicatory functions and neuro-cognitive substrates. , 2003, Philosophical transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological sciences.

[168]  Alan Garnham,et al.  How language relates to belief, desire, and emotion understanding , 2003 .

[169]  J. Decety,et al.  Neural correlates of feeling sympathy , 2003, Neuropsychologia.

[170]  M. Legerstee,et al.  Sharing attention and pointing to objects at 12 months: is the intentional stance implied? , 2003 .

[171]  N. Kanwisher,et al.  Common Neural Substrates for Response Selection across Modalities and Mapping Paradigms , 2003, Journal of Cognitive Neuroscience.

[172]  Albert Gjedde,et al.  Emotional valence modulates activity in the posterior fusiform gyrus and inferior medial prefrontal cortex in social perception , 2003, NeuroImage.

[173]  R Saxe,et al.  People thinking about thinking people The role of the temporo-parietal junction in “theory of mind” , 2003, NeuroImage.

[174]  G. Csibra Teleological and referential understanding of action in infancy. , 2003, Philosophical transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological sciences.

[175]  J. Mazziotta,et al.  The essential role of Broca's area in imitation , 2003, The European journal of neuroscience.

[176]  V. Gallese The manifold nature of interpersonal relations: the quest for a common mechanism. , 2003, Philosophical transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological sciences.

[177]  Stephan Hamann,et al.  Nosing in on the emotional brain , 2003, Nature Neuroscience.

[178]  What Imitation Tells Us About Social Cognition , 2003 .

[179]  P. Skudlarski,et al.  The role of the fusiform face area in social cognition: implications for the pathobiology of autism. , 2003, Philosophical transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological sciences.

[180]  A. Meltzoff,et al.  What imitation tells us about social cognition: a rapprochement between developmental psychology and cognitive neuroscience. , 2003, Philosophical transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological sciences.

[181]  Thomas E. Nichols,et al.  Switching attention and resolving interference: fMRI measures of executive functions , 2003, Neuropsychologia.

[182]  C. Frith,et al.  Development and neurophysiology of mentalizing. , 2003, Philosophical transactions of the Royal Society of London. Series B, Biological sciences.

[183]  R. Adolphs Cognitive neuroscience: Cognitive neuroscience of human social behaviour , 2003, Nature Reviews Neuroscience.

[184]  C. Frith,et al.  Functional imaging of ‘theory of mind’ , 2003, Trends in Cognitive Sciences.

[185]  The role of eye-gaze in understanding other minds , 2003 .